News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Region of the Americas is declared free of measles by kragen on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @01:08PM (#12599375)
It makes me really unhappy to see comments on HN that liken human beings to garbage, even if they are ignorant human beings making dangerous choices. It makes me even more unhappy to see that such a comment is the #1 voted comment on a front-page story. If this situation is not corrected today, I will take a one-year break from commenting on HN. I encourage anyone else who values basic decency to other human beings to join me.
Re:Region of the Americas is declared free of measles by gojomo on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @03:52PM (#12600759)
You may be mis-parsing the parent comment. The phrase…

Thanks to all the anti-vaxxer "do your own research" garbage people.

…can also be interpreted as…

Thanks to all the anti-vaxxer people and their "do your own research" garbage.

That is, the garbage is the "do your own research" rejection of expertise, not the people themselves.

Participating in group discussions requires charitable reading, so if a 1st way of reading the comment makes you so disgusted you must storm out in protest, but a 2nd way of reading the comment lets you continue to participate, you should consider adopting the 2nd interpretation.

But perhaps, given the existence of 'garbage people' as a separately-occurring slur, you've read it as the writer intended. [And indeed I now see a confirmation from the original author, that labeling anti-vaxxers as 'garbage people' was their intent.]

Still, it's a throwaway bit of word-choice to indicate the speaker's anger and disgust at the situation. They (and their up-voters) likely believe, and with some justification, that the choices of these anti-vax people have put their own health at risk.

A bit of anger is natural in that situation, and language only has so many ways to express anger against others' practices. Every way of expressing that anger will in some way be seen as a slur against those people, lowering their relative-status, rejecting their choices, and rallying others to take corrective actions.

As long as those corrective actions don't include actually treating people like 'garbage' – destroying/disposing them – such adjectival choices should usually be forgiven as concise rhetorical flourishes. Most of the world communicates in such sloppy, emotional ways. Enforcing a standard of clinical precision and coolness, and careful word-choice against any ugly implications against any humans, would in fact exile many people, with valid perspectives, from your conversations.

Re:Region of the Americas is declared free of measles by bostonpete on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @01:15PM (#12599432)
I share your distaste but I'm not sure bowing out of the conversation for a year is the best way to bring about change.
Re:Region of the Americas is declared free of measles by kragen on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @01:26PM (#12599521)
Let me explain a little further.

As of 2016-08-28, we have reached a point where the most upvoted comment on a popular post is vilifying ignorant people as "garbage". That means the problem is not one person or a small group of people; the majority of the active users on the site endorse such dehumanizing tactics. Of course, like everyone else, without listening to you, they won't be able to tell when they're actually the mistaken ones. But they won't be able to listen to you if they begin the process by deciding that you are subhuman scum.

Consequently, dialogue is impossible.

The best way to bring about change, barring immediate decisive action by moderators here, does not involve trying to bring it about on this website. It has become part of the problem. Maybe it always was by its very nature.

Re:Region of the Americas is declared free of measles by splawn on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @01:35PM (#12599603)
You shouldn't leave. The comments you posted here are waay more effective than leaving. I made the offending comment and even though I do think anti-vaxxers are garbage people... I do agree with your point that saying so is bad for discussion. Because of that, I would edit the word out now if I could... Thanks for speaking up.

Edit: for clarity