News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Uber-owned Otto to offer freight hauling services using a... by pedrosorio on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @11:06AM (#12598206)
"I wrote a lane follower by taking 20-30 lines of pixels off an NTSC frame grabber on an Intel 486. The core algorithm was on the order of 100 LoC, and we took second place. Super simple algorithm, hardly intelligent."

How is this relevant to self driving cars in 2016 and the following decades?

Re:Uber-owned Otto to offer freight hauling services using a... by seibelj on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @11:21AM (#12598351)
I think he/she is arguing that what people are "ooing" and "ahhing" about is not really that amazing or novel, it's the infinite number of edge cases that will kill people regularly that is difficult and will not be solved for quite some time.
Re:Uber-owned Otto to offer freight hauling services using a... by Hydraulix989 on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @04:31PM (#12601101)
Yes, that reminds me of the stretch on the 101 near Palo Alto that has two sets of lane markings (one old and slightly faded out but still very visible, and one newly repainted). Of course, drivers should only follow the newly painted set of lane markings.

Even as a human, I get confused while driving on this stretch. The old lane markings aren't quite faded out enough to easily tell them apart. As I'm driving, I see every other car slowing down and "dead reckoning," too.

How will the run-of-the-mill self-driving car's lane following handle this corner case? If it's a Canny edge detector (like most self-driving cars), it's definitely going to fail and find false positives.

Re:Uber-owned Otto to offer freight hauling services using a... by jayjay71 on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @04:41PM (#12601188)
Why do you assume most self-driving cars use Canny edge detection? And even if they did, you can simply have the algorithm choose the higher threshold (with some other sanity checks, suck as are the lines the expected distance apart) and ignore the lower threshold.

The algorithms for lane following are quite a bit more sophisticated than that though. Here's a paper from 2008, and there are other approaches as well.

http://www.vision.caltech.edu/malaa/publications/aly08realti...

Re:Uber-owned Otto to offer freight hauling services using a... by Hydraulix989 on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @10:50PM (#12602997)
Hough lines/RANSAC are definitely on the same level of ad-hoc sophistication as Canny edges (in fact, Canny edges are often done as a preprocessing step for the voting scheme used by the candidate Hough lines).

Take a look at Figure 12 for an exemplary look at its failure cases -- cases that are much less forgiving than the aforementioned Palo Alto stretch 101 lane markings.

Re:Uber-owned Otto to offer freight hauling services using a... by DaiPlusPlus on Thursday September 29, 2016 @08:55AM (#12604846)
I'd have thought road-marking interpretation would nowadays be based on something more elaborate, such as HOG, without the need for an initial edge-detection pass.

(But in this case, I'll add that HOG doesn't solve the problem of overlapping old/new road markings)

Re:Uber-owned Otto to offer freight hauling services using a... by mtgx on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @01:19PM (#12599468)
That's why I disagree with Elon Musk and others who say "autonomous driving systems only need to be like 50% or 2x better than the average driver".

What if I drive 5x better and safer than the "average driver"? Doesn't that mean that these cars would now put me in more danger than I would normally be in with my own manual car?

Self-driving cars should be 10x better than the best (as in safest by number of incidents, say, per decade) drivers on Earth. Then I could begin trusting them ... if only there wasn't that pesky security issue, too, with self-driving cars getting hacked and then driving you off the highway at 70mph and killing you.

We see Teslas getting remotely hacked. If that happens with Tesla, a Silicon Valley car company with a lot of hired top tech talent, how can we ever trust a company like GM or Volkswagen to build safe self-driving cars?

Re:Uber-owned Otto to offer freight hauling services using a... by dllthomas on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @03:37PM (#12600612)
> What if I drive 5x better and safer than the "average driver"?

Then don't use the system?

You are giving thresholds - 50% to 2x better, 10x better. Before what? Before we ban manual driving? "10x better than the best driver" might make sense. Before we allow it on the road? Why not "better than the worst drivers we allow on the road"?

The most relevant point for Musk is probably "before the marketing works out". The market of people who consider themselves "substantially below average" drivers is much smaller than the market of people who consider themselves "not all that much better than average".

Re:Uber-owned Otto to offer freight hauling services using a... by bsder on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @02:56PM (#12600266)
> What if I drive 5x better and safer than the "average driver"? Doesn't that mean that these cars would now put me in more danger than I would normally be in with my own manual car?

Because you are unlikely always that.

Are you tired? Do you have a cold? Are you hungry? Are you playing with the radio? Are you having a conversation with a passenger?

The huge advantage that self-driving cars will have is integrated systemic control from multiple sensor sources and multiple transducer outputs--and they will never get distracted.

