Re:Alleged hacker Lauri Love to be extradited to US
by foldr on Thursday October 06, 2016 @07:05AM
(#12651473)
Your arguments were based on various hypothetical scenarios (extradition to Sudan on pornography charges, etc. etc.), which could not happen in the present system due to some combination of (i) the dual criminality requirement, (ii) the probable non-existence of the relevant extradition treaties, and (iii) the discretion that courts have to refuse extradition requests to countries which are unlikely to give a fair trial, or where disproportionate penalties are applied.
> This is just wrong on the face of it, and you've provided no supporting argument
All of my comments have contained the supporting arguments, to which you've merely responded with how things currently are. This does not make for much of a refutation.
IMHO this is one of the problems with a common law legal system. It's all too easy to forget that its various principles and precedents are actually man made and not manifest immutable truths.