That's quite dismissive of men who have become the target of harassment campaigns.
>The notion that women should write under pen names while men freely and safely claim credit for any random achievement is a perfect example of how this industry allows itself to be rigged against women. Women aren't even supposed to identify themselves --- when they do, they're just allowing themselves to be victimized by the forces of nature, which apparently include mobs of misogynist trolls.
There are plenty of men who cannot safely claim credit for their writings, though the reason is usually ideological rather than rooted in their identity. If you, as a man or a woman, post something which is found disagreeable by a large majority of your peers in 2016, someone will come after your job. Someone will try to find out where you live. To ignore this problem and solely focus on the fact that women receive snide, misogynist comments sometimes when they write innocuous articles seems intellectually dishonest.
Not as often as women, but that wasn't the claim being made.
And yes, some authors have been "selected for the sin of being a man".
Thank you. If I had myself suggested people believed that, I'd be accused of caricaturing. But we'd both know: I wouldn't have been.
† (or "patronizing", a word that means literally the exact same thing and has somehow been used for centuries without mortally injuring our manly feels)
No and that isn't what I said. That was in reference to a certain demographic of people that do target men specifically because they are men and men are equivalent to being the devil, since their beliefs are borderline a religion to begin with I feel fine in making that equivalence.
Similar here is what is often called a "weasel word" -- to make the whole thing subjective and impossible to disprove (since nobody knows what would be "similar" enough to satisfy the un-disclosed similarity criteria -- in other words, sort like the "no true scotsman" fallacy).
If we omit that word, the truth is simply this: men who write or men who post online in general also can and often do become targets of harassment campaigns. Especially on the internet, where harassment comes as easy as writing a swearing/threatening/derogatory comment and mobs are quick to jump on mass attacks.
Their attackers may not call them "bitches" and "sluts" (so in that sense it's not "similar") but they do call them tons of other things, including things that they don't call women (e.g. "faggot").
Here are some examples grabbed from literally the first page of Google search:
Overall, men are somewhat more likely than women to experience at least one of the elements of online harassment, 44% vs. 37%. In terms of specific experiences, men are more likely than women to encounter name-calling, embarrassment, and physical threats.
http://www.pewinternet.org/2014/10/22/online-harassment/
One blogpost (civilly) critical of Sarkeesian and her supporters offers a fully sourced compilation of online comments wishing death, rape, mutilation and deadly diseases upon Jack Thompson, an activist critical of violent and sexual content in videogames—as well as death threats directed at male videogame developers who ran afoul of their fans.
Meanwhile, role-playing game designer James Desborough claims to have been viciously threatened for defending the use of sexual violence as a plot element in games.
And film blogger Alex Sandell (Juicy Cerebellum) has described receiving not only a deluge of hate mail but threatening phone calls—sometimes in the middle of the night, and sometimes made to his relatives—after writing negative reviews of the first two Lord of the Rings movies.
In the political sphere, several conservative male writers and activists have been targeted for rape and death threats, with their phone numbers publicly posted, after producing a documentary critical of the Occupy movement.
Right-wing bloggers involved in the bizarre war with leftist activist Brett Kimberlin that David Weigel recently chronicled in The Daily Beast have faced scary cyber-harassment from some of Kimberlin’s supporters, including graphic fantasies of violent revenge, lurid sexual slurs, and accusations of child pornography. (Particularly disturbing examples are documented in a blogpost by First Amendment advocate Ken White.)
On the other side, Charles Johnson, who runs the blog Little Green Footballs, relocated to a gated community because of threats he received after breaking with the right and embracing more liberal politics.
One male victim of cyberstalking, British expatriate novelist James Lasdun, told his story in the 2013 memoir, Give Me Everything You Have: On Being Stalked. Lasdun’s stalker, a former creative-writing student whose romantic overtures he had rejected, not only barraged him with abusive messages but emailed his colleagues accusing him of stealing her work, preying on female students, and even setting her up to be raped; she posted similar slanders on websites including Amazon.com and Wikipedia. But an experience like Lasdun’s gets no political sympathy; indeed, the review in The New Yorker chided him for failing to admit his “crush” on the woman and his role in leading her on.
