Re:Uber-owned Otto to offer freight hauling services using a...
by thesimpsons1022 on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @01:04PM
(#12599346)
don't want to sound elitist but a lot of us will consider the driverless car successful if we get it working in places like california and ny and completely ignore rural areas
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Uber-owned Otto to offer freight hauling services using a...
by new_hackers on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @06:42PM
(#12601946)
I don't want to sound pragmatic, but I will consider the driverless car successful if we get it working in places like Kansas or eastern Colorado, and completely ignore highly unpredictable, densely populated urban areas.
If you are taking a long trip, or hauling freight, then I'd rather get out on the open road, turn on the AutoPilot and take a nap, or do something more productive with my time.
Re:Uber-owned Otto to offer freight hauling services using a...
by protomyth on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @01:31PM
(#12599562)
You do realize this is an article on freight hauling? Perhaps you might want to look up where a lot of freight originates or passes through (or even the picture in the article).
Re:Uber-owned Otto to offer freight hauling services using a...
by thesimpsons1022 on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @02:05PM
(#12599842)
what i've heard a lot of people say is that that human drivers would still drive in rural and suburban areas. but most of the time spent driving is on large well established highways which are accurately mapped and could easily
be handled by automation.
Re:Uber-owned Otto to offer freight hauling services using a...
by protomyth on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @03:09PM
(#12600371)
What do you consider "large well established highways"?
Re:Uber-owned Otto to offer freight hauling services using a...
by dx034 on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @03:32PM
(#12600576)
For example all interstates in the US. I guess a significant proportion of trucks spends more than half their time on interstates. And if the driver can relax there, they are more alert again when driving in the city for the last miles.
Re:Uber-owned Otto to offer freight hauling services using a...
by galdosdi on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @04:10PM
(#12600901)
I wouldn't be so certain that "all interstates in the US" are uniformly easy to drive. A specific counterexample: the BQE (Brooklyn Queens Expressway) is technically signed as I-278, but poor maintenance, frequent and shortened ramps and interchanges, and idiosyncratic local driving culture would IMHO make it quite a bit more challenging for automated driving than the proverbial four lane interstate through a midwestern cornfield in the middle of nowhere that you probably were thinking of...
Re:Uber-owned Otto to offer freight hauling services using a...
by dx034 on Thursday September 29, 2016 @02:20AM
(#12603595)
For trucks it's still easier to drive there automatically as they have less lane changing than other cars. And your example is from a city. I think the time drivers spent in a city is not what makes the job so hard, it's the endless hours driving through the middle of nowhere. Automating that could be a huge gain already.
As an example, consider freight from LA to SF. The driver would still drive until he leaves LA, the truck would drive up the I-5 and the driver takes over again south of SF. In the end, the driver only had to drive for 30% of the time and could be more alert during that time (and spend his time with sth useful in the meantime).
Re:Uber-owned Otto to offer freight hauling services using a...
by protomyth on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @05:51PM
(#12601633)
"I guess a significant proportion of trucks spends more than half their time on interstates."
I would have to look at actual figures, but my gut feeling given the truck routes around us is that might be suspect. I'll echo galdosdi on the rest, the interstates aren't exactly easy.
Re:Uber-owned Otto to offer freight hauling services using a...
by TheCoelacanth on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @04:05PM
(#12600855)
Limited access highways that have on/off ramps instead of intersections.
Re:Uber-owned Otto to offer freight hauling services using a...
by ghaff on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @01:12PM
(#12599416)
You do realize that both California and New York have very large rural areas?
Re:Uber-owned Otto to offer freight hauling services using a...
by thesimpsons1022 on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @02:04PM
(#12599823)
yes i do. but i believe we can handle those. handling the rural areas between LA and SF is very manageable. It's essentially just driving straight on the 5 freeway. Also, all the tech companies are here and probably would be willing to hammer out the details for the cars to work only in california as it is a lot more manageable. just like tesla has supercharger stations all over california so you can drive anywhere. don't think it's quite the same in other states.