News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Major Investor Sues Theranos by hkmurakami on Monday October 10, 2016 @07:31PM (#12680637)
Why is that weird? The photo choice manipulates the reader impression just as they intend.

Perhaps what you might mean is something like "disingenuous" or "biased" or "unethical"

Re:Major Investor Sues Theranos by alexqgb on Monday October 10, 2016 @09:08PM (#12681200)
Alternately, it reflects the tenor of the story and the facts it contains. You could say this is inappropriate editorializing, but that makes the obviously absurd implication that fraud is a neutral thing, and that there are many good kinds of fraud in additional to the bad ones.

If you're reporting clear facts about something unambiguously bad, then it's entirely appropriate for the supporting photographs to support the article.

Re:Major Investor Sues Theranos by djf1 on Monday October 10, 2016 @10:28PM (#12681481)
It's entirely appropriate for the supporting photographs to support the article, but that's not what the parent is questioning. If the news is based on facts, then the facts can speak for themselves. An unflattering photo does not support the article if the article is not related to how well the subject takes photos.
Re:Major Investor Sues Theranos by sangnoir on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @09:32AM (#12684178)
> If the news is based on facts, then the facts can speak for themselves

Photos, are not based on facts. There is no such thing as a 'neutral' photo - all photographs are editorialized. Timing, framing, composition, lighting, contrast are among the hundreds of variables that contribute to a photo. Most news organisation are well of this and they allow post-processing of photos (to different extents). I would say an unflattering photo goes well with an unflattering article.

Re:Major Investor Sues Theranos by alexqgb on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @01:47AM (#12682123)
If facts could speak for themselves you wouldn't need journalists to put them into words, photojournalists to render them in pictures, editors to package stories, and publishers to deliver them to millions.

Of course it's important for the people in that process to be judicious and scrupulous about their handling of the facts so they can deliver material that provides reliable impressions. But showing unflattering pictures of people found to have done seriously unflattering things isn't some egregious departure from these requirements. Indeed, to the extent that a picture can say a thousand words, it's a useful - and generally appreciated - bit of data compression.

Re:Major Investor Sues Theranos by djf1 on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @02:40AM (#12682259)
I think it's equivalent to ad hominem, pushing in a direction that should be irrelevant. This example isn't egregious (I didn't have any particular reaction to the picture, personally), but it's unsavory to attempt to build a negative association by spotlighting someone's unflattering physical characteristics.
Re:Major Investor Sues Theranos by DavidWanjiru on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @02:18AM (#12682195)
>If facts could speak for themselves, you wouldn't need a journalist to put them into words.

How would facts speak for themselves without being put into words by someone?

Re:Major Investor Sues Theranos by 36bydesign on Monday October 10, 2016 @11:14PM (#12681643)
So no photo is the way to go? Unless the article is about taking photos?
Re:Major Investor Sues Theranos by djf1 on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @12:52AM (#12681946)
I'm not sure how you came to that conclusion. I just took issue with the suggestion that an unflattering picture somehow supports an article about shady business practices.
Re:Major Investor Sues Theranos by Shivetya on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @07:27AM (#12683308)
I don't see the unflattering aspect here, to we want her perfectly done up with makeup and hair? that too would insinuate a disconnect from common people. in the picture I saw my take away was she was trying to explain a situation and nicely at that.

is this all a male perception of a problem they fully do not understand and therefor think they know how its perceived by the opposite sex?

Re:Major Investor Sues Theranos by djf1 on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @02:56AM (#12690868)
To be clear, I have no opinion about this photo (see my other comments on this thread). * Original commenter highlights their observation that the degree to which a photo is 'flattering' is correlated with the author's desired characterization of the story subject. * Child commenter responds that it is reasonable to attempt to sway the reader's opinion by including an unflattering photo. * I respond that I don't think this is fair.

The question related to gender seems to be somewhat out-of-left-field

Re:Major Investor Sues Theranos by stonemetal on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @08:29AM (#12683711)
The exact same argument applies to any photo: If the news is based on facts, then the facts can speak for themselves. A photo does not support the article if the article is not related to how well the subject takes photos.
Re:Major Investor Sues Theranos by djf1 on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @03:01AM (#12690881)
My claim may have been somewhat unclear. More precisely... a photo that is intended to portray the subject's physical characteristics in a negative light has no place supporting an article about the subject's non-physical characteristics. Photos are great for adding informational content to new stories (e.g. http://cdn.abclocal.go.com/content/wabc/images/cms/1408319_1...).
Re:Major Investor Sues Theranos by dagw on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @05:02AM (#12682684)
No, but if all you really want to do is add some visuals and show what the CEO of the company looks like, why not just grab the default portrait photo from the company press pack?
Re:Major Investor Sues Theranos by briandear on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @06:07AM (#12682891)
And that photo isn't a manipulation? The press kit photos are designed specifically to portray executives in a competent, flattering light. THAT is manipulation of an even more devious sort -- if the company is doing something wrong, showing smiling, in-control executives when that isn't reality -- that's public relations, not Journalism; it misleads the public in drawing a conclusion of trustworthiness when that isn't warranted by the story.
Re:Major Investor Sues Theranos by camillomiller on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @01:29AM (#12682065)
As a journalist, I disagree. In this case the technique is used more to portray the way Holmes is perceived publicly (a "neurotic and delusional powerful woman out of control" -- not my opinion, just what the photo conveys), than to add a spin to a story that's already independently and factually spun in a very clear direction.

