Because it will cause their ad revenue to plummet. The users with money are the ones advertisers actually want to reach, so if you let them opt out of seeing advertising you'll just be left with an exclusive pool of users who won't buy anything. And no advertiser wants that.
Up to this point, the counter to this argument was basically "Well, what Twitter's doing is obviously working for them". But that's not quite as strong as it used to be now. How much money did Twitter leave on the table? It is, sure, possible that it would have been a net loss for them. But now I think a fresh look must be taken at the possibility that it would have been enough of a net gain to ensure their indepedence.
Plus one must consider the second-order effects of receiving subscription revenue. Might they have created a different and more valuable service to their customers and made even more as a result? Advertising-based businesses face the intrinsic paradox of trying to serve two customer bases at once who have somewhat opposed interests. (Even ignoring the socially corrosive influence of advertising incentivizing our smartest people to build the most powerful spying networks in history.) It is still not determined to my satisfaction that that is a stable business plan in the modern era.
One possible salutatory effect of Twitter's demise could be making the idea of subscriptions reasonable again. If even Twitter can't monetize entirely on advertising, who else can? Even Google and Facebook may be surprisingly fragile to a disruption in the advertising space, which is nominally not actually their business (even though of course it is). (The most likely disruption would be the continuing growth of ad-blocking software, but there's also the black swan possibilities as well.)
$0.55/month is the mean for the entire userbase. The actual amount for any particular user can be far more or far less (well up to .55 less) than that.
Users who are more likely to pay 4.95/month are much more likely to be worth more than 4.95/month in advertising revenue.
Given the paucity of people I know who've made a purchasing decision based off of an ad on Twitter, I seriously doubt that.
... which is plagued with spam and fraud. Victims are both the advertisers (who pay for ad slots that are viewed/clicked by bots) and the consumers (who suffer from malware ads, un-usable websites because there are 30+ trackers, ad brokers etc. on one single site, and higher product prices because the vendors have to pay for ads). The only ones who profits are the countless middle men - ad brokers and "big data analysis/retargeting" companies which kill user privacy on a global scale while providing next to zero value.
We should, once and for all, simply massively regulate advertising and re-think about how we as a society fund the services currently funded by ads. Especially in media, where "real" journalism had to step back in favor of ever more clickbait crap...
A good distinction but even if you assume a power-law/Pareto distribution for the revenue per customer, it would be roughly ~$2.20/user/month.
Hypothetically speaking, allowing those users to opt out would mean Twitter makes $0.20/month from the remaining users, rather than $0.55/month. Will enough users buy a premium subscription to make up that loss? I don't see the evidence that they would.
Of course, it's all hypothetical and none of us know the actual numbers involved. But I'd wager Twitter has looked at it at least once and decided it was not a good idea.
It can't work worse than operating at a loss until they go out of business, which is Twitter's current trajectory.
Look at Twitter for a moment the way game designers look at free-to-play mobile games. Whittling Tweets down to 140 characters is the sort of un-fun, repetitive process that a game designer would describe as a "grind" (see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grinding_(video_gaming)). And free-to-play games have established that letting players buy their way out of having to grind is a completely workable business model.
So just let Twitter power users skip their way out of grinding to get their Tweets under the 140 character limit by letting them buy bags of extra characters, preferably at low enough prices to be attractive as an impulse buy. If you spend all day on Twitter, and you're faced with the need spend five minutes editing a tweet to get it down under the limit, being able to just pay ten cents for a bag of ten extra characters and get that five minutes of your life back might be very attractive! And from Twitter's perspective, those ten cents are more or less pure profit, since the marginal cost of shipping 150 bytes over the wire instead of 140 is next to nothing. Free users can keep on using Twitter for free, power users can become the "whales" that provide the revenue that keeps the lights on, Twitter makes money. Everybody wins.
Also, it's a bit of support/maintenance/overhead for something that doesn't have as much support as you might think - otherwise tools like Google Contributor would be blowing up. I imagine like ~1% of users would actually opt to pay, maybe 2 or 3%, based upon my experience with freemium business models at a few different companies.
I think there's the hypothesis that these "pro subscribers" have higher incomes and are therefore better ripe for advertising demand. I would argue that Google has enough data and intelligence to internalize this hypothetical lifetime value from ad dollars into a reasonable price for a monthly subscription that would be roughly equivalent. If the counterpoint is that $7-10 / year doesn't quite equal how much Google could get for the same user through advertising (which could be substantially higher I think,) then it's hard to fault Sundar or Jack Dorsey or any other tech CEO in this space for going with what would provide better value to shareholders (which is ultimately their responsibility, for better or worse.)
I've just googled, looks like they're making $0.55/user/month [1]
I would have totally paid $7-$10/yr for no-bullshit version without ads, focused on user experience instead of manipulating my attention. I bet many other people would too. And I would use it way more actively as a result.
Why do neither twitter nor facebook offer premium/business accounts? It's not like it would cost them users, many people can still use the free ad-supported version....
[1] http://qz.com/131932/twitter-average-revenue-per-user/