Re:How Hacker News can be improved, 3 things
by jsnell on Saturday October 08, 2016 @12:36AM
(#12665700)
I don't think whybroke was being entirely truthful. Downvoting is already disabled for comments older than a day.
Preventing upvoting of old comments would kind of suck, sometimes you only see really great comments years after they were posted.
Re:How Hacker News can be improved, 3 things
by whybroke on Saturday October 08, 2016 @01:37AM
(#12665820)
Perhaps so, I did not screenshot the posts of the last week. Certainly scores that were very positive yesterday are now negative. And certainly it began immediately after a post to wikipedia's marginal utility page which apparently disturbed someone's ideology. And it seems to have been aggravated further by this[1] post.
But perhaps this is desired result. Either way the issue is no longer interesting to me.
Re:How Hacker News can be improved, 3 things
by noobermin on Saturday October 08, 2016 @01:21PM
(#12667736)
Not sure about what you're saying about last week's comments but I have experienced a day or so after a less popular comment I receive downvotes on other comments after that for what I consider less controversial comments. Could be selection bias. What I usually see though is that upvotes and downvotes tend to average to where they would have been otherwise even in those cases overtime. I just miss out on extra karma I suppose :)
I would suggest disabling voting from profile comment pages, to avoid voting on comments without reading their context, but this is Hacker News, and it would be trivial to script that...