Re:Region of the Americas is declared free of measles
by epistasis on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @12:55PM
(#12599262)
>who don't trust current vaccine combinates.
These are not so different, though. There's no reason to not trust the current schedule and combinations, other than as a reactionary position to be so utterly wrong and shut down about the risks of vaccines. It's precisely the same stupidity, based on nebulous distrust and ignorance.
> But: In general I'd guess that no human is ever convinced by being belittled. Spraying hate (not you personally) and incomprehension only helps the own moral compass, not the cause nor the conversation.
In public discussions, there are many people to convince, not just the person advocating a viewpoint. If somebody has argued themselves into being anti-vax, changing their minds is not usually possible. They are 99% of the time a lost cause. I say this as somebody who has tried, tried so hard, on many approaches.
In my experience, the ridicule is borne from two directions: 1) fatigue of dealing with people that should be reasonable but are being fundamentally dishonest and tribalistic, and 2) preventing others from thinking that anti-vaxxers' "arguments" are worth anything except belittlement.
If a person doesn't like vaccines, I may try to convince them, but it's far more important to stop the lies from being perpetuated to more people than it is to convince just that single person. One of these goals is possible. Public discussion counts tremendously in these matters. I don't have to accept racist views without calling them out with force, and I certainly don't need to accept anti-vaxxer views without calling them out with force. There are times to convince and gently guide an individual, and a time to prevent them from poisoning the world. The way I talk about racism on a public forum is going to be different when dealing with a racist Uncle; different audiences and different approaches.
These are not so different, though. There's no reason to not trust the current schedule and combinations, other than as a reactionary position to be so utterly wrong and shut down about the risks of vaccines. It's precisely the same stupidity, based on nebulous distrust and ignorance.
> But: In general I'd guess that no human is ever convinced by being belittled. Spraying hate (not you personally) and incomprehension only helps the own moral compass, not the cause nor the conversation.
In public discussions, there are many people to convince, not just the person advocating a viewpoint. If somebody has argued themselves into being anti-vax, changing their minds is not usually possible. They are 99% of the time a lost cause. I say this as somebody who has tried, tried so hard, on many approaches.
In my experience, the ridicule is borne from two directions: 1) fatigue of dealing with people that should be reasonable but are being fundamentally dishonest and tribalistic, and 2) preventing others from thinking that anti-vaxxers' "arguments" are worth anything except belittlement.
If a person doesn't like vaccines, I may try to convince them, but it's far more important to stop the lies from being perpetuated to more people than it is to convince just that single person. One of these goals is possible. Public discussion counts tremendously in these matters. I don't have to accept racist views without calling them out with force, and I certainly don't need to accept anti-vaxxer views without calling them out with force. There are times to convince and gently guide an individual, and a time to prevent them from poisoning the world. The way I talk about racism on a public forum is going to be different when dealing with a racist Uncle; different audiences and different approaches.