One thing we all can agree it's radical.
(basic income, etc.), it's like Communist propaganda once again
I don't think you really understand what Communism/Socialism is. Under these systems you have no right to private property. They are post-capitalistic. In Communism money doesn't exist. Communist Countries have been Socialist (example: U.S.S.R. United Soviet Socialist Republic). Socialism is the transfer from Capitalism TO Communism.Basic Income is just classical liberalism. Helping people survive who are under privileged within a capitalistic economy while leaving the existing capitalistic economy and power structures largely intact.
Calling basic income communism is just GOP propaganda, not even libertarian propaganda.
:.:.:
Communists see Basic Income as a bourgeoisie hand out necessary to preserve existing class structures of a post scarcity capitalist society. By pacifying the proletariat and ensuring that in the event the bourgeoisie no longer require proletariat labor, they will still be able to exploit them for profit.
But if there is no scarcity or labor, why must there be profit?
We heard it all before, down to every word.
Have you seriously ever read Marx as an adult? Not under a teachers supervision? He disagrees with >75% of everything Stalin, and everyone who came after him did. A strong argument can even be made that Leninism is a fundamental diversion from Marxism.
But (assuming you are European) non-Leninist communist literature was banned.
The divergence actually goes back further than Stalin to Lenin and his rather extensive deviations from classical Marxism to come up with a new program that could plausibly be deployed in a society that was itself pre-capitalist without developing mature capitalism on the road to the socialism that Marx saw as the necessary stage between capitalism and the end-state goal of utopian communism. Outside of the utopian ultimate end-state that both strove for in principle, this required complete revision of every part of the Marxist program starting with the preconditions and working through the whole rest of the policy path.
http://4.bp.blogspot.com/-Zg4XgbxYd3k/Ul2WhkOQUiI/AAAAAAAAAI...
Basic income as an alternative to existing social welfare programs has a substantial amount of support on the right, particularly the libertarian right (and, likewise, a substantial amount of opposition from the left, particularly outside of the small left-libertarian segment, which is actually probably where the most fervent support for BI is), though the more extreme position of "no social support structure at all" is even more popular on the right (both libertarian and not).
BI, IOW, is not a distinctively left-wing position.
> One thing we all can agree it's radical.
There's some support for truly radical (or reactionary) ideas in SV, but overall its not really "radical" except in being a radical break from the establishment orthodoxy of either the left or the right. SV, on the whole, is a weird mix of naivete and pragmatism when it comes to policy preferences, with some leanings (though perhaps not as strong as one would expect from the people making up SV) toward the self-interest of relatively wealthy white men.
Whenever discussing what "SV" wants, we should try to distinguish whether we're talking about the leaders, venture capitalists, prominent opinion-formers etc versus trying to find an average of what the public in that area think. And there's an extreme diversity of views to average over.