Cable internet falls into that category too. The common setup in the USA is effectively a municipally sponsored monopoly.
> 1. A free-market dynamic requires an actual market. If the buyer can't chose among competing sellers, then it's not a market. At the grocery store you can choose from among many different sellers: that's a functional market. The point where your plumbing connects to the water main, simply isn't.
Sure but rather than directly hiring N people to run the water works and plumbing crews, the city could contract out the maintenance of those things to a private company. It would still own the pipes and be on the hook for the maintenance, but it wouldn't be directly employing the workers. If company X doesn't work out (say due to crappy service), then they could award the maintenance contract to company Y. In this model, the private company doesn't get a local monopoly on the resource, only a contract to provide the service for some limited duration (say N years).
It may well be that there are services that are not profitable to operate. It's governments job to fund those based on excess tax dollars it collects from other services. A bus route to a poor part of town that it's particularly popular isn't going to fund itself. Government smooths those bumps to provide services where they're needed.
The problem occurs when a private entity must make a self-contained business case off the back of the infrastructure. Since they'll never be able to capture any of the positive externalities, they have to take everything out of end-user-fees, externalities be damned. This can be very, very bad for the city as a whole.
And yes, agreed about cable internet being in this category too!
I know this can work, but in addition to the usual misalignment of goals between public and private sector, I still see more inefficiency with this than just letting the government do it.
For example, the government has to pay all the workers (indirectly, at least). On top of that, it has to pay to negotiate contracts, and an entire layer of oversight of the contractors (which also have their own HR and bureaucracy that you are paying for). On top of that, they will likely have built-in some extra profit to give them some flexibility in case they don't get the next contract. Plus money for lobbying in many instances.
If you find the contractors aren't doing their job, now you will probably have to get lawyers and whatnot, and have expensive, time-consuming litigation. Then, if the government wants to change companies at some point, you have a large expense in finding a new one, with bidding, etc. And that is if there is another contractor available in your area. And then you have lobbying, cronyism, and other political issues.
The entire reason for hiring another company to do this is to get around public pay and pension issues. If this is all just a workaround for that, fix the source of that problem, rather than trying to abstract away responsibility.
Business contract law is much simpler to deal with than employment law. Plus it wouldn't be the governments job to deal with individuals at all. Only the end result of the service provided. It'd be the private companies job to deal with their own employees and contractors.
> The entire reason for hiring another company to do this is to get around public pay and pension issues. If this is all just a workaround for that, fix the source of that problem, rather than trying to abstract away responsibility.
That's exactly the point! Because no private company would be stupid enough to enter those types of agreements with their workers because they can't maintain their end of them. The government can't do it either (without bankrupting and/or eroding it's tax base) so the solution is to prevent government from ever having a chance to enter those agreements. Otherwise some weak willed politician will hand out defined benefit plans like it's candy to get votes for one election, only to doom their children's children for years to come.
This American Life had an example of this with Colorado Springs city services, act 3 of http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/459/w...
The answer to that is to have shorter contracts and/or having clauses in them that allows you to break the contract. The would naturally lead to higher costs as there would be additional business risk but it'd probably be worth it.
In fact, a more general law I'd like to have in place is that a given government cannot create obligations that extend past N years unless there's a damn good reason for it. Short of distributing the cost of building a bridge over 20-30 years, there's no reason for governments to hand cuff their citizens like that (besides croneyism and kickbacks). Maybe have the max duration of the obligation be tied to the percentage of vote required. 51% max would be 1 year, 60% max would be 3 years, etc.
I'm skeptical.
> A free-market dynamic requires an actual market.
Not really. A free-market type would say the supply is limited. Even if the supply is zero it's still a free-market if the actors are trading voluntarily. The supply for many markets is zero, but it typically correlates with demand.
> The entire purpose of infrastructure is to generate positive externalities
A free-market type would probably use the word value rather than positive externalities. But isn't the purpose of any action to create positive value? Your argument is essentially that forced trades via central planning can create more value than voluntary trades.
> 3. There are broader socio-economic issues of accessibility to services that profit-driven companies have no incentive to be responsive to.
A free-market type would probably say that the supply of accessibility services is low due to limited demand / profitability. While true maybe this is where charity plays a role.
See "Myth of the Natural Monopoly" by Thomas DiLorenzo https://mises.org/system/tdf/rae9_2_3_3.pdf?file=1&type=docu...
1. A free-market dynamic requires an actual market. If the buyer can't chose among competing sellers, then it's not a market. At the grocery store you can choose from among many different sellers: that's a functional market. The point where your plumbing connects to the water main, simply isn't.
2. The entire purpose of infrastructure is to generate positive externalities. Ready availability of transport, water and electricity, etc., makes it easy and desirable to do business in a place and with each other. This leads to emergent urban economies, where mutual comparative advantage among a heterogeneous population leads to mutually beneficial exchange, which in turn leads to more growth and prosperity for everyone. The fewer low-level frictions, the more prosperous everyone becomes. But capturing value at the point-of-use -- which is what private operators generally do -- creates a low-level friction with substantial knock-on effects. Every dollar you extract from the farebox of a public transport system, for example, is many dollars removed from the wider economy. It's much more appropriate to subsidise the infrastructure networks and then tax the positive externalities (via sales, income, and property taxes) after the uplift has been created.
3. There are broader socio-economic issues of accessibility to services that profit-driven companies have no incentive to be responsive to.