News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why I hate frameworks (2005) by collyw on Tuesday October 04, 2016 @10:14AM (#12635640)
Is this only a problem with Java frameworks? (The hammer-factory-building-factory talk leads me to believe that).

I stared learning Django a few years ago and have never looked back, it has increased my productivity loads. Admittedly its reasonably opinionated about the style of app you are building (but it covers the majority of apps and you don't need to use every part of the framework).

Re:Why I hate frameworks (2005) by zeveb on Tuesday October 04, 2016 @11:13AM (#12636137)
> Is this only a problem with Java frameworks?

No, but Java is notable for this problem. I think the root issue is that it is of course possible to write flexible software in Java, but in order to do so you must write all the dynamic bits in this static language, which ends up meaning that everything you write has to conform to an external statically–implemented-dynamism framework, and if you're going to have a framework then you might as well add to it, and … you end up with a standard Java app.

I haven't programmed in some of the cooler/reputed-to-be-better static languages like Haskell or the ML family (not beyond a few simple exercises, anyway), so I can't say to what extent they would suffer from this same problem if they enjoyed the same popularity.

I think that from the perspective of two decades on, Java turned out to have been a failure, not with respect to popularity but to quality. It turns out that it enabled mediocre software architects to spend great quantities of corporate money coming up with mediocre designs to be implemented by mediocre programmers, resulting in mediocre software and mediocre return on investment. That doesn't mean that it's impossible to write high-quality Java, just that that's not the norm: the entire Java ecosystem militates against quality, because quality is risk, and Java is not about risk: Java and Java-using organisations prefer predictable mediocrity to excellence. That's not even necessarily bad — sometimes predictable mediocrity is preferable to risk — but it's certainly not inspiring.

I too used to really like Django; I spent about six years using it for one project and another. Were I going to do Python web development again, I'd probably use Flask or Bottle, but Django definitely taught me a lot.

But I'd prefer not to do Python web development in the future.

Re:Why I hate frameworks (2005) by algesten on Tuesday October 04, 2016 @02:18PM (#12637883)
I think part problem is also that many programmers tend to gravitate towards abstraction and reusable code before there is a clear need for it.

Just today I read about this project https://github.com/primus/primus and it's a point in case. A "universal wrapper for real-time frameworks" with the main benefit being "Effortless switching between real-time frameworks by changing one single line of code."

Because clearly, I often need to switch between WebSockets and BrowserChannel... or wait, do I?

Re:Why I hate frameworks (2005) by seibelj on Tuesday October 04, 2016 @03:06PM (#12638375)
The documentation is more lines than the actual code is. Essentially it provides a uniform interface to multiple socket libraries. Why you would need this... I have no idea
Re:Why I hate frameworks (2005) by ignasl on Wednesday October 05, 2016 @03:19AM (#12642063)
" It turns out that it enabled mediocre software architects to spend great quantities of corporate money coming up with mediocre designs to be implemented by mediocre programmers, resulting in mediocre software and mediocre return on investment."

But most people are mediocre. That's just how the world works.

Re:Why I hate frameworks (2005) by zeveb on Wednesday October 05, 2016 @10:49AM (#12644244)
> But most people are mediocre. That's just how the world works.

Sure, but I choose to pursue excellence.

And, in the marketplace, excellence wins. Maybe not technical excellence (sadly, it's often marketing excellence which wins), but mediocrity loses in the end.

Re:Why I hate frameworks (2005) by collyw on Saturday October 08, 2016 @10:39AM (#12667077)
Not really. I try to produce good clean code (its a lot better than the last two projects I have inherited). No one seems bothered by that, they just want new features done as soon as possible.
Re:Why I hate frameworks (2005) by alyandon on Tuesday October 04, 2016 @10:39AM (#12635860)
No, not just Java (really J2EE). The actual problem can manifest itself anywhere where dogmatic design principles are allowed to trump pragmatism.
Re:Why I hate frameworks (2005) by secstate on Tuesday October 04, 2016 @10:53AM (#12635981)
I don't know if it's only Java, but I agree whole-heartedly about the general health of the Python framework community. I love Django, but it's also pretty easy to excise parts you don't need for a particular project, while being opinionated enough to get things done quickly and allow folks on the internet to help debug things.

Then of course there's Flask for lightweight API projects, which can get trotted out if Django is being TOO opinionated :)

Don't get me wrong, there are plenty of criticisms to level at frameworks-as-a-solution mindsets, but in the context of the OP, I think Joel's rant doesn't really apply to Python web development at the moment.