News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Natural Law for Rotating Galaxies: What Does This Mean ... by madaxe_again on Monday October 10, 2016 @04:56AM (#12675919)
It's not actually clear that there is any problem with current theory - it may just be that our understanding and application of it is incorrect. You can have a perfect mathematical model, but if just one of your premises is incorrect, the output can be nonsensical.

I am a physicist (well, I studied as one, before going technology entrepreneur), and have always sat in the "dark matter is bullshit" camp - so my opinion is likely tainted.

I think a far more likely explanation, as this paper could suggest, is that something far more mundane is happening.

For instance, we already understand tidal forces - that bodies can become tidally locked, that there is an inertial frame shear that drags bodies along around a rotating centre of mass, and exchanges energy between an orbiting body and the centre.... So why is it infeasible that galaxies are tidally locked, and the lack of fall-off in radial velocity is down to the gravitational shear from the galactic core being far more intense than we anticipate, causing the behaviour we see. It doesn't require a rewrite of relativity, "just" of galactic evolution.

Either that, or galaxies are sprites, and lazily rendered ones, at that.

Re:A Natural Law for Rotating Galaxies: What Does This Mean ... by kmm on Monday October 10, 2016 @10:38AM (#12677284)
> For instance, we already understand tidal forces - that bodies can become tidally locked, that there is an inertial frame shear that drags bodies along around a rotating centre of mass, and exchanges energy between an orbiting body and the centre.... So why is it infeasible that galaxies are tidally locked, and the lack of fall-off in radial velocity is down to the gravitational shear from the galactic core being far more intense than we anticipate, causing the behaviour we see. It doesn't require a rewrite of relativity, "just" of galactic evolution.

Because someone has indubitably already ran the numbers. The tidal force only has a non central, orbit changing influence on spatially extended bodies, and its effects even on objects as large as our solar system are completely negligible, as it doesn't seem to have a measurable effect on the orbits of the planets. The rotation curves are way off, which is a huge chunk of excess angular momentum that no tidal force can conjure. Where would it even come from, the rotational angular momentum of component stars?

Re:A Natural Law for Rotating Galaxies: What Does This Mean ... by madaxe_again on Thursday October 13, 2016 @04:22AM (#12699281)
You're aware that mercury is tidally locked, as is our moon, mars' moons, and others? I would call those real, physical effects, not negligible.

As to running the numbers - agreed - but one can get an answer which is correct but incorrect if your premises are incorrect.

At a galactic scale the perturbations are likely tiny, but a tiny force applied over enough time adds up.

Anyway. It's a poor example that's almost certainly wrong but my point was more about how a single incorrect assumption can wreck a model.

Re:A Natural Law for Rotating Galaxies: What Does This Mean ... by dnautics on Monday October 10, 2016 @06:25AM (#12676219)
I've half joked that dark matter might be cumulative IEEE floating point rounding errors.
Re:A Natural Law for Rotating Galaxies: What Does This Mean ... by adrianN on Monday October 10, 2016 @08:07AM (#12676565)
I hope God doesn't use IEEE floats.
Re:A Natural Law for Rotating Galaxies: What Does This Mean ... by aminorex on Monday October 10, 2016 @08:45AM (#12676719)
A Catholic one would.