News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:ORWL – The first open source, physically secure computer by JohnStrange on Thursday September 29, 2016 @01:31PM (#12607130)
It's criminally irresponsible to sell such a computer, because it will easily result in data loss and not all users are educated enough to understand the consequences of such a flawed "security" design. Of course, you can claim that it's ultimately the customers fault in this case, and I agree, but they should nevertheless expect some lawsuits.

There is always a tradeoff between security and data integrity, something which the people who downvoted my post apparently don't understand. When even your mom can mount a 100% successful denial of service attack with a screwdriver, then you're screwed.

If you disagree, I challenge you to show me a use reasonable case that couldn't also be solved by actual physical security or by locking down booting and the BIOS and using tamper-evident seals.

Re:ORWL – The first open source, physically secure computer by jamesgeck0 on Thursday September 29, 2016 @01:57PM (#12607361)
It's not illegal or irresponsible to sell a computer that deletes data when tampered with when "deletes data when tampered with" is _advertised as one of the primary features of the machine_.
Re:ORWL – The first open source, physically secure computer by JohnStrange on Thursday September 29, 2016 @02:18PM (#12607552)
I agree "criminally irresponsible" was the wrong choice of words and I rightly got flamed for it.
Re:ORWL – The first open source, physically secure computer by loup-vaillant on Thursday September 29, 2016 @02:09PM (#12607469)
People should learn what a computer is. Those who don't will get screwed anyway.
Re:ORWL – The first open source, physically secure computer by howardbeware on Thursday September 29, 2016 @01:59PM (#12607367)
The same argument could be applied to nearly any product. Knowing how to use the product is the user's responsibility and helping educate users is the manufacturer's responsibility. If you don't have data back ups, regardless of the type of computer, then you're setting yourself up for disappointment.
Re:ORWL – The first open source, physically secure computer by JohnStrange on Thursday September 29, 2016 @02:17PM (#12607540)
True, maybe I overreacted. What worries me is that is apparently supposed to be sold as a general computing device. Tamper-resistant hardware may be used in the military to protect implementations and keys stored in hardware that will eventually get stolen. For other types of data stored? Probably not so much. As I said, reasonable uses for this kind of device are limited.

For ordinary users, deleting everything immediately when someone tampers with it is a recipe for disaster. Sure, they can backup everything in encrypted form, but then the data is not really deleted when somebody tampers with the machine, isn't it?

Regarding the security, well, apart from software-based attacks, how about installing a tiny USB keylogger inside a USB cable that is already used by the user? Or in the keyboard itself? Or a camera that records your keystrokes?

That's what the <insert agency or special interest group of your choice> would be doing in such a case.

Re:ORWL – The first open source, physically secure computer by 0xdeadbeefbabe on Thursday September 29, 2016 @02:31PM (#12607681)
> Knowing how to use the product is the user's responsibility

Not all products are the same. It's irresponsible, but maybe good business strategy, to presume a complicated computer, which runs software that no human can hold in their head is the same as other products people are accustomed to.

Re:ORWL – The first open source, physically secure computer by nixos on Thursday September 29, 2016 @02:35PM (#12607720)
> tamper-evident seals.

Doesn't help when the tamperer isn't hiding