News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Evidence That Computer Science Grades Are Not Bimodal [pdf] by taeric on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @03:41PM (#12592434)
I'm not clear on what the link is supposed to be getting me. Phonetics and Phoenician are two different things. Right?
Re:Evidence That Computer Science Grades Are Not Bimodal [pdf] by jdmichal on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @03:44PM (#12592466)
I agree that the post is severely underspecified. I think the point is the last paragraph of the linked section:

> Phoenician had long-term effects on the social structures of the civilizations which came in contact with it. As mentioned above, the script was the first widespread phonetic script. Its simplicity not only allowed it to be used in multiple languages, but it also allowed the common people to learn how to write. This upset the long-standing status of writing systems only being learned and employed by members of the royal and religious hierarchies of society, who used writing as an instrument of power to control access to information by the larger population.[11] The appearance of Phoenician disintegrated many of these class divisions, although many Middle Eastern kingdoms such as Assyria, Babylonia and Adiabene would continue to use cuneiform for legal and liturgical matters well into the Common Era.

That is, Phoenician was the first wide-spread phonetic script. That, in turn, had major effects on civilizations as it was simple enough for commoners to learn. That being the rather tenuous link back to the original idea of teaching reading based on phonetics.

Of course, there is a bit of a gap here, in that English phonetics are notoriously unstandardized across the lexicon.

Re:Evidence That Computer Science Grades Are Not Bimodal [pdf] by thaumasiotes on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @07:31PM (#12594196)
> Phoenician was the first wide-spread phonetic script. That, in turn, had major effects on civilizations as it was simple enough for commoners to learn.

The cuneiform of the time was, at heart, a syllabic script; while a phonetic script is arguably simpler, it's not much simpler. The real problem with cuneiform is not that it was syllabic instead of alphabetic, it's that you had plenty of options other than syllabic representation, as well.

(And written Egyptian, the parent system of the Phoenician alphabet, was already genuinely phonetic! It didn't have vowels, but neither did the Phoenician script.)

All that said, that sort of shortcut-encrustation seems to develop naturally within all writing systems. If I send someone "have a good day" and get back "u 2", that's exactly the kind of shortcut that we blast ancient writing systems for using. But that shortcut, in modern English, actually represents a very high literacy rate, and use of the writing system by someone who can't be bothered to observe its formal conventions. Under low-literacy conditions, educated people tend to scrupulously observe whatever weird conventions their writing system might have. That's how you know they're educated.

Re:Evidence That Computer Science Grades Are Not Bimodal [pdf] by jdmichal on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @10:30AM (#12597896)
I'm assuming by Egyptian you mean Hieroglyphics. (They also used Hieratic and later Demotic.) Hieroglyphics are a mixed phonetic-logographic system. Even on the phonetic side, there are many ways to spell the same set of consonants, thanks to the existence of digraphs and trigraphs and repetition. The vowels probably differed, but those aren't written. The spelling for a particular word was usually fixed, though.

Wikipedia has an excellent example using nfr in its determinatives section:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Egyptian_hieroglyphs#Determina...

So, Hieroglyphics had phonetic components, but it was far from being a phonetic abjad like Phoenician. (An abjad is an alphabet without vowel markers.)

Re:Evidence That Computer Science Grades Are Not Bimodal [pdf] by thaumasiotes on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @05:11PM (#12601394)
Hieroglyphics are a mixed phonetic-logographic system in the same way that English is a mixed phonetic-logographic system, where the second person pronoun can be represented by "you" or by the logograph u. How much is that hurting our literacy rate?
Re:Evidence That Computer Science Grades Are Not Bimodal [pdf] by jdmichal on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @05:33PM (#12601545)
"u" and "you" have exactly the same pronunciation /ju/. "2" and "two" and "to" and "too" all have exactly the same pronunciation /tu/. That is, phonetically there is no difference -- again, English has terribly inconsistent phonetics. These shortcuts arose due to texting applying negative pressure to the length of words, both in maximum message size and ease of input.

Compare this to Hieroglyphics, where the glyph representive of a loaf of bread could mean either an actual loaf of bread or the abstract phoneme /t/. Specifically, a logogram represents an idea regardless of its pronunciation. This is not what we see in "text-speak", where words were replaced with shorter methods of achieving the same phonetics. Or, in other words, reading the text "u 2" is /ju tu/, which is exactly the same as what you would read with "you too". The matched phonetics are an integral part of this replacement.

