News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:90 Cents of Every 'Pay-For-Performance' Dollar for CEOs A... by Florin_Andrei on Friday September 30, 2016 @01:18PM (#12613767)
> a generous severance package, as well as generous benefits if the company does exceptionally well, are on the table, to simultaneously soften the blow if he takes a bad risk

So a pay gap of up to (and sometimes over) 1000x between CEOs and rank-and-filers, given all the saving and investing that the CEO could do just like any Average Joe, would not be enough to "soften" any "blows"? Huh.

Re:90 Cents of Every 'Pay-For-Performance' Dollar for CEOs A... by charrondev on Friday September 30, 2016 @03:04PM (#12614542)
I never really understood why people think the pay gap between the CEO's and the rank-and-filers is such a negative thing.

If you look at walmart for example, and entirely eliminated the compensation of the CEO (19.4 million), and all executive vice presidents and CFOs (2.8, 10.8, 8.4, 10.1, 11.5, and 8.5 million respectively) and total them all up you get ~$71.5 million.

71,500,000 / 2,000,000 million employees = $34 dollars per employee per year of a raise. That's almost negligible, and if you assume minimum wage (7.25) 50 weeks a year, for 40 hours a week gives $14,500 / year, you get $35 / $14,500 = a .24% raise. That's less than a 2 cent per hour raise per employee if you completely slashed the salaries and compensations of the top executives.

Re:90 Cents of Every 'Pay-For-Performance' Dollar for CEOs A... by wpietri on Friday September 30, 2016 @04:27PM (#12615079)
You picked the an extreme example there. Walmart employs a zillion unskilled people. Similar numbers for Google would yield something like an extra $6,000 per employee per year.

But I think it's a negative thing because it's a sign of a shift in behavior. Look at the graph here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Executive_compensation_in_the_...

CEOs have gone from making 20x the average worker to 200x. Are CEOs ten times more amazing? If anything, I think they're worse. I think that, broadly, they've shifted their focus from economic value creation to generating the numerical appearance of success in ways that let them extract lots of money.

There's also the problem of worker motivation. Companies are human enterprises. The greater the wealth differential, the less the people doing most of the work will feel part of something bigger than themselves. As with Walmart, they may show up and do what they're told, but they are less likely to actually give a shit.

Re:90 Cents of Every 'Pay-For-Performance' Dollar for CEOs A... by charrondev on Friday September 30, 2016 @04:54PM (#12615226)
I definitely agree that they are not 10x more amazing, but I also find that in the case of a company like google any kind of pay differential has far less of an impact. Employees at google get paid enough, and have such great benefits that they are easily in the top few percentages of the economy. The same can be stated about many tech companies and their employees. Engineer salary and benefits are very comfortable at this particular point in time, because it is very in demand, and requires high levels of skill.

It seems at least from what I've noticed that the companies with the highest differential in terms of rank and file -> CEOs, tend to be the ones with some of the lowest barriers to entry and the lowest skill levels. This is a subject that I would love to see a detailed study on because what "it seems like" is not always the reality of the situation.

I used Walmart precisely because besides being an extreme example, it is one of the largest employers in North America by a good margin.

Edit: forgot a word.

Re:90 Cents of Every 'Pay-For-Performance' Dollar for CEOs A... by wpietri on Friday September 30, 2016 @08:19PM (#12615986)
Reasoning from extreme examples is unhelpful when you are asking people to consider the general case.
Re:90 Cents of Every 'Pay-For-Performance' Dollar for CEOs A... by caseysoftware on Saturday October 01, 2016 @12:14AM (#12616487)
Let's not guess.

According to Google search: "Google CEO Sundar Pichai made $100.5 million in 2015, according to a regulatory filing released Tuesday. The filing revealed that Pichai was paid a salary of $652,500, awarded restricted stock worth $99.8 million"

and according to Business Insider, Google has roughly 57k employees.

If we just take Pichai's $652k salary, it is +$11/employee/year which is a couple cups of coffee.

Alternatively, if take his entire compensation of $100M, it becomes +$1754/employee/year which is more tangible but still nowhere near the $6k/year cited in parent.

