Re:Free Lossless Image Format Publications
by vanderZwan on Monday October 03, 2016 @11:20AM
(#12628057)
That's the encoder, which isn't something browsers would usually bother with. The decoder is Apache licensed.
Re:Free Lossless Image Format Publications
by mark-r on Monday October 03, 2016 @01:00PM
(#12629166)
Thanks, I missed that. Still it means that e.g. Photoshop will never support it, leading to the same conclusion.
Re:Free Lossless Image Format Publications
by jonsneyers on Tuesday October 04, 2016 @02:44AM
(#12633710)
I'm open to negotiation if Adobe would want to include the FLIF encoder in Photoshop. The other contributors have signed a CLA that allows me to change the licensing to anything more permissive than GPLv3. So if Adobe wants it, they can pay for a non-copyleft license (e.g. Apache 2.0). If that ever happens, I'll be happy to share the licensing fees with the other contributors and donate some of it to the FSF.
Re:Free Lossless Image Format Publications
by h1d on Wednesday October 05, 2016 @12:07AM
(#12641489)
Why would they want to pay?
Unless the format is widely spread and the fee is much cheaper than implementing their own what interest do they have to pay? I feel it's the opposite now.
Re:Free Lossless Image Format Publications
by jonsneyers on Tuesday October 04, 2016 @09:12AM
(#12635217)
Also, Adobe Photoshop (or any other program) is of course free to dynamically link to the libflif library. The LGPL allows that.
Re:Free Lossless Image Format Publications
by vanderZwan on Monday October 03, 2016 @07:14PM
(#12632159)
Well, IANAL but I think the original creator of FLIF could still decide give a special license to Adobe if they want to negotiate one, no?
EDIT: practically confirmed elsewhere in the thread by the original author, with motivation:
> There is still a lot of room for improvement in the encoder, which is why (at least for now) it has the LGPL license, to ensure that improvements can be integrated in the reference implementation
Re:Free Lossless Image Format Publications
by mark-r on Monday October 03, 2016 @09:35PM
(#12632736)
IANAL either, but I suspect it would be between difficult and impossible to offer an alternate license once outside contributions are integrated.
Re:Free Lossless Image Format Publications
by vanderZwan on Tuesday October 04, 2016 @06:29AM
(#12634488)
Good point, I had forgotten about the viral aspect of the GPL. But it looks like Sneyers already thought of that too, luckily.
The choice of GPLv3 licensing is unfortunate, since it will limit native browser support.