You're definitely right that we can't share our ideas if we don't effectively communicate them. I know I deeply appreciate when people take the time to respond with comments to help make what I've shared better. +1 are always great, but comments are better :)
For me, how we write is as important as what we right - both need to be good enough to successfully communicate our ideas.
I also want to share that I often encounter copy-editing responses that I see as cover for bias. Not all copy-editing feedback is a cover for bias, but much of what I see is - I think this happens because it is easier and less risky to comment, critique or outright attack the form of a position rather than engaging with the with substance of the position.
The kind of bias I'm referring to, and the sort of responses it can lead to is described in this article:
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/fact-checking-is-largely...
Thanks for taking the time to share your thoughts on this. I really appreciate it.
Sean Yo
I see what you did there, and it suggests a playfulness that means a question I was crafting about the literalness of that statement can be dumped. If anything, you've demonstrated that the wrong word in the right place can carry an enormous subtext. This, though, is a layer beyond merely correct spelling.
That said, not all feedback is meant to be constructive - that can come across clearly, even on the internet. It's unfortunate that a young woman, clearly still in high school, felt torn down instead of built up.
The most important feedback I'd like to send to the young women who publish with us is that there's room for your voice and your opinion, and you'll be treated with respect.
It is a bad thing when it is used as a way to belittle someone. As a way to smugly dismiss their argument without having to actually examine it. That's bad, and it's common, and it's often done with a childish, passive-aggressive meanness of spirit. There's nothing inherently wrong with helping someone communicate better; it becomes a bad thing when it's used as a way to belittle someone and dismiss their argument on grounds that have nothing to do with the actual argument.
In this very thread, clifantic makes it clear that s/he will ignore what someone has to say if they are bad at expressing it.
one of the most valuable pieces of feedback?
Not nearly as valuable as feedback about the actual message, I would say. Even Shakespeare couldn't turn falsehood into truth by beauty of expression.
Here's the thing that you "I'm not writing a college essay!" people seem to miss - for a lot of us, keeping track of the difference between "your" and "you're" or "their", "there" and "they're" takes literally zero concentration. I'd go so far as to say that a majority of native English speakers have never, ever (since elementary school, anyway), mixed those words up accidentally. These aren't mistakes that non-native English speakers make either. Keeping track of proper grammar is, by far, the least difficult part of expressing thoughts in written form. If you're prone to making mistakes like that... you probably aren't very smart. And what you have to say probably isn't very profound. You really shouldn't be writing, you should be reading. You shouldn't be talking, you should be listening.
So basically you are the type of person that caused the problem being discussed here.
There is a difference between someone making mistakes and someone feeling the need to point them out in public or private, or to judge who should be writing.
Maybe they should be reading more. But who are you or any other anonymous person to comment on that. If you don't have anything nice to say...
For you. People think differently, and something that comes natural to you does not come natural to others.
I find it hard to take that argument seriously
I think you vastly overestimate how many people are aware of these things. The people that are aware, are only aware because of experience with assholes like you. You don't need to show off how clever you are that you know some pointless rule.
Like Jesus, how fucking arrogant and smug you must be to say "you probably aren't very smart" over a trivial grammar mistake. There may be some correlation between spelling errors and intelligence, but certainly not a 100% correlation.
Of course they were. There is a despicable passive-aggressive smugness that is far too common, involving demonstrating one's superiority by sniping at the medium (no pun intended) instead of addressing the message; it allows one to show off without having to take any risks. I've found it very common in circles in which many participants spent their formative years being clever and being told how clever they are.