i agree that it is perfectly reasonable as a product. however, this is there entire business model. it is why they provide free storage for photos. it is why they want to get hardware into user's hands. it is why they do not provide end-to-end encryption for their communication apps. to me that is a distinction with a difference. it is a philosophy, not a product. and as i see our society marching into the future with a technological infrastructure at it's core built on the philosophy that it is ok to erode personal privacy for the benefit of the private corporation, i worry.
i think we should all get out an protest. but not with pitchforks. i'm a strong believer in public discourse, public disobedience, peaceful protect, constructive criticism, and constructively building alternatives.
But yes, unless things change at the macro level, we're pretty quickly moving into a future ruled by corporations: health, energy, technology, etc, and that is scary.
In that context, I believe that it's important to prioritize "citizen" issues over "consumer" issue, and security over convenience. Google has done some awe inspiring work, much of which I believe Google could have accomplished without requiring a user to agree to a single ToS governing all Google products, without demanding access to all user data. Statistical methods have come a long way, and much smaller data sets coupled with more explicit interaction with its stakeholders/customers (out in the open, explicit conversations vs deep dives into data without notifying the sources of the data) can still enable almost everything Google is doing. The stuff that would not be enabled within that framework could still be accomplished by Google explicitly paying folks to provide data sets (paying people to read scrips or have conversations explicitly recorded for instance) for the express purpose of building up data sets to work against for deep learning related to NLP for Google's "assistant". Lord knows Google has the cash to afford such an approach. But, since Google's current corporate structure requires it to highly prioritize profits, it just takes the data from private conversations.
The argument then is, well, that's what happens when you utilize a free or subsidized service. Yes, that is what you get. But it is not the only way we could be going on about this business. We just have our priorities all mixed up, because of the systemic incentives.