Yes, risks should be honestly assessed, both for individual vaccines and the whole schedule. Yes, there exist vaccines which have questionable benefit, and there exist vaccines with higher risks that only make sense in certain situations.
None of this detracts from the abject denial of reality that is embodied in someone who has decided not to vaccinate their kids at all...
I didn't suggest that it should comprise an argument for an automatic rejection of all vaccines. Quite the opposite, actually.
But, if you acknowledge that some vaccines have questionable benefit and higher risks that don't make sense for all, then it begs the question: who decides?
Seems to me parents should have discretion there. Now, it comes down to whether you agree with their tolerance for risk.
To be clear, I think vaccines are mostly wonderful. I just don't think it's my place to go around thumping people on the head about the choices they make for their own children.
If it's a question of personal discretion, shouldn't the parent of one those children have the discretion to force others to be vaccinated, in order that their own child won't die?
You asked "who decides?".
Jacobson v. Massachusetts (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jacobson_v._Massachusetts ) decided "that it is within the police power of a state to provide for compulsory vaccination. That case and others had also settled that a state may, consistently with the federal Constitution, delegate to a municipality authority to determine under what conditions health regulations shall become operative. Laurel Hill Cemetery v. San Francisco, 216 U. S. 358. And still others had settled that the municipality may vest in its officials broad discretion in matters affecting the application and enforcement of a health law. Lieberman v. Van de Carr, 199 U. S. 552."
That quote comes from Zucht v. King, https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/260/174/case.htm... , which settled that a city could require vaccinations in order for a child to attend school.
You may not like it, but Prince v. Massachusetts (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prince_v._Massachusetts ) established that "the government has broad authority to regulate the actions and treatment of children. Parental authority is not absolute and can be permissibly restricted if doing so is in the interests of a child's welfare."
So yes, the parents have some discretion. It isn't absolute.
We have a government in part so we can collectively make hard decisions like this one.
I don't know how the count of these "unvaccinatable" people compares to those who suffer adverse reactions from vaccines, but it grows even stranger to demand that everyone assume risk for even smaller segments of the population; especially if the primary argument is a common welfare numbers game.
BTW, FWIW, some pretty heinous activities have been conducted in the name of the common welfare, including human experimentation. I'm obviously not saying this is happening here; only that "because common welfare" is not an ipso facto rationale. We've all benefitted from experiments, etc. at the expense of others. But, we later acknowledged that some of these things were completely unethical because, at some point, the rights of the individual trump even the common welfare.
Anyway, clearly the government has decided. My question was who should decide?
More specifically, I was speaking to the parent comment's acknowledgement that some discrimination among vaccines is prudent. At the same time, the commenter expressed anger over parents opting out of vaccines. Well, if discrimination is warranted but the commenter is angry about someone else's manner of discrimination, then that boils down to the commenter believing he/she should be the one who decides.
Again, I believe vaccines are generally beneficial, however, I also believe it's wrong to berate parents who don't blindly follow the vaccine schedule. The relatively low percentages of serious adverse reactions are little comfort when you're the one who is impacted. I'm just not prepared to demand that someone else do anything to their bodies for my sake, at any risk to him/her.
Government policies also agree "that some discrimination among vaccines is prudent". That why some are mandatory and some are voluntary. That's why the polio vaccine switched from using attenuated live viruses to dead ones, even though the latter isn't as effective.
There is no requirement that everyone follow a vaccination schedule. As I pointed out, there are good medical reasons for why someone might not be vaccinated.
The question is, should non-medical reasons be enough to justify a variance? Should a general sense of malaise be enough? Or, if someone expresses a concern that their child might get ill as a result of a vaccine, and that concern - based on knowing the counts rather than expressed by people who don't - has already been factored into the decision to require vaccination, then should the opinion of one non-expert parent overweigh the opinions of thousands of experts made as the result of decades of study, with open publications and public participation, and repeated in scores of countries?
Any absolute statement like yours, which says the parent's discretion comes first, means there is no way to keep a parent from heinous activities, nor for that matter can children be required to go to school.
We see this tension already for Jehovah's Witnesses, where doctrine prohibits the use of blood transfusions. If a 2 year old needs surgery which requires a blood transfusion, should the JW parent have a right to let the child die in order to follow the faith? The US says (as do other countries) the doctor has the right to overrule the parent's wishes in that case.
Do you want otherwise?