If we just consider salary, I think the multiplier between the lowest to highest paid is going to be lower than you expect in tech. It's really only visible in more low skilled industries.

Re:90 Cents of Every 'Pay-For-Performance' Dollar for CEOs A... by wpietri on Saturday October 01, 2016 @12:17AM (#12616498)
I'm following charrondev's approach; he was using total compensation for the easily findable executives.
Re:90 Cents of Every 'Pay-For-Performance' Dollar for CEOs A... by wpietri on Saturday October 01, 2016 @08:25AM (#12617572)
Oh, and, discussion on executive compensation always includes total compensation. For historical and legal reasons, much of the compensation growth happened in non-salary categories.
Re:90 Cents of Every 'Pay-For-Performance' Dollar for CEOs A... by jdavis703 on Friday September 30, 2016 @04:14PM (#12615016)
Walmart is an extreme example. If you read "Capital in 21st Century" you'll see a lot of the worries of inequality is caused by the general rise of "super managers." If you don't have time to read that massive book, I think this is a good summary: https://jesiwagle.wordpress.com/2015/01/16/super-managers-do....
Re:90 Cents of Every 'Pay-For-Performance' Dollar for CEOs A... by xorcist on Friday September 30, 2016 @05:08PM (#12615309)
I believe the reasoning is that it is negative if it hurts the company's bottom line. It's hard, if not impossible, to causally correlate CEO compensation with company profits so there is no reason to assume for example that "golden parachutes" pay for themselves. They don't. If company profits scaled with C-level compension, why not double their bonuses already? That's silly.

And what would compensation per employee be indicative of? Nobody is criticizing that. There can be tension in public companies between the board's interests and the shareholders'. Questions of compensation is a common source.

Re:90 Cents of Every 'Pay-For-Performance' Dollar for CEOs A... by kornish on Friday September 30, 2016 @04:14PM (#12615010)
When people talk about pay gaps between executives and rank-and-filers, they generally mean pay gaps between individuals, not pay gaps between collectives (in this case, the 7 executives vs the 2 million employees).
Re:90 Cents of Every 'Pay-For-Performance' Dollar for CEOs A... by brbsix on Friday September 30, 2016 @05:48PM (#12615462)
There's a popular narrative that CEO compensation is at the expense of workers, that workers could be paid a livable wage if only executives could do without their extravagent bonuses. It's commonly referenced with respect to Walmart. I believe this is the myth the OP was attempting to dispel.
Re:90 Cents of Every 'Pay-For-Performance' Dollar for CEOs A... by nkurz on Friday September 30, 2016 @01:51PM (#12614026)
The gigantic pay gap may be an injustice, but I think you are missing the subtlety of the theory. The worry is that the CEO will become too personally dependent on that 1000x salary to take "appropriate" risk. For example, assume that launching a new product line has a 50% chance of doubling the companies profit, a 25% chance of doing nothing, and a 25% chance of cutting the profit in half. For the shareholders, this is probably a good bet to take.

Then assume the CEO will be replaced if profits drop. In the absence of a "golden parachute", a CEO might reason that a 25% chance of being fired and loosing their cushy job makes the plan not worth pursuing. The theory (OP wasn't necessarily endorsing it) is that a rich severance package can better align the interests of the parties. While I personally think "cronyism" is a better explanation for the current situation, the theory is better than others I have seen.

Re:90 Cents of Every 'Pay-For-Performance' Dollar for CEOs A... by Florin_Andrei on Friday September 30, 2016 @02:02PM (#12614098)
> I think you are missing the subtlety of the theory

There's nothing "subtle" about a plain racket. And there's nothing subtle anymore, either, about bringing in the Ayn Rand style of "debating" by putting people down.

At 1000x pay gap, the CEO needs only work a few months to have nothing to worry about for the rest of his life. Anything on top of that, anything, is a luxury item.

"Risk" of what? Having to manage with only 2 yachts instead of the customary 3? Right, that's a serious existential threat, gotta mitigate it.

Shave a couple orders of magnitude off that pay gap, and then the argument might, just might, begin to make sense.

