News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Examples of How City Services Privatization Leads to Ineq... by Retric on Monday October 03, 2016 @10:58AM (#12627830)
Externalities, generally prevent profit from aligning with optimum resource allocation for society. I may only be willing to pay X to ride a subway and it might cost Y to provide subway service, but having one less commuter on the roads is worth Z to society. In a classic free market if X < Y then I don't ride the subway, but if X < (Y - Z) society is better off if I do ride the subway.

Further, subways systems, electricity, water, etc are far more efficient as a single provider which suggests a heavily regulated utility. But, if the government is going to subsidizes and heavily regulate a company like this then it's not really a company any more just a government organization with a funky org chart.

To further complicate things, this opens the door for a huge range of corruption as someone is legally allowed to take taxpayer money and profit.

Re:Examples of How City Services Privatization Leads to Ineq... by djschnei on Monday October 03, 2016 @11:38AM (#12628272)
"Z" is a premise I disagree with; especially when government/force is involved. If you want to ride the subway to a determent of yourself for society's benefit, that's your decision. Hell, I might even be sharing the subway with you. However, I'm not about to make that decision for others. Pushing aside the individual for the collective is something I am vehemently opposed to on moral grounds. So, I guess I understand what you're saying, I just disagree with the premise.
Re:Examples of How City Services Privatization Leads to Ineq... by Retric on Tuesday October 04, 2016 @12:50AM (#12633404)
It's not about forcing people to ride the subway it's building and subsidizing a subway so people will ride it. Abstractly, it's little different from building and maintaining a bridge.

Supose you save 1/1,000th of a second of commute time on average per driver that takes the subway * 1,000,000 drivers taking the subway. That's 16 minutes eat way or 30 minutes a day. Ethics or not that is actual value.

Now if you you feel morally opposed to subsides and are not willing to pay for them fine, but that does not mean they can't work. Further, building and maintaining infrastructure has been one of the hallmarks of government for 8,000+ years it's not going to change any time soon.

But hey, if you want to argue for less efficient systems that's your right.

Re:Examples of How City Services Privatization Leads to Ineq... by djschnei on Wednesday October 05, 2016 @04:06PM (#12647317)
I don't oppose subsides, per se; I oppose the involuntary collection of tax money, or any involuntary transfer of property. If for example, a subway is inherently more efficient than other means of travel, and it can be funded via ticket sales, I am SO for it. If it can't survive or exist without the involuntary collection of property, then I oppose it.

And infrastructure has been a major role for governments for quite some time, and I completely agree it's a legitimate role. However, it should be based on usage fees.

Re:Examples of How City Services Privatization Leads to Ineq... by infinite8s on Monday October 03, 2016 @09:37PM (#12632741)
On what moral grounds? Just because your chosen morality puts the individual above the group in all cases doesn't mean everybody else subscribes to that morality (in fact, I highly doubt most people subscribe to that morality fully, given the society we have built up).
Re:Examples of How City Services Privatization Leads to Ineq... by djschnei on Wednesday October 05, 2016 @03:57PM (#12647227)
Putting the individual above the collective is a very simplistic, and quite inaccurate, summation of my morality. My morality is that I can't use violence in an aggressive manner, only defensive - this is often described as the non-aggression principle or "NAP".

You might be fine with the idea that as long as the majority agree, we can delegate aggression upon the minority via a central governing body; but I am not.

I also hope (and suspect) most people subscribe to the idea you can't initiate coercive force against others - however we've for some reason agreed you magically can as long as we vote about it. I'll never understand that... It seems like a logical disconnect to me... Maybe I am weird... idk.