Re:Evidence That Computer Science Grades Are Not Bimodal [pdf] by thaumasiotes on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @07:23PM (#12602142)
> Compare this to Hieroglyphics, where the glyph representive of a loaf of bread could mean either an actual loaf of bread or the abstract phoneme /t/. Specifically, a logogram represents an idea regardless of its pronunciation. This is not what we see in "text-speak"

"u" does not have the pronunciation /ju/, it has the name /ju/.

And we specifically don't see that egyptian glyphs "represent an idea regardless of its pronunciation". Look at the story of the decipherment:

> Champollion focussed on a cartouche containing just four hieroglyphs: the first two symbols were unknown, but the repeated pair at the end signified 's-s'. This meant that the cartouche represented ('?-?-s-s').

> Champollion wondered if the first hieroglyph in the cartouche, the disc, might represent the sun, and then he assumed its sound value to be that of the Coptic word for sun, 'ra'. This gave him the sequence ('ra-?-s-s'). Only one pharaonic name seemed to fit. Allowing for the omission of vowels and the unknown letter, surely this was Rameses.

( http://www.bbc.co.uk/history/ancient/egyptians/decipherment_... )

That's the glyph "sun" being used because of the phonetic value of the word "sun" coinciding with part of a name. The idea goes unused (at least, the glyph is not marked with the logograph mark). That's precisely what we see in text-speak.

(Side note: while the vowel of Coptic "sun" might be /a/, this is a rare case where the ancient Egyptian vowel is known, and it is /i/. Fortunately, the general omission of vowels makes this mistake irrelevant.)

> "2" and "two" and "to" and "too" all have exactly the same pronunciation /tu/

This is not correct. "to" is a clitic; its pronunciation differs from the others, which means in particular that "to" and "2" have different pronunciations. That doesn't stop "2" from substituting for "to" on occasion.

Re:Evidence That Computer Science Grades Are Not Bimodal [pdf] by jdmichal on Friday September 30, 2016 @09:40AM (#12612339)
When you see an isolated letter "u" in English, you say /ju/. When you see the word "you", you also say /ju/. This fact is what allows "u" to be shorthand or abbreviation for "you". Perhaps for you there is no distinction between a shorthand and a logogram. But, in that case, I don't see how you also couldn't argue that "you" is a logogram for the abstract idea of the second person.

In reality, we separate between logograms and alphabets by the use of symbols representing ideas or sounds. In the English example, "u" is being used as a non-traditional phonetic digram /ju/. Your example from the Rosetta Stone was a phonetic use of the symbol. There are also non-phonetic uses, where the symbol represents the sun, regardless of its phonetics. This is why it's a mixed system.

The Egyptians marked semivowels /j~i/ and /w~u/. Egyptologists use them as vowels, because they have to use something and that's as good a thing as any. We have no idea how any ancient Egyptian word was realized.

Everyone I know produces all the variations of "to" the same. Maybe there is a dialectic difference.

EDIT: I just had a thought. Let's use an English example where the shorthand is not isolated. Let's look at "r8" for "rate". This is obviously not a logographic use of "8", as the "r" is still necessary for the meaning. Instead, "8" is again being used as a non-traditional phonetic gram, the trigram /eɪt/. The use of "u" and "2" is exactly the same; their use is as phonetic grams and not logograms.

Re:Evidence That Computer Science Grades Are Not Bimodal [pdf] by GregBuchholz on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @05:00PM (#12593154)
Sorry. I just found it amusing, that here we are, using the English alphabet (a descendant of the original Phoenician alphabet) talking as if phonetics as a reading aid is a new phenomena. But the whole reason the Phoenician alphabet became so popular 3200 years ago was it's use of symbols representing spoken sounds.
Re:Evidence That Computer Science Grades Are Not Bimodal [pdf] by 13of40 on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @06:10PM (#12593654)
Maybe the point is that deemphasized the phonics technique for 3000 years and focused more on lessons like this:

https://books.google.com/books?id=E-diAAAAcAAJ&dq=reading&pg...