News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sweden Wants to Fight Disposable Culture with Tax Breaks ... by mseebach on Monday September 26, 2016 @08:59AM (#12581383)
The idea is great. The problems will be with the implementation, how it will change incentives, any loopholes introduced, cost of enforcement and unintended consequences.

What exactly is a repair? Are parts covered, or only labour? Think ship of Theseus. Is an upgrade a repair, can I put a better compressor, rather than like-for-like in my refrigerator when it's failed? Can I have my TV repaired by replacing all the parts, except the power cord? How broken must something be before it can be repaired? Totally failed, failure imminent, or just worn? (Unintended consequence: people have their things fixed long before it's strictly necessary, leading to greater waste than if they'd just let the thing fail and bought a new one. Another one: appliances are only upgraded to newer, much more energy efficient ones much later than otherwise).

And for labour, where is the line drawn? Is the labour cost of diagnosing a problem covered? What if the problem is bigger than expected, and it isn't economical to carry out the repair? What if I have you upgrade the Foo (not a repair), which is trivial, while you've taken the widget apart anyway to fix the Bar (a repair)? What about repairing something, pocketing the tax break, then selling it (perhaps outside of the country)?

Once you have considered all of these questions, you either have a lot of loopholes which will make the tax break much more expensive, or have a very long body of legal texts, and some very exited lawyers and auditors which will impose an indirect cost on society broadly.

Sure, it's pessimistic, but I'm essentially working backwards from an attempt to impose a tax on dietary fat (for health reasons) in Denmark. Sounds great, right? Hilarity ensued over mixed nuts (the accountants had a field day with that one, and IIRC all kinds of meat being taxed at the same level, and the tax was repealed after only 15 months.

Re:Sweden Wants to Fight Disposable Culture with Tax Breaks ... by AJ007 on Monday September 26, 2016 @10:09AM (#12581908)
A alternative approach could be taxing garbage. Perhaps inevitable once sensors become pervasive and cheap enough. Too some extent this is already done and enforced for disposing of blatantly dangerous things. In some cases you could end up in prison in addition to fines, if caught. The more subtle things that add up to a big problem have been given a lot of leeway.

Right now it is profitable for many parties to extract non-renewable resources, assemble them in to something that has a short life cycle, and be sold to consumers who would rather keep buying the same thing over and over again than a single time. There have been big incentives on the government side for hitting GDP numbers, which has led to both low interest rates and an urgency to extract and process non-renewable resources as quickly as possible. Capital utilization numbers certainly doesn't account for any of this and very well exacerbate the problem.

I don't want to confuse cause and effect here, but the consumption of low quality products directly relates to the volume which they are produced. The actual costs have just been transferred to the future. In the future there will be both fewer resources to produce those goods and more pollution/ecosystem effects to account for it.

At Berkshire Hathaway's shareholder meeting this year Charlie Munger specifically said he thought all petrochemical reserves would be eventually exhausted to make things, not for fuel (there was a specific word he used which I never use and forgot.) Billionaires are thinking about resource exhaustion. Poor, uneducated people are not, unless they are still in hunter-gatherer societies and see problems first hand.

We often think of food and bio-products as renewables, but in many cases they are not. National Geographic (August 2016) ran a great article on the exhaustion of the Ogallala aquifer. California gets a lot of attention, but ground water is being drained globally. Longer term, there may be limits with phosphorus as well. Food production is going to become a lot more expensive, global warming or not.

I don't know about the returns, but Al Gore's Generation Investment Management philosophically probably has the right approach.

The flipside to all of this is that technology can make using the same resources much more efficient. My leading theme for the past 5+ years or so has been exponentially more efficient technology running head on in to global government policies -- of all political leanings -- of creating GDP growth at all costs. The two don't mix, and the results could be very ugly.

Re:Sweden Wants to Fight Disposable Culture with Tax Breaks ... by athenot on Monday September 26, 2016 @11:24AM (#12582587)
Unfortunately, there is something far easier and cheaper (from the end user's perspective) to duming in a controlled landfill: dumping in random places.

It's been a long battle in many places to get people to properly dispose of their trash in a proper way, it's still way too easy to revert to prior behavior. In many places in the US, people have to pay a private company for disposal or haul their trash to a landfill (usually in more rural areas). So it's a very visible cost, making savage dumping more compelling.

Re:Sweden Wants to Fight Disposable Culture with Tax Breaks ... by acaciapalm on Monday September 26, 2016 @12:42PM (#12583342)
Exactly this. We socialize the cost of garbage disposal in the first world to disincentivize dumping. Worth it, IMO.
Re:Sweden Wants to Fight Disposable Culture with Tax Breaks ... by Kalium on Monday September 26, 2016 @02:45PM (#12584486)
Oakland, CA still has a dumping problem.
Re:Sweden Wants to Fight Disposable Culture with Tax Breaks ... by Grishnakh on Monday September 26, 2016 @11:16AM (#12582512)
>A alternative approach could be taxing garbage.

