News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple loses patent retrial to the litigious VirnetX, orde... by AnthonyMouse on Sunday October 02, 2016 @02:47AM (#12621315)
> If you believe that patents, in general, are more good than bad, because they coax trade secrets out into the open after an amount of time, then they are just as valid for inventive software as for i inventive hardware/chemistry/biology/mechanics.

There are important ways that software is different.

One is that software is inherently abstract. If you're making a battery or a machine or a drug, it matters what materials you use, what the temperature is at different points, how long the product lasts, how much it costs per unit to manufacture, etc. In software there is none of that. But without any of those constraints the inherent result is unreasonably broad patents.

This combines on the other end with the fact that software has effectively zero reproduction cost, so there is trivial cost for adding support for things. Which means combinatorial explosion. "You asked for a banana but what you got was a gorilla holding a banana and the entire jungle." If you're making batteries and you use A, B and C then it doesn't affect you if someone else has a patent on the combination of D, E and F. If you're making software there is no unit cost to adding support for everything from A to Z, so you do. But then it doesn't matter which combination of things someone patents, you end up unwittingly infringing it because you support everything and the patent covers some subset of everything.

The result is unworkable. The system can't function when everything infringes everything.

There are no comments on this comment yet.