Human drivers have mostly 1 input: vision. Human drivers have mostly two outputs: hand and foot.

The lag in that system from input to output is >100ms even if you are perfect (I will grant you an exception if your name is Michael Schumacher).

Automated systems will have far more inputs. Multiple vision sources. Multiple radars. Temperature readings. RPM readings. etc.

Automated systems have far more outputs. Steering is the same. Brakes on individual tires is the big starter. With electric, individual suspension becomes feasible. Transmissions change form and become electrically controlled.

And the lag in the system is probably <10ms. That's huge. That's the difference in reacting in roughly 3 meters (2.7 meters) vs 1/3 of a meter at 100kph (9 feet vs 1 foot roughly for 60mph).

Finally, automated systems will take subtle preventative actions all the time. They will "see" the child on bicycle on the sidewalk (the idiot detector as Google called it) and "know" that they need to find him again when they attempt to turn right or slow down significantly. They will see the dude on a skateboard and know that they need to give him an extra couple feet if they can in order to deal with him falling. I know very few drivers that are that diligent.

Re:Uber-owned Otto to offer freight hauling services using a... by walshemj on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @03:13PM (#12600412)
yeh but humans have full AGI unless the culture comes calling (giz us a job dizzy) it isn't going to happen soon
Re:Uber-owned Otto to offer freight hauling services using a... by hx87 on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @06:29PM (#12601869)
AGIs aren't necessary to drive safely; a sufficiently advanced ANI will do.
Re:Uber-owned Otto to offer freight hauling services using a... by walshemj on Thursday September 29, 2016 @09:55AM (#12605236)
In all conditions? not all driving is on a clear day on a motorway.
Re:Uber-owned Otto to offer freight hauling services using a... by hx87 on Thursday September 29, 2016 @01:50PM (#12607289)
An AI that would be able to drive in all conditions (but not be able to do anything other than drive the car) would still be an ANI.
Re:Uber-owned Otto to offer freight hauling services using a... by maxerickson on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @03:17PM (#12600457)
If you are 5x better than the average driver, the most likely cause of any accident you are in will be the other driver.

Why wouldn't you want to make them better?

Re:Uber-owned Otto to offer freight hauling services using a... by hx87 on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @06:27PM (#12601861)
> What if I drive 5x better and safer than the "average driver"?

How do you know that you're actually 5x better than the average driver and not just deluding yourself?

Re:Uber-owned Otto to offer freight hauling services using a... by tim333 on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @03:24PM (#12600512)
Well ideally everything should be perfect but if a 2x system cuts US fatalities from 30k/yr to 15k are you going to ban it?
Re:Uber-owned Otto to offer freight hauling services using a... by jp555 on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @02:11PM (#12599885)
But even if you're the best driver around you 19/20 times you still drive now.

I don't see why you give wetware more leeway than hardware.

Re:Uber-owned Otto to offer freight hauling services using a... by phkahler on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @01:28PM (#12599538)
>> How is this relevant to self driving cars in 2016 and the following decades?

My point is that basic lane following can be done quite trivially, but it's nowhere near something one should entrust with the safety of human beings. Your question implies that you think all modern systems being deployed involve some really sophisticated AI. You don't know that.

Re:Uber-owned Otto to offer freight hauling services using a... by phkahler on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @01:32PM (#12599566)
As an example, anything using LIDAR is probably fundamentally incapable of robust object identification and tracking.
Re:Uber-owned Otto to offer freight hauling services using a... by Animats on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @01:34PM (#12599590)
Is that statement backwards?
Re:Uber-owned Otto to offer freight hauling services using a... by phkahler on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @04:17PM (#12600970)
>> Is that statement backwards?

Nope. LIDAR is used to determine geometry when a camera system can't tell WTF it's looking at.

Re:Uber-owned Otto to offer freight hauling services using a... by robotresearcher on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @08:26PM (#12602443)
But you stated that anything using LIDAR was not capable of robust tracking. Perhaps you meant that anything using LIDAR was doing so because camera-based tracking is not very robust. But that's not the straightforward interpretation of your statement.
Re:Uber-owned Otto to offer freight hauling services using a... by phkahler on Thursday September 29, 2016 @09:29AM (#12605037)
>> But that's not the straightforward interpretation of your statement.

Yes, that would be a communication problem of mine. It's something I'm working on ;-) But I would counter that LIDAR isn't going to fully make up for the problems of the camera based system with the result being a simple sounding statement like "if they're using LIDAR it's not good enough", or grossly oversimplified to "LIDAR sucks".

I will admit that LIDAR could conceivably enhance a really good vision system by offering better depth perception, but I don't believe that's why people are using it today.