News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:“Finland could employ some 2000-3000 developers immediately” by blfr on Monday September 26, 2016 @02:47PM (#12584503)
What makes Finns a morally meaningful group here is what makes family a morally meaningful group: blood ties and inheritance. It's not unfair that people inherit after their ancestors, whether it's a stamp collection, height, or a country.

I don't have an objection to people maintaining their own communities, closed or not. I believe in freedom of association. I'm not an American either so US taboos around race don't hold much sway over my opinions.

Re:“Finland could employ some 2000-3000 developers immediately” by yummyfajitas on Monday September 26, 2016 @03:34PM (#12584866)
Ok, fair enough. I guess that's our point of disagreement; I only believe in individual rights, and don't view any group as being special.
Re:“Finland could employ some 2000-3000 developers immediately” by blfr on Monday September 26, 2016 @03:37PM (#12584893)
You don't see your family as special for example? Just another random collection of individuals?
Re:“Finland could employ some 2000-3000 developers immediately” by yummyfajitas on Monday September 26, 2016 @03:57PM (#12585041)
I don't see a family as being a morally privileged group in the way you seem to.

For example, if A threatens B with violence should B employ C, I believe that's wrong. I don't believe it becomes morally acceptable if A and B are members of the same family, or the same ethnic or national group.

I believe parents owe a certain individual obligation to their children (due to the fact that they chose to birth them), but little else.

Re:“Finland could employ some 2000-3000 developers immediately” by blfr on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @04:55AM (#12588214)
You just restated the same thing without addressing the core similiarity.

If you consider the accident of birth in a certain country unfair. That is, Sven being born in Sweden and Sandeep in India which should be rectified by allowing Sandeep to move to Sweden (or Finland, or wherever), do you consider other instances of inheritance unfair?

For example, if Sven stands to inherit an apartment in Stockholm and a nice cabin in the woods, while Lucas' parents were renters who won't leave him much, should Sven's parents' estate be taxed at 100% to rectify this unfairness (or 50% to pass it to Lucas)? If not, why not? What is the principled objection?

It seems to me that both lines of arguments for inheritance (whether better capital allocation and stewardship, or simple blood ties) work just as well for material goods as they do for citizenship. And property is guaranteed by the threat of violence (often from the same actors) just like borders are.

Re:“Finland could employ some 2000-3000 developers immediately” by yummyfajitas on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @07:31AM (#12588750)
I restated my principle in terms of family because I don't think you disagree with my principle there. Do you think my brother should threaten me with violence if I employ someone other than his son?

I have no problem with individuals disposing of their property as they see fit. Just as Sven might like to pass his house to Lucas, I might like to rent my house to Jose the Mexican. And I object to laws that would prevent both of these things.

I guess another disagreement we have is that I don't see citizenship as property.