The use FoxNews does of this photo-picking with President Obama or liberal politicians is much worse. Or check the tabloids, they're masters at that.

This one? Just fine. I also want to point out that the picture is all but an outtake. Photography agencies publish photos like this on their online collections all the time, they won't discard them. Exactly because they know outlets may pick them for a story where they would fit.

Re:Major Investor Sues Theranos by NumberCruncher on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @02:56AM (#12682298)
>>As a journalist, I disagree. In this case the technique is used more to portray the way Holmes is perceived publicly

As a non journalist this is what I call manipulation.

Re:Major Investor Sues Theranos by celticninja on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @03:27AM (#12682398)
Then so is the text.
Re:Major Investor Sues Theranos by johncolanduoni on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @05:19AM (#12682737)
Do you feel picking a photo to match the caption is more manipulative than picking a caption to match the photo?
Re:Major Investor Sues Theranos by conjectures on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @04:19AM (#12682560)
> the way Holmes is perceived publicly

...which presumably is almost entirely based on what they read or see in the media?

Re:Major Investor Sues Theranos by camillomiller on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @05:08AM (#12682703)
Do you know any other way of forming a public opinion about someone you've never met and probably never will?
Re:Major Investor Sues Theranos by pavs on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @12:58PM (#12686181)
There is a difference between news reporting and manipulating public perception. Let the public make up their mind, just give them the dry facts.
Re:Major Investor Sues Theranos by conjectures on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @07:34AM (#12683344)
Nope, which is exactly why I expressed a high level of certainty in my earlier statement.
Re:Major Investor Sues Theranos by smegel on Monday October 10, 2016 @08:01PM (#12680834)
> "disingenuous" or "biased" or "unethical"

Mainstream journalism will also do just fine.

Re:Major Investor Sues Theranos by M_Grey on Monday October 10, 2016 @08:38PM (#12681057)
Implying that once outside of the "mainstream" journalistic integrity suddenly improves?

Nonsense.

Re:Major Investor Sues Theranos by logicallee on Monday October 10, 2016 @10:02PM (#12681387)
But it does. We (readers here, you, me, etc) are far outside of mainstream at this news site, HN, and journalistic standards are much higher. When you go from default subreddits to niche ones, the journalidtic integrity improves substantially. Yes, yes, once outside the mainstream, integrity suddenly improves, across the board.
Re:Major Investor Sues Theranos by M_Grey on Monday October 10, 2016 @10:03PM (#12681390)
We're not journalists, this is not a journalistic outlet.
Re:Major Investor Sues Theranos by logicallee on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @04:28AM (#12682587)
I'm just going to go ahead and disagree. This is journalism and news in 2016. (I'm also including people's blog write-ups that they or others submit.) On tech and fundraising issues, I'd say HN and yhe niche blog posts submitted, do count for a kind of journalism.
Re:Major Investor Sues Theranos by M_Grey on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @10:54AM (#12684922)
Only by throwing the definition of the word out the window to make a point, could that possibly fly.
Re:Major Investor Sues Theranos by logicallee on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @11:57AM (#12685587)
Fair enough. there's no good word for people giving lots of facts in a blogpost that is meant to be informative, open to comments, includes updates and good-faith efforts to be informative and correct. it may not be journalism, but people read these blog posts and these posts have huge weight. I don't think there's historical precedent for this kind of self-publishing, so not sure the terminology has caught up, but I'll concede your point regarding the specific term 'journalism'.

Would you include in 'journalism' very badly-written articles that are done by a writer collecting or reporting on sources (example: reporting on a tweet and its responses), while using horrific grammar and being very low-quality? You know the kind of link-bait 'articles' I'm talking about - I wonder if you would consider that part of journalism or not.

Re:Major Investor Sues Theranos by mozumder on Monday October 10, 2016 @10:50PM (#12681557)
> HN, and journalistic standards are much higher.

Mainstream media has FAR higher journalistic standards than independent media.

Major media sites have volumes of books that their reporters follow for their editorial process. AP has a style guide you can buy (and vet).

Independent media follow no such journalistic rules.

Never trust independent media. Mainstream corporate media is far more trustworthy, since they are a known known.

