News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Are Politicians So Obsessed with Manufacturing? by JDiculous on Thursday October 06, 2016 @01:37AM (#12650448)
How do we fix this?

Here's an idea - direct democracy where one can only vote on a topic that he/she has proven a minimal set of competence in. This could be in the form of an exam on a topic (eg. economics) and/or logic test. The goal is that one should not be allowed to vote on something like climate change without knowing the science and data behind climate change.

We need to acknowledge that the world is too complex for one person to know what's best for everyone on every single topic. Our system of representatives is totally outdated now that we have the internet.

The beauty of direct democracy is that it removes the politicians. As long as there are politicians, there will always be corruption (eg. bribery).

Ideally of course we'd have AI deciding our best course of action because humans are inherently biased, but that's further down the road.

Re:Why Are Politicians So Obsessed with Manufacturing? by Broken_Hippo on Thursday October 06, 2016 @04:56AM (#12651051)
Corruption is one of those things that probably isn't going away any time soon: It isn't just a plague on politicians, but other areas of life as well. Businesses, etc.

And unfortunately, you have to have someone produce those voting tests. How do you think they will get their positions? Do you think that the tests in states such as Utah will have the same sort of things as tests in California or Vermont? In your version of the system, the politicians have simply changed professions.

Besides, there is actual need for politicians at this point (the AI still seems pretty far out). It is good to have someone to organize large infrastructure projects, good to have folks handle money and dividing it up, overseeing military operations - and it is good to have folks outside some of the industries asking questions and learning and trying different solutions.

Corruption itself won't go away any time soon: The best we've been able to do is minimize it.

Re:Why Are Politicians So Obsessed with Manufacturing? by JDiculous on Thursday October 06, 2016 @03:00PM (#12655100)
I'm not saying that every decision must be handled by the entire voting populace, just that we need to embrace a more issue-focused mindset and acknowledge that the world is too complex for one person to know what's best on every policy stance.

The test should be on the federal level (knowledge is universal), and wouldn't be designed by politicians. The tests should be very very basic and test a minimal level of understanding. For example you should be able to explain what the Fed does if you were voting on an issue pertaining to monetary policy. The questions would be as objective as possible.

Yes we may still need politicians, but again the main idea is that we seek to have people only working on matters they're qualified for rather than some jack of all trades who's supposed to have the country's answers on everything. Military operations would be handled by military personnel, housing policy would be designed by experts in housing policy, energy and climate change issues would be designed by experts in those fields, foreign policy would be dictated by foreign policy experts, etc.

Could this new system be a slippery slope? Are there other problems? Of course. But our current system is failing - just look at the presidential "debates", they're a complete laughingstock. We need to try to figure out how to improve this broken system rather than keep perpetuating the status quo.

I'd love to hear your ideas on how we could improve things.

Re:Why Are Politicians So Obsessed with Manufacturing? by maverick_iceman on Thursday October 06, 2016 @02:32AM (#12650627)
This is an extremely naive view. The sort of direct democracy you propose will most likely end up systematically discriminating against various groups.

>As long as there are politicians, there will always be corruption

Corruption is unlikely to go away with politicians, my guess is that it'll be there as long as human nature stays the same.

>Ideally of course we'd have AI deciding our best course of action because humans are inherently biased

AI can be as biased as the training data you feed it.

Re:Why Are Politicians So Obsessed with Manufacturing? by JDiculous on Thursday October 06, 2016 @03:04PM (#12655138)
What's your solution?

I'm not claiming that this idea isn't without its flaws. Our current system is just such an inefficient laughingstock that we need to be seeking to improve it.

Of course corruption will most likely persist under any system. The goal is to minimize it. The purpose of my proposal would be to make us make more informed policy decisions and incentive society and the media to focus on the issues.

Re:Why Are Politicians So Obsessed with Manufacturing? by chillacy on Thursday October 06, 2016 @02:47AM (#12650670)
> one should not be allowed to vote on something like climate change without knowing the science and data behind climate change

Okay, so in states where the majority don't believe in climate change and evolution, you'll have them design tests to exclude voters who believe in evolution/climate change from voting?

> This could be in the form of an exam on a topic (eg. economics) and/or logic test

We already have a long history of stifling voting rights: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voting_rights_in_the_United_St...

Some that stood out:

* Poll tax prevented the poor from voting * At one point, religious tests prevented non-christians from voting * Literacy tests prevented blacks from voting

Re:Why Are Politicians So Obsessed with Manufacturing? by JDiculous on Thursday October 06, 2016 @03:23PM (#12655293)
The tests should be as objective and unbiased as possible. Yes one can never remove 100% of bias, that doesn't mean we shouldn't do anything at all.

Remember, the whole point is to only have people qualified on a topic voting on said topic.

So if you're voting on, say, the minimum wage, you should be familiar with the economic ramifications of it. You should be familiar with both the arguments and counter-arguments, and perhaps the general consensus of economists.

If you're voting on trade policy, you should know the economic ramifications of a tariff. You should probably know the history of our positions on trade as well.