Re:90 Cents of Every 'Pay-For-Performance' Dollar for CEOs A... by nkurz on Friday September 30, 2016 @03:46PM (#12614796)
And there's nothing subtle anymore, either, about bringing in the Ayn Rand style of "debating" by putting people down.

I may be the one missing the subtlety now, but if you are referring to my phrasing, I didn't intend any insult. From your comment (voted below zero before I upvoted and replied) I felt you were being unreasonably dismissive of a potential explanation that I found interesting and had not heard before.

There's nothing "subtle" about a plain racket.

The theory offers an explanation of why stockholders might rationally offer a generous severance package to a CEO. I agree that the "racket" theory has greater explanatory power, but I found it worth contemplating alternative explanations. Maybe "subtle" is the wrong word? "Counterintuitive"?

the CEO needs only work a few months to have nothing to worry about for the rest of his life

In practice, though, CEO's worry tremendously about their ability to accumulate further wealth. I wouldn't be surprised if this worry increases the greater their current salary. And from the shareholders' point of view, it's the CEO's perceived risk that affects their decision making, not the actual risk.

Shave a couple orders of magnitude off that pay gap, and then the argument might, just might, begin to make sense.

Well, no. As a theory to explain current behavior, I think this theory is actually more applicable the greater the discrepancy in pay between the CEO's current job and the other jobs available if they are fired. You are right that the situation would be different the if the gap was less, but that doesn't mean the theory is not relevant when the gap is large.

Maybe you'd prefer looking at it from a "Prisoner's Dilemma" perspective. Assume you have a extremely-well-paid self-interested psychopath making the executive decisions for your company. Ideally, this would not be the situation you find yourself in, but let's assume it's the case.

Assume that as a rational (read, "amoral") shareholder you wish to maximize your gains, which is positively but nonlinearly correlated to the company's profitability. How do you best achieve this? Perversely (and to me counterintuitively) reducing the downside to the CEO for risky decisions may be a strategy with a positive return.

Re:90 Cents of Every 'Pay-For-Performance' Dollar for CEOs A... by charrondev on Friday September 30, 2016 @02:54PM (#12614469)
Who are you to tell a company how to manage itself and how much they can pay their employees? If the board feel a CEO generates that much value for their company they should definitely pay him/her what they are worth.
Re:90 Cents of Every 'Pay-For-Performance' Dollar for CEOs A... by nkurz on Friday September 30, 2016 @09:19PM (#12616142)
Who are you to tell a company how to manage itself and how much they can pay their employees?

A citizen, which is to say, part of a group that collectively decides the "rules of engagement" for corporations. Society has chosen to grant certain rights to corporations because society feels that properly regulated corporations are a net benefit. At the point where enough individuals decide that the benefits are no longer sufficient, new rules can and will be made.

There is (to me) nothing inherently sacred about allowing amoral corporations to operate in the manner that they decide is most effective for their interests. We've decided that minimum wages are acceptable, that maximum work weeks are a good thing, that certain styles of contracts are unenforceable, and if we wanted to, we could decide that excessive differences in pay are legally unconscionable.

There's always a danger that societally we'll make the wrong choices, and that new rules will do more harm than good, but I don't think there is any question that society has a "right" to make such rules? At least no more than there is question that society has the right to make and enforce any other law? Turning it around, who are you to tell us that we can't regulate these companies how we choose?

Re:90 Cents of Every 'Pay-For-Performance' Dollar for CEOs A... by drakonandor on Friday September 30, 2016 @02:23PM (#12614233)
Why do you think that the shareholders don't have a right to offer generous compensation packages to those they consider good leadership talent?
Re:90 Cents of Every 'Pay-For-Performance' Dollar for CEOs A... by Florin_Andrei on Friday September 30, 2016 @02:39PM (#12614364)
Why do I think something I don't actually think?

Shareholders, in theory, should have the right to make any decision that is legal and is advantageous to them. That's what I think should happen, in an ideal world.

The practice, however, is different. The entity that decides CEO compensation is not "we the people". It's more like the smoke-filled room at the Republican Party's HQ in The Simpsons.

