of course, this gets into a deeper discussion... many people /want/ to only talk with people who agree with them. For most people, the 'groupthink' that results from voting moderation systems /improves their experience/
The original article is suggesting paid moderators. Personally, I think PG coming on here and setting social expectations (he dressed me down, once.) probably has more to do with hn being a tolerable place than anything else. Paid or not, having a 'community owner' who can designate things as unacceptable, either by having a large amount of social capital (as pg does) or by having access to the banhammer as a paid moderator would, I think, is more important than anything else when it comes to maintaining an online community.