News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Future of Computer Science, and Why Every Other Major... by jerf on Thursday April 15, 2010 @10:35AM (#1267887)
I went through a period where I worried a bit about that, but I've stopped. Regardless of how bioinformatics is structured politically, there's either going to be heavy CS involvement or, well, trouble.

The thing is, in general, a "person" might be able to hack together a small program that works for a particular problem most of the time, but it takes a computer expert to create a program that works essentially all the time, with good performance and strong reliability. If someone in the biology department is capable of doing that, it's probably because they're a "double-major", for some value of the term. A normal biology education will leave them unprepared, and trying to hack together a strong understanding of OpenMPI or something is certainly _possible_ but also extremely likely to leave gaping holes in their education. (Even if one has the brains to become both a biology expert and a parallel computing expert, one must question if that's necessarily the best use of one's time.)

CS keeps making it easier to write programs, but the cutting edge will remain CS's domain for a long time, and academia for some crazy reason tends to like the cutting edge. As specialization continues its march onward it will continue to become more and more difficult to be an expert in both $FIELD and computer science.

Re:The Future of Computer Science, and Why Every Other Major... by etal on Thursday April 15, 2010 @02:21PM (#1268491)
This viewpoint seems to go against the HN zeitgeist -- a lot of programmers are self-taught, especially in the sciences. Just by necessity, students in molecular biology and genetics learn some scripting and how to push data around on the command line, and from that point a fair number of them really get into it and start studying the finer points of software engineering on their own.

(NB: Nearly everyone in bioinformatics has to accept some gaping holes in their education -- who has time to become an expert in each of biochemistry, medicine, computer science, and statistics?)

Re:The Future of Computer Science, and Why Every Other Major... by mattrepl on Thursday April 15, 2010 @12:26PM (#1268175)
There will be CS influence in informatics and data science, but I'm guessing the influence will come from individuals with CS backgrounds rather than CS departments. These individuals will leave CS departments to join other departments involved in domain-specific data science or more formal data analysis and learning methods (e.g., statistics).

The modern field of CS is too broad for a single department. Perhaps more universities will follow CMU, creating a school of computer science with specialized departments. Until then, expect to see CS undergrads and Master's students involved in informatics/ML joining non-CS Ph.D. programs.