It's such a fallacy to assume that just because it's independent that it's more trustworthy, when the exact opposite is true.

Re:Major Investor Sues Theranos by nickpsecurity on Monday October 10, 2016 @11:22PM (#12681664)
You just argued that mainstream media has rules, that they problems they bring in are well-understood, and independent media is untrustworthy. You provided evidence for two of them. You did not in any way show mainstream media to be more trustworthy than independent media. If anything, they're clearly not due to all the times they've been caught manipulating their audiences, lying, or even justifying a right to lie. They're both untrustworthy and consistently subversive in how they do things.

So, the proper response is to do just what honest journalists or even agents in intelligence collection are taught to do: use diverse sources, rate their integrity, identify their biases, and merge them in a way that accounts for the two. It's what I have to do if I rely on the mainstream sources. It's been clear on a regular basis that their goal is to hold interest of specific demographics to keep them looking at ads rather than inform them. They're also very prone to self-censorship of anything that gets in the way of that due to cash flow.

Re:Major Investor Sues Theranos by mozumder on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @03:46AM (#12682464)
> So, the proper response is to do just what honest journalists or even agents in intelligence collection are taught to do: use diverse sources, rate their integrity, identify their biases, and merge them in a way that accounts for the two.

That's pretty much what mainstream media does. That's why you see major investigative articles with lots and lots of cross-referenced sources.

You know about the Theranos fraud because mainstream media, The Wall Street Journal - the largest newspaper in the country - thoroughly exposed them.

Did you thank mainstream media for their work?

Re:Major Investor Sues Theranos by nickpsecurity on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @11:35AM (#12685343)
"That's pretty much what mainstream media does. That's why you see major investigative articles with lots and lots of cross-referenced sources."

This is not what the mainstream media does. What it does is start with the biases and goals of the organization that targets the beliefs and wants of particular viewers. The journalists will have run into this trying to get things by editors in the past. Then, they'll begin on their peace which may use any combination of sources to support its claims with little presented for alternative opinions. They even like to cite "anonymous sources" to push total bullshit. They'll then present the story.

Sometimes I see well-researched stories that cover most odds and ends. Most of the time I see them reporting whatever they saw or heard from one source with their own slant. The funny thing about your comments is that even most viewers of these organizations I run into know they're extremely biased. They'll say "What else do you expect from (Huffington Post or Fox News here)? They always push that (liberal/conservative) BS!" They just think the bias of their preferred outlet is correct most of the time. Of course, that's all the info they see too. ;)

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Echo_chamber_(media)

Re:Major Investor Sues Theranos by mozumder on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @01:29PM (#12686502)
Why would anyone support independent media's biases over mainstream media's biases?

So I take it you don't want to thank mainstream media for uncovering the Theranos fraud?

Re:Major Investor Sues Theranos by nickpsecurity on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @03:40PM (#12687851)
Because mainstream media's biases are beholden to the companies and government people causing us many problems. They also self-suppress critical stuff that could result in reform if it had people's attention. They also have this weird habit of running and heavily covering shock stories when critical legislation or business events are happening, making citizens miss the chance to act on it.

A media more independent from corporate and government interests would have less of these issues. Especially suppression. Then it's just a matter of gauging accuracy and bias of each.

Re:Major Investor Sues Theranos by mozumder on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @05:28PM (#12688661)
And yet, it was mainstream media that exposed the Theranos fraud.

You're welcome.

Re:Major Investor Sues Theranos by nickpsecurity on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @06:42PM (#12689122)
I didnt say they do nothing of benefit. I use them since they're most of what we have. Your claim also doesnt counter mine in any way. Large, well-funded, independent media wouldve done the same thing if we had that instead. Further, it would be more likely as MSM continues to shift from journalism to just sharing anything that will get views. Most MSM just copies stories of relatively few journalists since that generates the most ad revenue at the lowest cost.
Re:Major Investor Sues Theranos by briandear on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @06:13AM (#12682916)
I agree on the independent-trustworthy fallacy. Many 'independent' journalists are highly dependent on foundation grants or other funding from some rather biased billionaires. NPR is listener (and taxpayer) funded. Since the majority of the listeners are of a certain political party, it follows that NPR won't challenge the orthodoxy of the hands that feed them.
Re:Major Investor Sues Theranos by harry8 on Monday October 10, 2016 @09:19PM (#12681238)
Implying that staying inside the "mainstream" journalistic integrity suddenly improving is a false assumption.

I don't know that I agree with it, but it's a valid opinion to have that mainstream is no better than elsewhere.

Re:Major Investor Sues Theranos by M_Grey on Monday October 10, 2016 @09:58PM (#12681369)
I addressed someone's implication, I didn't offer one of my own.
Re:Major Investor Sues Theranos by harry8 on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @08:17AM (#12692139)
And my interpretation of their implication differed to yours, as I explained.