Unfortunately, it was the worst kind of debugging, throw drugs at the problem and see what sticks. If it doesn't work change the dosage, then some more drugs to counteract the side effects, then clean up and start over. It feels so unscientific and medieval.
What your describing sounds a lot like team debugging and trouble shooting! Trial and error of a failed hypothesis, further testing when someone looks at the data with fresh eyes. Finally a solution, or in your case, clarity.