I started feeling Murray Gell-Mann amnesia (https://seekerblog.com/2006/01/31/the-murray-gell-mann-amnes...) reading him a while ago and sent him a tweet about an important thing not discussed in some article, and his sarcastic response made me realize that he doesn't care very much about getting stories as right as he can: https://jakeseliger.com/2015/07/03/why-you-really-cant-trust....
as a founder you do have a choice of the kind of business you start. I think he just points out that debt-driven is not the only way to grow a successful company.
At least, enough of them have value to pay for the ones that don't.
This is basic economics.
"The market can stay irrational longer than you can stay solvent".
But it cannot continue to be so for half a decade.
I have met absolutely incompetent business owners who just happened to stumble into goldmines and through their own incompetence have locked in customers.
Start looking at software for an unsavoury infrastructure industry and you'll find this stuff abounds. Particularly in industries that were early adopters of computerized databases.
Whatsapp did charge for the iOS App and also a 99 cent subscription but it's not clear if they were break-even or profitable from November 2009 to April 2011. Since they were a private company, I'm not sure if they have ever disclosed their financial details before the 2014 Facebook acquisition.
[1]https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/whatsapp/funding-rou...
Yes, I've seen that video. Increasing the price to slow growth is a separate tool from weighing pros/cons of VC money to grow huge. At the time of Sequoia's 2011 investment, WhatsApp was estimated to have ~30 million users. It seems that Jan Koum felt it made more financial sense to get $8 million from Sequoia rather than from his customer base. If JK could raise subscription prices higher ($2? $5?) without his customers complaining to "self-fund" that $8M, that would have been financially better than giving up 10-15% of company ownership to Sequoia. He must have liked the first vc financial deal because he went back to Sequoia again for another $52 million.
If JK is ever on stage again, maybe somebody can ask him why he didn't get that $60 million from his user base. It would be interesting to hear his thought process.
The author, Farhad Manjoo, is romanticizing a bootstrapped business as "good" and (via his prosaic examples of restaurants and dog walking) dismissing the VC-backed businesses as "bad."
It should be obvious that the opposite can be true: a bootstrapped business can also be dysfunctional and a VC-backed firm can be disciplined with its money.
Bootstrapping is great strategy especially if you're company that doesn't benefit from "network effects" such as Mailchimp/Sendgrid. You acquire customers one at a time and offer a good enough value proposition for them to subscribe or pay. A lot of SaaS/enterprise companies and lifestyle businesses can grow that way.
Venture capital is really helpful when you need to deliberately grow exponentially faster than bootstrapping will allow because you're trying to build a giant footprint for the network effects. Snapchat is a good example of this. It wouldn't make sense to try to sell the Snapchat app on App store for $4.99 each so it can be cashflow positive and pay for programmer salaries. The first users of their apps were teens in high school and they can't just purchase an app like that without their parents' permission. If Snapchat charged money for the app, they wouldn't even know that teens were the leading edge of that trend. In that case, you need to wisely use vc funding to pay the bills while you grow the audience. Hopefully, Snapchat will end up profitable like Facebook instead of losing money like Twitter.
If you're a "network effects" startup that insists on bootstrapping as the only funding, you will be beat by the competitors that are willing to live with $0 revenue for a few years while their equity financing allowed them to build their user base faster.