[a] study, conducted by the British think tank Demos, was limited to a fairly small sample of British celebrities, journalists and politicians whose Twitter timelines were tracked over a two-week period, its findings are nonetheless interesting. On the whole, 2.5 percent of the tweets sent to the men but fewer than 1 percent of those sent to women were classified as abusive. Male politicians fared especially badly, receiving more than six times as much abuse as female politicians. The only category in which women got more Twitter abuse than men was journalism: abusive messages accounted for more than 5 percent of the tweets sent to the female journalists and TV presenters in the study and fewer than 2 percent of the ones sent to the male journalists.
http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2014/09/04/men-are-har...
Have you recently done any of the following on HN:
Engaged a woman in good faith discussion?
Upvoted her comments, submissions, or written work?
Addressed the substance of her points instead of nitpicking minor issues or focusing on her gender in some way?
Engaged with her in a manner that in some way enhanced her public reputation as a professional or otherwise enhanced her professionally?
These things happen routinely for men on HN. I think they are far less common for women.
I am not afraid to stick my neck out, but I am unusual for a woman in many ways, yet I am still finding it enormously frustrating. The degree to which expressing myself gets hatred, sexual harassment or dismissal vastly outweighs the degree to which anything I do gets taken in any way seriously. The sad thing is that I suspect my experiences are dramatically more positive than what is typical for a woman online.
How are we to know? People here are just usernames. If there are any substantial number of women here, then I've certainly had the same mix of positive and negative interactions with them as anyone else on this site (I'm green because someone changed the password to my account, and I didn't have an e-mail registered to it).
There are few enough people that explicitly mention their gender here, and I'd always assumed it wasn't an issue (within this community, at least). It's sad to hear that you're having trouble.
Probably. I engage commenters -- and because of the handles (which I don't even check before commenting) I seldom know whether they are men or women (or LGBT), and basically I don't even care whether they are X or Y sex or not, as long as they have something interesting to say, or say something that I disagree with and want to comment on.
I'm an equal opportunity "somebody is wrong on the internet" commenter.
>These things happen routinely for men on HN. I think they are far less common for women.
Maybe because woman are much fewer than men on HN? I engage with both men and women on somewhat equal frequency on other forums and media, e.g. Facebook.
It's tough in the real world (which is bigger than tech) for everybody.
Bullying and harassment on the internet is a fact for both women and men (as it is in real life for that matter. Male geeks, for example, hardly get much love in high school from the "football team" type guys, and same for geeky/unpopular females from the schools "a-list").
Women have the historical baggage of sexism and double standards to fight against, which has been closing down since the 60s.
Men who are not of the macho/alpha-male type (that is, most of us tech geeks) have the macho/violence/"bro"/anti-"faggot" etc crap to put up with, which doesn't get much attention, but is a real problem too.
It is possible (and I'd say, preferable) to acknowledge both, and their unique mechanics, without flying any flags for one or the other.
Is it only meaningful when it gets physical?
Or are violence threats and death threats, internet mob justice, bullying and the like is not "meaningful harassment" if it happens to men?
And why would that be?
Is that because most attacks on men are mere jokes, or maybe most men are thick-skinned Rambos that just brush them off?
And, the corollary, is that because most attacks on women are real-world threatening, or most women are little delicate creatures that can't take a verbal/written attack?
I find it hard to agree with either idea.
Maybe there's some other possible intended meaning behind this "meaningful harassment" notion that I've missed?
I'm not interested in the noodling semantic argument. Don't bullshit me. You're not getting anywhere with it.
I stand by everything I've said on this thread. Anyone who suggests men in this industry deal with harassment of the same kind women do should be embarrassed. Will, inevitably, be embarrassed. I'll happily sign my own name to that.
>in other words, sort like the "no true scotsman" fallacy).
Further, you don't seem interested in any form of conversation. I can't say you're posting in good faith - but rather have already made your mind certain of something with no intentions of discussing it. Calling others names and taking the moral high ground, even when that moral high ground has little to no basis in reality and you've been given evidence otherwise.
"men become targets of similar harassment campaigns"
was the case.