Ok, how do you keep people from dumping their garbage in someone else's garbage bin, or in some public place in the middle of the night?

This also doesn't really deal with the fact that different garbage has very different effects on the environment and society, and very different mass. "E-waste" frequently doesn't weigh that much, but has a lot of both valuable metals and also hazardous materials which can cause problems when dumped in a landfill. Mercury-bearing batteries are especially bad, but those don't weigh much at all. Some broken dishes, however, can easily weigh far more than old electronic gadgets or leaky batteries, but they're just pottery so they're completely inert and have zero negative environmental effects. And yard waste and kitchen waste isn't environmentally problematic at all, yet it can weigh a lot because much of it is water. It'd be better to compost it, but urban dwellers have no place to put a compost pile.

Re:Sweden Wants to Fight Disposable Culture with Tax Breaks ... by david-given on Monday September 26, 2016 @12:26PM (#12583195)
I live in Zürich. Here, you can only throw things away if they're in the proper bags, which cost about two francs for a 35 litre bag.

But taking stuff to the recycling centre is free, and there's usually one within five minutes walk of any given house.

The end result is that waste is basically self managed --- people are incentivised to recycle as much as possible and reduce waste. I remember hearing that disposal largely pays for itself, but I don't have a reference for that, so don't quote me.

(Fly tipping is basically unheard of.)

Re:Sweden Wants to Fight Disposable Culture with Tax Breaks ... by nommm-nommm on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @08:46AM (#12589170)
Many municipals in the US have similar policies with garbage, either pay for the special bags or pay per bin. Even at a small cost this often leads to dumping. I saw someone had dumped their trash in a cemetery. :(
Re:Sweden Wants to Fight Disposable Culture with Tax Breaks ... by vkou on Monday September 26, 2016 @11:34AM (#12582671)
> urban dwellers have no place to put a compost pile.

Curb-side compost pickup.

Re:Sweden Wants to Fight Disposable Culture with Tax Breaks ... by Grishnakh on Monday September 26, 2016 @12:41PM (#12583337)
Good luck getting the dysfunctional, incompetent, and corrupt local governments in America to implement that.
Re:Sweden Wants to Fight Disposable Culture with Tax Breaks ... by vkou on Monday September 26, 2016 @01:27PM (#12583763)
My dysfunctional, incompetent, and corrupt local government (In America) has managed to pick up my curbside trash once a week, for years.

Over the past year and a half, it's also managed to pick up my curbside compost. It's also managed to provide both electricity, and running water.

Most of America isn't some kind of lawless hellscape, filled with wandering ghouls, cursed with a hunger for human flesh (Despite what Randian fiction seems to claim.) Mandatory infrastructure tends to work, for some definition of working. (Now, if only the same could be said about Comcast...)

Re:Sweden Wants to Fight Disposable Culture with Tax Breaks ... by Grishnakh on Monday September 26, 2016 @04:25PM (#12585242)
>Most of America isn't some kind of lawless hellscape, filled with wandering ghouls, cursed with a hunger for human flesh (Despite what Randian fiction seems to claim.) Mandatory infrastructure tends to work, for some definition of working. (Now, if only the same could be said about Comcast...)

About half of it is. Visit the South sometime and you'll see. A lot of places still don't have recycling, much less compost pickup.

And as for mandatory infrastructure, the entire United States fails here: internet access is mandatory infrastructure in this day and age, just like running water was considered mandatory by the mid-20th century, and the US's internet infrastructure is pathetic (as you admit about Comcast).

Re:Sweden Wants to Fight Disposable Culture with Tax Breaks ... by vkou on Monday September 26, 2016 @05:40PM (#12585836)
Most of those places in the South don't have recycling precisely because they are too busy complaining about how terrible and inefficient and wasteful their government is, and how taxes and fines harm their freedom to throw whatever they want to in the garbage. To uncharitably generalize a bit.

There's that, and the belief that environmentalism is a communist plot, and that aluminum grows on trees.

If they wanted compost pickup, there'd be no reason why they couldn't have it. When you've solved curb-side garbage pickup, you've also solved curb-side recycling pickup, and curb-side compost pickup.

Comcast is a publicly traded firm.

