News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Natural Law for Rotating Galaxies: What Does This Mean ... by michaelrccurtis on Monday October 10, 2016 @04:59AM (#12675936)
It always depresses me (as an astrophysicist) how poor the communication is on dark matter, and this leads people to unfair conclusions. We have known for some time about the limitations of our understanding of gravitational dynamics in extreme environments - the issue is not that "our theories must be right", it's that we have to square General Relativity (which is phenomenally well tested in other regimes) with the results we see. There are broadly 2 different ways of doing this: you can postulate that not all particles interact with electromagnetic radiation (after all, why should they?) or you can come how add extra terms into your gravitational laws.

Both of these have been tried, but there are many reasons why the majority of astrophysicists prefer the dark matter approach. Firstly, there are observations which suggest large regions of mass that are not aligned with the visible mass (e.g. the bullet cluster). Secondly, dark matter can explain the statistical properties of the Cosmic Microwave Background radiation in a way that can not be achieved with ordinary matter alone. Thirdly, when we include dark matter in simulations, we get results that are a very good match for the universe as we observe it. etc. etc. If that weren't enough, we know that there are plenty of types of matter that are dark - e.g. neutrinos, early black holes etc. Whilst none of these have yet satisfied the conditions for dark matter as we understand it, it's perfectly possible that we have already identified some of the constituent parts, and there is a list of potential candidates as long as my arm that the particle physicists are working their way through.

Finally, the biggest annoyance is the intimation that we are all just one big cabal. Let me put it like this: if you could provide indisputable evidence that dark matter was wrong, you would be a superstar in our field and everyone would be phenomenally excited, because it would demand the hunt for new physics. Scientists are a rational bunch, however, so any evidence must be weighed against the existing evidence already observed (which, as above, is substantial).

Dark energy is slightly different. No one know's what this is, but models with a dark energy component do very well at modelling the universe. The question is, why? No one is pretending that this is a solved question, but what we do know is that whatever is driving the universe's accelerated expansion has properties that are very similar to what dark energy is.

tldr: There are loads of great reasons for thinking dark matter exists, contrary to many posters here, and it is well accepted that dark energy is a mathematical term that represents something of unknown physical origin.

Re:A Natural Law for Rotating Galaxies: What Does This Mean ... by cygx on Monday October 10, 2016 @06:22AM (#12676204)
Personally, I'm interested to see what happens to conformal gravity. The theory is able to fit galactic rotation curves without a need for dark matter[1], but supposedly leads to inconsistent results when trying to do the same for gravitational lensing[2]. However, that might have been an artifact of incorrect approximations and the calculations should be repeated using exact solutions[3].

[1] https://arxiv.org/abs/1011.3495

[2] https://arxiv.org/abs/1403.7930

[3] https://arxiv.org/abs/1609.07633

Re:A Natural Law for Rotating Galaxies: What Does This Mean ... by phkahler on Monday October 10, 2016 @11:31AM (#12677628)
I keep seeing a couple problems in this whole discussion.

Number one is the continued references to Keplers laws. Kepler only applies to 2-body systems where the mass of one is dramatically larger than the other. This works well for the solar system, where the sun is huge compared to the planets and the planets have little effect on each other. But do note that some planets were predicted to exist based on their effect on the orbits of other planets, so even in this sparse system the effects do make a difference. My point is that Kepler has no place in galactic dynamics but is often referenced - if that were the model that doesn't match observation then DUH! But the physicists are smarter than that.

Second, I occasionally see mis-application of the divergence theorem and/or gauss's law. Some folks seem to treat a portion of a galaxy out to a radius R as a point mass by using this theorem. The problem of course is that to make that leap you must have a uniform spherical distribution of matter inside the spherical boundary. In other words, a disk-like distribution of matter does not have a uniform gravitational pull at all points of distance R from its center. You'll find it is stronger near the edge of the disk than at the same distance perpendicular to it.

Third, this particular article keeps making reference to the "radial velocity" or speed of stars where I believe they are actually talking about the orbital or tangential velocity.

And lastly, if the dark matter obeys the same laws of gravitation, there must be a reason for its distribution to be different than the other matter. At that point, I don't see any need for "strange dark matter" or new particles or physics. You really can't have it both ways - it's fundamentally different, yet it obeys the same rules. Having said that, I could see how exploding stars would spread non-visible matter (remnant material) in a way that might be very different from the stars themselves.