Not
"men become targets of similar harassment campaigns because of their gender"
If you want to qualify away from beliefs towards physical properties then fine. Lets turn around and look at those harassed for their hair colour. How about skin colour? Origin? Things other members of their family have done?
> If you want to qualify away from beliefs towards physical properties then fine. Lets turn around and look at those harassed for their hair colour. How about skin colour? Origin? Things other members of their family have done?
I do not understand why this is not sufficient to preempt your comment.
In case it is not here are some example I have found alongside their google search terms:
* "Ginger driven to suicide" http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2507153/Bullied-ging...
* "footballer harassed racial" https://www.theguardian.com/football/blog/2013/may/13/racism...
* "father harassed by" http://www.abc.net.au/news/2016-06-28/sandy-hook-massacre-vi...
My point is this: at least our industry recognizes a problem and is slowly doing something about it. So don't stop just because it seems overwhelming to fix the issue; we've already come a long way and can continue to progress.
I don't know who gets harassed more, men or women, but I'd definitely guess women. That being said, the advice is pretty standard for everyone.
The internet is still a dangerous place for everyone. If you want to pretend it's not, have fun and let me know how that works out for you.
Women don't.
I'm not OK with it. Nobody should be OK with it.
Nobody is saying it's OK. We are saying that's just how it is.
What's the evidence of this? If these trolls aren't using real identities I'd be skeptical if it were more than one person. Maybe even someone who knows her personally if they're dedicated this much energy.
I'm not OK with this. Nobody should be OK with this.
It may be ignorant of me to suggest blowing these trolls off and not paying them attention - but it isn't insincere or sexist. I'd like to hear your solution.
It behooves the people proclaiming "something must be done" to detail what exactly they'd like to see happen. Otherwise we just have an emotional mob seeking any convenient scapegoat.
Specific constructive ideas appear to be lacking, and in their place vague allusions and shouting down of people who do concretely point out how individuals can try to protect themselves. I think what most "detractors" are worried about is an alignment with the government desire to remove anonymity from the Internet, which seems to be implied as some kind of solution even though it should be a complete non-starter.
http://micheleincalifornia.blogspot.com/2016/06/promoting-ge...
Yes, that same link is posted elsewhere in this discussion. So far, it has gotten zero upvotes (or downvotes) or replies. Because, as usual, it is getting mostly ignored.
People making the kinds of comment you have just made seem to not actually want solutions. They seem to want a convenient excuse for dismissing the criticism entirely.
I have been working hard to bring solutions, not complaints, for quite a few years. It is mostly ignored.
If you actually want real change, you could start by paying more attention to the things I suggest, acting on them and promoting my writing. But I imagine that won't happen at all.
- Women need to create accounts and participate in voting
- Post more articles by women
- Have candid and honest conversation. Don't condescend
I almost think not being condescending and promoting an article because the author is female is contradictory. An article should stand on its own merit. This is really a tech/startup forum. It'd be great if gender didn't matter here, right?
Furthermore, when men try to make money here, that's a-okay. But it's a problem if I try to monetize my work -- not just here, anywhere. Everyone seems to object to a woman wanting money for her work. Everyone seems to think women should do things out of the goodness of their hearts. Then I also get told I am crazy for suggesting that there is any connection at all between my gender and my persistent poverty.
It's really rather maddening.
You aren't supposed to condescend to anyone here. Asking that women not be condescended to is not asking for special treatment. It also doesn't mean you cannot critique their work.
Thank you for replying.
In my experience most male forum members have exactly the same experience. It is simply very difficult to be taken seriously, to have people invest the time to read and honestly consider your ideas, and just to get visibility at all, regardless of gender!
I appreciate you're actually taking the initiative to propose concrete actions to make our community more inclusive. However, your writing reeks of egotism. This is not a gendered thing. I and many others simply can't take seriously anyone who writes, "If you actually want real change, you could start by paying more attention to the things I suggest, acting on them and promoting my writing. But I imagine that won't happen at all."
But I will say, despite my agreement with it, that post of yours does not actually address this current subject of outrage. It is true that one component of harassment is the pervasive social attitudes held by the majority, and thus can be changed through social integration. But concentrated harassment also comes from a small minority that are either deliberately trolling, or so socially mistuned as to use a comments section as if it were a bar. All of the outreach and awareness is not going to change this latter group - think of Pascal's Wager for a date.
