News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple loses patent retrial to the litigious VirnetX, orde... by IshKebab on Saturday October 01, 2016 @03:11PM (#12619400)
How would patent issues stop it being an open standard? H.264 is an open standard but still subject to patents.
Re:Apple loses patent retrial to the litigious VirnetX, orde... by xenadu02 on Saturday October 01, 2016 @05:34PM (#12619983)
VirnetX claims to have patents covering the P2P mechanism behind the original FaceTime.

Originally it worked similar to iMessage in that you had a system to exchange identities but the actual communication was all P2P after that.

Apple had to change it to use their servers to get around the patents (which VirnetX claimed wasn't enough and was still infringing).

Once that changed there was no point in releasing it as an open standard since it required Apple's servers to operate.

If VirnetX prevails then Skype, Google Hangouts, and everyone else is infringing too and VirnetX will use the precedent to go after them as well. It's a common strategy: go after a couple of people first, establish a win, then use that to leverage settlements out of the remaining players.

Re:Apple loses patent retrial to the litigious VirnetX, orde... by jpalomaki on Saturday October 01, 2016 @03:25PM (#12619468)
Maybe the problem was that they had to change the original design due patent issues and with the new design (proxy servers etc) the openness would not have worked out so well.
Re:Apple loses patent retrial to the litigious VirnetX, orde... by gwright on Saturday October 01, 2016 @03:32PM (#12619506)
Because the patent owners bought into the intellectual property regime created by H.264.

H.264 happened because the patent owners agreed to the standard not because the H.264 committee had some sort of legal authority to ignore the patent owners.