Actually, it's that counter-argument that's meaningless. The (rather obvious and enormous) difference is that no one is demanding that everyone else do something according to those parents' discretion. It's actually the point here.
>Government policies also agree "that some discrimination among vaccines is prudent".
It's odd that people are so trusting of "the government" in this one area. The mandatory vaccine schedule most certainly features vaccines for illnesses that are generally self-limiting, and for which the benefits are arguable, even for "experts" (gasp!).
>There is no requirement that everyone follow a vaccination schedule.
Huh? Your previous comment stated that I might not like it, but the government decides; then it painstakingly laid out supporting case law. Don't know what you're trying to say.
>The question is...
That whole paragraph progresses into a slippery-slope of increasingly discretionary rationale that highlights why people should have ultimate control over their own bodies. Yes, we could keep listing rationales until, eventually, even you might find a reason for pause.
And, your trust in the purity of the process is interesting.
>and repeated in scores of countries?
The schedule is not uniform and countries disagree over specific vaccines. Kind of blows your whole theory. Now, which "experts" do you trust to decide what you must pump into your kids?
>*We see this tension already for Jehovah's Witnesses...Do you want otherwise?
False equivalence.
You haven't added anything new. Even your complaints about 'trusting of "the government"' are older than my parents. By "added nothing new", I mean that the existing policies have long since tried to respect people with viewpoints similar to yours.
You haven't proposed anything better than what we have now. All you seem to want to do is throw away a framework which has seemed to mostly work for generations.
You also malign me and the system with your statement "trust in the purity of the process". No system is pure, including whatever alternative you might propose. But yes, the vaccine system we have is a lot more transparent and externally verifiable than most of what goes on in government. What angels do you think will run things for us?
Of course different countries have different vaccine policies. The world isn't in lock-step, different countries have different levels of wealth and medical care, and many diseases are only regional. Most people in the US don't need the typhoid vaccine or yellow fever viral vaccine, even if they are required in places where those diseases are common.
The case law says that children with contraindications and adults are not required to follow a vaccination schedule. That's what I mean when I say that children with a medical reason do not need to follow the schedule.
"It's the best we got, so sit still while I ram it down your throat" seems to be your argument.
I'm not "anti-vaccine", but you seem to feel a need to lump me into that group in order to trot out the same tired lambasting of anyone who even raises his hand with a question. Calm down.
>different countries have different levels of wealth and medical care, and many diseases are only regional
I'm not talking about developing countries and I'm not talking about yellow fever. Look up the history of the varicella vaccine in Britain, for example. So, the set of vaccines you'd demand of others would be different based on the opinions of experts in your locale. And, you see nothing wrong with continuing to make those demands? No room for questions? OK.
I won't even refute the statement about maligning you, etc. I don't have the energy to continue pointing out the contradictions.
Have you been living under an anti-intellectual rock for over two centuries? Modern representative republics and bureaucracies were invented for this exact reason. We elect people we trust to implement bureaucracies in the best interest of the people so that we can receive guidance from real experts that we can trust. This democratic system of electing representatives and appointing experts to regulatory agencies has eliminated polio and smallpox, improved automobile safety a hundred fold, improved air and water quality across the country by a thousand fold, made safe air travel possible, all but eliminated industrial scale food poisoning, led the country to several moon landings, and countless other achievements. This system has also decided that vaccination is critically important to public health based on decades, if not centuries, of hard evidence and that no one has absolute freedom over themselves or their children because there exist life altering consequences for everyone in the case of vaccines.
If you don't like that social contract, you are free to elect different representatives or move to the autonomous regions of Somalia (you'll really want to get vaccinated though).
Thanks for the Great Rant of Obvious Facts, none of which were being disputed.
Not sure why it's all or nothing.
Because biology. Because anyone who isn't vaccinated is a potential carrier for the disease, which allows it to mutate and defeat the immune system protections created by the vaccine in everyone else. Because those who refuses to vaccinate, especially the mandatory schedules, are selfishly avoiding a tiny risk and instead putting everyone else at much greater risk.
They should be thumped, when airing their views in public, so their ignorance doesn't spread.
But, this shouldn't lead to the complete discrediting of concern over the risk, as is often the case. To be clear, I'm not suggesting that you're doing so here.
Likewise, it shouldn't lead to a blind allegiance to a mandatory vaccine schedule, irrespective of what new vaccine pops up on it. That is, the risk-benefit equation should be evaluated per vaccine, not per the schedule as a whole.