It's not that I don't "want" a solution to the latter. It's that I don't see how one, as envisioned, can exist. Education and awareness can shrink the quantity. Centralized sites with heavy moderation can shrink the quantity [1] [2]. Maybe even personal filtering-assistants could shrink the quantity. But at some level of fan-in it is still going to be present and require that people build their own mental defense.
[0] FWIW, I clicked the up arrow on that comment, and this one as well. But my votes don't actually count because it was determined that I upvote "low quality" comments - a year or two ago, anti-circlejerk comments were forced to really snipe.
[1] You have a post about rejecting offers for dates on HN. I don't believe I have ever seen such a proposal on HN (and I'm showdead=yes). I'm not refuting your experience, just contrasting - an event can be objectively extremely rare, yet still quite personal, intense, and resentment-forming.
[2] Furthermore, this ignores alternative avenues of contact - I don't think Medium passed along all this harassment itself. Which is why ambiguous "something" can't not imply some greater control over the wider Internet.
I have studied social phenomenon both formally and informally for a lot of years. In a nutshell, you do not need to announce that egregiously bad things are not okay when you establish a standard of real respect. Of course, that won't stop all of it. But the overall character of the experience can be modified.
> Of course, that won't stop all of it
This is the crux of my point. The egregious things are already outliers - I don't think hitting on someone has ever been within the HN community standards, and your anecdata implies the ratio is better than 1:10,000. At that rarity, it's going to be awfully hard to even analyze how to shrink that number further.
Rereading the original post, it seems like the specific unwanted behavior in this case is having random (male) readers try to friend a young woman on Facebook with hopes of hitting on her. If that ratio were actually under say 1:1000, I don't know that we'd even be here as a species.
If either situation were limited to a small town, there would be a manageable number of occurrences over a longer time with a wider social sphere to police them. But at Internet scale, a small chance times a stateless flash mob causes an immediate intense issue.
I don't believe the overall pattern of behavior where women get male attention that is motivated primarily by sexual interest is remotely as rare as you are suggesting. We would not be having this conversation at all if that were the case.
Women do get treated differently than men online. I am hardly the only one that sees that.
My ratios were meant as lower bounds. As in, I would expect at least 1 in 1000 readers to attempt to friend the author [0], especially as such an action can be plausibly denied as just friendly professional networking. In reality that number is much higher [1], but I'm using a conservative estimate to make the point that even if it is this rare, multiplied by a huge audience still creates an issue.
[0] I certainly wouldn't do so myself and I'm not condoning the behavior either. I'm just saying that there are going to be at least this many asshats.
[1] In fact I now see that the original post only had 3k views, so I should revise that to 1:100 - without contradiction.
This is not what is being said.
I think you have found a very small number of comments and extrapolated them to take a side on the argument you want to have.
And I think in doing so you are confusing the issue and hope of progression.
Firstly, what I am seeing said in these comments and in other articles and circles is that harassment is something that happens, something that is worse if you are seen as vulnerable, and many suggesting that more women are seen as more vulnerable than men.
As a response to that a lot of people are suggesting that perhaps vulnerable people should use pen names. The response to this is that pen names hamper the point of writing.
Nowhere have I seen serious claims that they were "begging for harassment".
What I have seen are people who receive hate simply for 'being ginger' in photo's on Reddit. People who are harassed and followed in the street for being obese or mentally ill. People who are teased and chased or excluded for being weaker or slower. People who receive hate for making political comments on Facebook or twitter. I have seen these people have real problems with those that harass them following and abusing them from site to site, stripping them of their self-worth.
These are the things I am not OK with.
I am also not OK with you marginalising the problems of others (which in this case appears to be any vulnerable person sporting a penis).
Men who write articles of any quality about helping elderly people learn to code might take some shit on message board comments, but none of them become the target of organized harassment campaigns.
The notion that women should write under pen names while men freely and safely claim credit for any random achievement is a perfect example of how this industry allows itself to be rigged against women. Women aren't even supposed to identify themselves --- when they do, they're just allowing themselves to be victimized by the forces of nature, which apparently include mobs of misogynist trolls.