Re:90 Cents of Every 'Pay-For-Performance' Dollar for CEOs A... by drakonandor on Friday September 30, 2016 @02:48PM (#12614417)
Shareholders do decide. You seem to be implying that shareholders are being cheated, however, if they are actually unhappy they can a. sell (or not invest in the first place if they don't like the representation they'll receive), or b. vote in a new board, or c. sue.

You are struggling hard to make a victim where everyone involved is happy.

Re:90 Cents of Every 'Pay-For-Performance' Dollar for CEOs A... by wstrange on Friday September 30, 2016 @06:43PM (#12615689)
I don't think it is that simple.

There is a tremendous amount of back scratching that goes on when setting executive pay.

The board hires pay consultants, the consultants are not going to rock the boat and suggest pay cuts, so they approve a nice increase over the current going rate. Rinse and repeat and you have out of control executive compensation.

Majority shareholders are often in the same position - very well paid, and well connected with other CxOs.

That leaves the rest of the shareholders along for the ride.

Re:90 Cents of Every 'Pay-For-Performance' Dollar for CEOs A... by Florin_Andrei on Friday September 30, 2016 @11:24PM (#12616399)
> You are struggling hard

Whenever I argue with a staunch defender of social inequality, the put-down tactics are par for the course. "You struggle", "you fail to comprehend the subtlety of the argument".

If doesn't take a PhD in psychology to understand why that is. For someone to be pro social inequality, they must believe they are already topkek - or are standing a very good chance to make it. If that is the case, then it's a simple matter of statistics that any random stranger is likely placed lower in the pecking order. Therefore they must be "struggling" to comprehend, etc.

There is no "struggle" when you're telling the truth. The higher cognitive load happens when you make stuff up from whole cloth - there are studies showing it, look it up.

> everyone involved is happy

In this reality, the trends in political news in the last several years show otherwise. Not sure about other realities.

Re:90 Cents of Every 'Pay-For-Performance' Dollar for CEOs A... by gaius on Saturday October 01, 2016 @05:05AM (#12617116)
It's not even that. A high-paid CEO is a prestige thing, like a status symbol, for a corporation. "We are great because our leader is great and as proof look how much he/she gets paid". It's like an individual flashing their gold Rolex (or in Marissa Mayer's case, a Cartier).
Re:90 Cents of Every 'Pay-For-Performance' Dollar for CEOs A... by wott on Friday September 30, 2016 @02:20PM (#12614206)
The kind of CEOs who get golden parachutes earn enough money in a single year to live a whole life on it without having a job again. There is absolutely NO risk whatsoever taken. There is not even any investment that they could lose either, it's only profit + more profit.
Re:90 Cents of Every 'Pay-For-Performance' Dollar for CEOs A... by wtbob on Friday September 30, 2016 @02:32PM (#12614311)
> The kind of CEOs who get golden parachutes earn enough money in a single year to live a whole life on it without having a job again.

You probably earn enough in a single year to live the rest of your life in a different part of the world, yet you continue to work, in part because you want your current standard of living.

Likewise, a CEO will want to continue to live at his current standard of living, or even better.

Re:90 Cents of Every 'Pay-For-Performance' Dollar for CEOs A... by knodi123 on Friday September 30, 2016 @03:50PM (#12614824)
The only thing that matters is your annual income and your expenditures. If you earn 1x as much as you spend, you're staying afloat. If you earn 30x as much, then a year of work covers 30 years of retirement.

The CEO of Kroger earned $13 million in his last year there, and called his own compensation "ludicrously high". I doubt he's spending a million a year, but even if he is, the ratio is indeed ludicrous. And he's nowhere near the high end for executive compensation.

Are you suggesting that the average top-tier executive lives a lifestyle in the same proportion of their income as the average software developer, or blue collar worker, or...? Really?

Re:90 Cents of Every 'Pay-For-Performance' Dollar for CEOs A... by Florin_Andrei on Friday September 30, 2016 @02:47PM (#12614414)
> a CEO will want to continue to live at his current standard of living, or even better

Al Capone and the robber barons had the same goals.