Re:Can you explain the ICANN transfer?
by robalfonso on Friday September 30, 2016 @10:38AM
(#12612700)
Just to add on to this. The NTIA has never exercised much in the way of oversite/interference. The largest issue I can recall was they got involved when the .XXX tld was being implemented.
As you say the actual running of ICANN/IANA and the internet at large is really managed under a multi stake holder model and is very inclusive and diversified.
Arguments to the contrary are typically FUD.
Re:Can you explain the ICANN transfer?
by drmcninjaturtle on Friday September 30, 2016 @06:23PM
(#12615599)
So why is it impossible for the UN to exert similar political influence?
In addition, ICANN the organization will have new accountability measures that will allow the community to challenge decisions it makes. It provides new powers like spilling its Board under certain circumstances.
One of the main drivers to change the current setup is NTIA's role above is seen as undue US government influence in what should be a purely technical operation by many. Over the years some have advocated fundamentally altering how ICANN works (like moving it to the UN) because of the US Government's influence. By transferring the primary oversight role to the multi-stakeholder community (users, business, non-profits, etc.) who have always really driven ICANN's decisions anyway, it is hoped that that criticism will go away and pressure to fundamentally alter how it works will dissipate.