it's efficient because the fast path is a very closed-source binary blob running on the hardware. anything the binary blob doesn't support, is going to be "software switched" as it is commonly called.
Yep. Does anyone know if there are fully open source solutions that can compare to the performance/price of Edgerouter & Co?
My understanding is without the binary blob, no. That's where the magic happens.
Re:A tiny PC as a router
by narrowrail on Tuesday October 04, 2016 @09:09AM
(#12635207)
Well, you could put Gentoo on your ERL-3:
With the hardware acceleration for packets routing it probably outperforms a custom-built PC.
It'll outperform a low-end PC on really simple and dumb benchmarks. But in the real world, routers should usually be doing active queue management and often traffic shaping. Good luck getting the hardware offloads to do any intelligent packet processing like that.
Exactly my point.
Yes, it's a valid option, but it's opaque closed source, and dumbed down with GUI crap for the clueless.
Re:A tiny PC as a router
by lightbulbjim on Tuesday October 04, 2016 @06:39AM
(#12634530)
Nope, EdgeOS is a fork of VyOS, based on Debian. There is a GUI, but there's also a CLI which exposes a lot more functionality. You can even install standard Debian packages via Apt.
See https://help.ubnt.com/hc/en-us/categories/200321064-EdgeMAX
[1] Available e.g. here: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=0XP-000A-000...