If you're voting on some issue related to the national debt, you should know the difference between a country's debt and household debt. You should probably also know the role of the Fed as well and how it relates to this.

The tests should be on a federal level because knowledge is universal. I'm really surprised that you and the other commenter implied that these tests would be on a state basis, and am curious as to what made you guys think that.

> We already have a long history of stifling voting rights

Poll taxes and religious tests are totally irrelevant. Literacy tests are sort of comparable to what I'm proposing, but I wouldn't advocate literacy tests because I don't care if you can't speak English if you know what you're talking about. Again, the main idea is that only people qualified on a specific issue should be voting on said issue.

Or maybe I should propose it from this angle - we should institute direct democracy instead of our current republic system due to the reasons I outlined in my original post. Direct democracy however has some glaring flaws (mainly that most people are too stupid and emotional), and the solution I propose seeks to rectify the glaring problem with direct democracy.

Re:Why Are Politicians So Obsessed with Manufacturing? by chillacy on Monday October 10, 2016 @10:34PM (#12681499)
> knowledge is universal

But it isn't... take your example on economy. In the last hundred years people tried out all sorts of things with the guidance of experts, from market economies, planned ones like communism, globalism, and now economists are shifting their thinking on that too. The chances that we're right about all that today are pretty slim too. In 10, 20 years economic thought will have shifted elsewhere. That's a mere 2-4 election cycles.

> If you're voting on trade policy, you should know the economic ramifications of a tariff. You should probably know the history of our positions on trade as well.

Isn't that why we have a representative democracy? And even those who govern look to advisors for these things anyways. I don't need to be micromanaging the government.

> So if you're voting on, say, the minimum wage, you should be familiar with the economic ramifications of it.

Does anyone know the economic ramifications with adjusting minimum wage? Seriously. We just did this in Seattle and there were experts arguing that it would destroy all the businesses in the area. That didn't actually happen: https://www.washingtonpost.com/posteverything/wp/2016/08/10/...

Turns out, people disagree about all sorts of things. Usually it helps to look at what people have to gain or lose. In the minimum wage case, business owners didn't want to raise their expenses. In your case, the more people you exclude from voting who disagree with you, the better chance your policy preferences come into play.

I'm not saying we shouldn't try to understand the choices we make through our voting decisions, but knowledge tests as a means to reduce.. "idiot voters" is just another way to exclude people who disagree with you from voting.

Re:Why Are Politicians So Obsessed with Manufacturing? by JDiculous on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @03:45PM (#12695910)
Our representative democracy is failing because the people in charge aren't the ones most qualified to answer all these questions - because jack of all trade politicians are tasked with deciding on all matters instead of experts in their respective fields.

I'm simply arguing that we need to break out of the status quo, and throwing out suggestions on how to fix this. Direct democracy is one way to bring the power back to the people. A competency test to accompany it is a stricter one to alleviate the pitfalls of direct democracy.

Even if we never adopt a competency test, I'd still argue that direct democracy would be a massive improvement to what we have now - if only because it'd bring the focus of the debate on the policy issues rather than on the scandals of politicians. It would totally obsolete are ridiculous two-party system.

Like I said, the test would seek to be as objective as possible. Questions would not be of the subjective format: "Does increasing the minimum wage improve the economy?" Actually I don't even think there would be any questions specific to minimum wage. Better questions would pertain to indisputable fact-based questions (eg. what's going on in the middle east in regards to foreign policy questions about that topic). Or again we could just default to basic logic tests.

These are all just implementation details though and secondary to the main point - which is to improve our policy-making.

Re:Why Are Politicians So Obsessed with Manufacturing? by chillacy on Friday October 14, 2016 @04:51PM (#12711008)
> what's going on in the middle east in regards to foreign policy questions about that topic

Also not a great example of something we understand. I think realistically you would not be able to test on something so practical since most of these things are so poorly understood. Logic tests may be the safest thing you could test, though at that point you would just be cutting everyone off below a certain SAT score.

If I were in charge of coming up with a test, it wouldn't be a logic test, but some sort of test against hubris: to see how much they can admit that they don't know or can't know. In my opinion politicians play the "I know everything vote for me" game and load up on untested theories, leading to poor results (interventionist foreign policy leading to terrorism, stock market crashes, maybe even deep ocean drilling, etc).

But I also recognize that while I believe that excluding overconfident people (the ones who don't know what they don't know) from office would lead to better outcomes, I also suspect that this could turn out terribly.

Re:Why Are Politicians So Obsessed with Manufacturing? by hasenj on Thursday October 06, 2016 @03:15AM (#12650746)
The problem then is it gives too much power to few people. Especially in the case of AI.
Re:Why Are Politicians So Obsessed with Manufacturing? by JDiculous on Thursday October 06, 2016 @03:30PM (#12655341)
That's already are problem - power is concentrated in too few people (politicians) that are bought out by special interests.

My direct democracy proposal expands that power to more people. You would have the power to vote on issues you're qualified to vote on rather than be beholden to your jack-of-all-trades representative who isn't the most qualified person to be making every decision.