Given that people can drive down the road in two directions, station #1 is also #5 and #2 is also #4. This changes your analysis slightly, but the result remains that you should go to station #3.
Re:How to find cheap gas using game theory
by JacobAldridge on Sunday April 18, 2010 @05:39PM
(#1275549)
And that the initial assumptions were crap.
Station #1 knows most of its customers won't be comparing (don't care or running low). So they can jack prices up a little more.
Station #2 knows that the only comparison they can be sure ALL their customers make is with Station #1, which will be jacked up, so they can increase their margins a little (above avg, below #1).
#3, #4 and #5 could follow the same logic, except for this. Station #5 knows many of its customers won't compare either. They're the last option without turning around, and many comparison shoppers won't turn around for a few lousy cents / gallon. So they can increase their margin a little.
Which leaves Station #3 wanting to look reasonable compared to #1 & #2, and able to survive a comparison with at least #4. And Station #4 knows they will be a good comparison with #5 but need to compete with #3 and so will probably be at or about the same level as #3.
In other words, #1 will be most expensive. #2 & #5 will have good cause for being a little extra. And #3 & #4 will both be subject to the largest competitive forces and will likely have similar, lowest prices.
Shame the initial assumption I made was completely crap.