Re:A Natural Law for Rotating Galaxies: What Does This Mean ... by Keysh on Monday October 10, 2016 @11:56AM (#12677837)
In other words, a disk-like distribution of matter does not have a uniform gravitational pull at all points of distance R from its center. You'll find it is stronger near the edge of the disk than at the same distance perpendicular to it.

But stars (and gas clouds) orbiting in a disk are essentially always "near the edge" of the disk (that is, the disk defined as matter interior to the orbit in question), so the approximation is usually pretty good.

reference to the "radial velocity" or speed of stars where I believe they are actually talking about the orbital or tangential velocity.

The (understandable!) confusion originates because "radial" and "tangential" refer, in an observational sense, to velocities along or perpendicular to the line-of-sight vector. To simplify a bit: for observations of astronomical objects, velocities along the line of sight from you to the object (detectable from Doppler shifts in its light) are "radial", while velocities perpendicular to the line of sight (which require that you wait long enough to see things change position on the sky) are "tangential". For edge-on spiral galaxies, the orbital motions that we can observe are those producing Doppler shifts along the line of sight (which are, in the frame of the galaxy, "orbital or tangential", as you suggest).

And lastly, if the dark matter obeys the same laws of gravitation, there must be a reason for its distribution to be different than the other matter.

The usual argument is that dark matter is "non-dissipative" -- that is, it can't lose orbital energy via things like radiation, the way ordinary matter in the form of gas can. (And, unlike gas, it doesn't feel pressure forces.) Stars are also non-dissipative, but stars form out of gas, so their distribution reflects the effects of dissipation in ways that dark matter can't.

Re:A Natural Law for Rotating Galaxies: What Does This Mean ... by phkahler on Monday October 10, 2016 @12:31PM (#12678103)
>> But stars (and gas clouds) orbiting in a disk are essentially always "near the edge" of the disk (that is, the disk defined as matter interior to the orbit in question), so the approximation is usually pretty good.

Not sure we're on the same page. For a star orbiting at radius r on a disk of radius R, some folks will lump all mass inside r into a point and apply keplers laws. They will reject all the mass between r and R because of the same surface integral theorems. The problem is that neither of those assumptions are anywhere near correct. The pull from the interior <r mass is not the same as though it were a point, and the pull from the outer mass >r is very much non-zero. For an example using electric charge instead of gravity:

http://www.phys.uri.edu/gerhard/PHY204/tsl34.pdf

Note that the field is non-zero at most places inside the ring, however it would be zero over the entire volume if it were a spherical distribution.

Re:A Natural Law for Rotating Galaxies: What Does This Mean ... by Keysh on Monday October 10, 2016 @01:06PM (#12678374)
Ah, I thought you were making some special argument about stars orbiting with very tilted orbits or something like that.

Yes, the orbits within the inner part of a galaxy don't follow a Keplerian curve. However, at large radii most of the visible matter is well inside the orbit and very little is outside (galaxies are quite centrally concentrated), so the rotation curve should approach the Keplerian limit as you go to larger and larger radii. The fact that it doesn't is one of the primary pieces of evidence for dark matter in galaxies (though not the only one).

(I'm not sure why you linked to that slide, since it's not calculating the field in the plane of the ring, nor is it dealing with a continuous charge distribution. Regardless, you'll note that E_x goes to 1/x^2 for x >> a, which is a "Keplerian" limit.)

Re:A Natural Law for Rotating Galaxies: What Does This Mean ... by phkahler on Monday October 10, 2016 @04:12PM (#12679485)
>> so the rotation curve should approach the Keplerian limit...

I don't agree. If we treat the galaxy as a bunch of concentric rings, many of them are nowhere near far enough away to reach that "Keplerian" limit.

As an experiment I modeled a flat disk of uniformly distributed stars. Without doing a dynamic simulation one can do the n-body calculation to determine the total pull on each star and determine what its orbital velocity must be to go in a circular orbit. You find that the "galactic rotation curve" will have a velocity that actually increases all the way to the edge. Of course a uniform distribution is not what a real galaxy looks like, but I think we can all agree reality is somewhere between the uniform flat disk and the highly concentrated central mass. And the actual rotation curves are somewhere between Keplers and mine. I'd expect people to work backward from the rotation curves to determine the mass distribution and then try to understand why that isn't what is observed. I suppose that's just a different way to get at the same mystery.