News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

A comment on WikiLeaks plans to release documents on US election and Google. Parent comment

Re:WikiLeaks plans to release documents on US election and G... by DominikR on Tuesday October 04, 2016 @03:56PM (#12638847)
Even if all of that were true, Assange is NOT a US citizen. He cannot go beyond a journalist's 1st Amendment right and he also cannot be a traitor to the US. He is an Australian that operates from outside the US by publishing (often secret) material that his sent to him by whistleblowers without any coercion or payment.
[ Parent | on HN ]
Re:WikiLeaks plans to release documents on US election and G... by extra88 on Tuesday October 04, 2016 @04:13PM (#12639028)
I never said anything about treason. I assume "espionage" would be the jist of whatever he'd be charged with. In a U.S. court, the 1st Amendment would apply to him as much as a citizen. Are you suggesting the U.S. hasn't charged him with anything because there is nothing they can charge him with?

I don't know about his other leaks but there's evidence that he communicated with, arguably collaborated with and advised, Manning before Manning copied the classified material. If Manning just sent the material to Wikileaks, Assange would be in the clear (e.g. the Pentagon Papers, Trump's 1995 tax return info this week). Maybe it's not a solid enough case to be sure of a conviction, I doubt the U.S. would want to take a chance on it, but it's not like there's nothing there.

[ Parent | on HN ]
Re:WikiLeaks plans to release documents on US election and G... by dragonwriter on Tuesday October 04, 2016 @04:14PM (#12639041)
> Even if all of that were true, Assange is NOT a US citizen. He cannot go beyond a journalist's 1st Amendment right and he also cannot be a traitor to the US.

No one has suggested charging him with treason. He certainly can be guilty of espionage against the US without being a citizen.

(And his citizenship is irrelevant to whether he can exceed the protection of the 1st Amendment, since that applies whether or not he is a citizen with regard to government action such as prosecution for espionage.)

[ Parent | on HN ]