Re:To Improve Fitness, Try Sleep
by suckafree on Wednesday April 14, 2010 @07:28PM
(#1266447)
If all studies were based on such small sample sizes as this, then we'd all be in a world of hurt. I'm very surprised it got approved for publishing.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:To Improve Fitness, Try Sleep
by corruption on Wednesday April 14, 2010 @07:43PM
(#1266486)
If all laymen knew that n is irrelevant, it's the effect size that matters, we would be in a world of good.
If the difference between means is large compared to the standard deviation of the population under study, you need less n.
Another fun fact: All groups are different given large enough n.
Edit: I'm not endorsing the study - just pointing out that n should not be the most critical thing you look for when evaluating a study. The study is fine as a simple quasi-experiment, testing the hypothesis by induction. I don't see anyone claiming causal links here. Now a study testing the hypothesis deductively needs to be designed.
Thank you for body slamming me. But in a nice way. I stand corrected.
I think the school, that conducted the study had some effect on it being published.
I don't suspect any school below a rank of 15 would be taken seriously.