Maybe it's fine to duplicate existing functionality on the iPhone if you do it so badly that there's no danger of anyone actually using it.
Re:Opera Mini approved for iPhone
by whalesalad on Tuesday April 13, 2010 @04:36AM
(#1261410)
That's the overruling statement right there for most of this App store shenanigans.., if something sucks people won't use it, and it won't be a threat.
So, wait: you think it should have been rejected for not following UI conventions?
My first thought is that plenty of games have UIs built from scratch. I think the conventions are just that: conventions.
"Opera Mini's flagrant disregard for UI conventions would get any other app rejected."
Pretty much sums up my thoughts. It's bad on so many levels and somehow received special treatment.