But I will say that FBA is very easy to get into. If you ever find yourself thinking "I wish that exists" about a relatively simple product, and can't find it already on Amazon, jump on to Alibaba and source a factory that makes something similar and ask them if they'll make what you want.
Doesn't strike me as particularly sustainable. Especially if you have all your eggs in Amazon's basket given their willingness to take over entire product lines with their own brand.
Then I realized that with the money they had, they had been able to hire me to do this work, so perhaps I wasn't the smartest guy in the room after all...
The thing to understand is that capitalism is about identifying opportunities to accumulate the largest amount of capital in the shortest amount of time.
The truth is if you focus only on "logical", sustainable, defensible, infinitely scalable business models, you'll be missing out a good 60% of the opportunities.
If you could let's say accumulate $600,000 in 5 months with a non viable business, you'd have all the time in the world to work on the viable businesses you mention.
In capitalism, you rarely know for sure which game the other person is playing. It's not because she is moving cards around that she is playing cards.
So the bottom line of my comment is don't be too smart . Being able to make dumb money is as important - if not more important - than being able to make smart money.
And I can even say : making dumb money at the right time is more valuable than making smart money at the wrong time.
I was looking for a "smart" business that was "worthy" of me. How could these people spend so much time on such an indefensible & unscalable process?!
Well, the joke was on me. My brother stopped consuming info and started Amazon FBA. And he does really well (full-time job replacement). Instead of waiting for the perfect idea - he executed.
Now I'm happily off my high horse and trying to follow in his footsteps.
Lesson learned - there is no perfect business. Get started with something simple and build from there.
Great article on this incremental approach for anyone interested: http://www.softwarebyrob.com/2015/03/26/the-stairstep-approa...
But past that starting a business, especially a physical product one is not a trivial thing to do. You need to be very motivated. Like with software you discover many time-consuming details as you implement. And here not everything can be automated once solved. Even established competitors do not copy as fast as one may think because of these forces.
It might be dumb money but it still isn't easy money - and that's what make it even dumber : why not invest the effort in something "better" someone will say.
The guy is just trying to offer us the benefit of his experience. We shouldn't penalize him for that.
I figured anybody motivated enough could do the same detective work he did...there's a difference between leaving room for inference and posting a billboard, though. That said, that particular niche is already crowded with 3 strong competitors, so anybody interested in duplicating would be better served spending half an hour with a junglescout.com trial to find a more competitive way to get a foothold.
However I really hope they won't, just like I hope poster above won't lose money for trying to be nice.
That actually reminds me - is there a good way of scrubbing that sort of data off the web? Googling around for me will eventually lead you to where I grew up, and where my parents still live. While it tends to keep me ... a bit more polite than I might normally be, it also means that one person with a grudge could start mailing my parents glitter, poorly-packed ant farms, or worse.
There is a certain bias effect to consider.
When you purchase something, your criteria for it to meet your expectations is a bit higher (subconsciously) than if it was given to you for free.
I found a very relevant subreddit and offered to send a sample to anybody who was willing to leave an honest review, up to 10 total. I got very enthusiastic responses, and sent out the samples.
Every review that I received from this group was five stars. I at no time asked for five stars, and was very explicit about asking them to be honest. Maybe my product is just that good, but I suspect there's at least a little bias there.
More to the point, every organic review I've received since has been five stars, which leads me to think there's a crowd effect going on.
I think what I did was a good deal less scummy that what ReviewKick et al do, since they explicitly find "good" reviewers for you, and the reviewers aren't necessarily knowledgeable about the product or niche. That said, even my targeted approach yielded a lot of bias.
For what it's worth, this exercise doubled my sales. I now effectively earn the equivalent of a full time minimum wage job through one tiny niche product, and an hour's work every couple of months.