Re:Sweden Wants to Fight Disposable Culture with Tax Breaks ... by floatrock on Monday September 26, 2016 @01:05PM (#12583545)
San Francisco sends its (mandatory) curbside compost up to Napa to grow our wine, and having lived through a couple ballot initiatives and largely-self-infliciated absurdly high rents here, I can think of no municipality that is more dysfunctional or incompetent.
Re:Sweden Wants to Fight Disposable Culture with Tax Breaks ... by wsinks on Monday September 26, 2016 @02:39PM (#12584438)
I had no idea that we sent it to Napa. I'm guessing we get paid pretty handsomely for it?
Re:Sweden Wants to Fight Disposable Culture with Tax Breaks ... by quadrangle on Monday September 26, 2016 @03:11PM (#12584715)
The small (<40k residents) American city I live in already has weekly curbside compost/yard-waste pickup.
Re:Sweden Wants to Fight Disposable Culture with Tax Breaks ... by donarb on Monday September 26, 2016 @03:06PM (#12584666)
Seattle does it.
Re:Sweden Wants to Fight Disposable Culture with Tax Breaks ... by ryandrake on Monday September 26, 2016 @11:05AM (#12582413)
Currently companies externalize the cost of disposing their products. You and I having to pay a bigger garbage bill is not going to change the behavior of the companies making all of this trash. If it were possible to query everything that went into a landfill, and bill the entire value chain proportionally for its disposal cost, THEN we might start to have a fair system and see changes. Current incentives are to produce the cheapest thing that will barely work for long enough that someone will buy it.
Re:Sweden Wants to Fight Disposable Culture with Tax Breaks ... by HillaryBriss on Monday September 26, 2016 @12:35PM (#12583287)
In California there's a paint-use fee tacked onto the cost of a gallon of paint when you buy it.

Of course, its main purpose is to pay for programs that safely manage the disposal of unused paint (i.e. you can take your extra unused paint to paint retailers for proper disposal.) But, this price hike should, at least in theory, reduce demand for paint a little overall.

Re:Sweden Wants to Fight Disposable Culture with Tax Breaks ... by ptaipale on Monday September 26, 2016 @06:38PM (#12586207)
>Currently companies externalize the cost of disposing their products.

At least Nordic countries have a system which shifts this burden to manufacturers or importers of stuff. It's called "product responsibility (fee)". (Producentansvar).

Small companies are excluded, the threshold is somewhere around 1M€ per year turnover.

Not sure if there is any EU wide regulation.I wouldn't be surprised if even some U.S. states had something similar.

Re:Sweden Wants to Fight Disposable Culture with Tax Breaks ... by dclowd9901 on Monday September 26, 2016 @11:46AM (#12582789)
Actually, they do. I believe at least electronics companies pay a small fee for every device to pay for its disposal. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electronic_Waste_Recycling_Fee
Re:Sweden Wants to Fight Disposable Culture with Tax Breaks ... by ryandrake on Monday September 26, 2016 @11:59AM (#12582920)
That's a pretty blunt instrument though. It looks like it just hits retailers, not manufacturers, and the fee is assessed regardless of whether the device ends up disposed. Seems like such a fee would serve only to make everything more expensive, instead of actually incentivizing the production of longer-lasting goods.

Another idea (probably full of holes, I'm sure): Tax manufacturers based on the length of their products' warranties, say 100 minus YEARS. So no warranty means company pays 100% of the product's sale price in tax. 5 year warranty means company pays 95% of the product's sale price, etc. down to no tax if the company offers a 100 year or more warranty.

Re:Sweden Wants to Fight Disposable Culture with Tax Breaks ... by Karunamon on Monday September 26, 2016 @12:18PM (#12583100)
Biggest problem I can think of there can be answered with most of the warranty repairs I've ever had done.

"We don't have any parts for your $old_thing, here, have a $new_thing"

Great from the consumer standpoint, but useless when it comes to reducing the amount of trash. And I'd be willing to bet that once something doesn't have any parts, it's not gonna be refurbished, it's gonna be scavenged for useful parts (if that's even possible), if not outright destroyed.

Re:Sweden Wants to Fight Disposable Culture with Tax Breaks ... by ptaipale on Monday September 26, 2016 @06:31PM (#12586173)
> A alternative approach could be taxing garbage.

There actually is a garbage tax (avfallsskatt) in Sweden. 500 SEK (59 USD) per ton.

This is in Swedish, but Google translate might help you. https://www.skatteverket.se/foretagochorganisationer/skatter...

Re:Sweden Wants to Fight Disposable Culture with Tax Breaks ... by rojobuffalo on Monday September 26, 2016 @02:28PM (#12584344)
"You optimize what you measure". Seems like incentivizing repair itself could lead to problems. Maybe the focus should be product longevity or components that can be repurposed, if the end goal is to reduce waste. In a totally different direction, share-ability could also do a lot to cut down on waste. There are a lot of products in the world where every individual doesn't need to own one, but only needs periodic access.
Re:Sweden Wants to Fight Disposable Culture with Tax Breaks ... by mmmpop on Monday September 26, 2016 @01:22PM (#12583712)
> Sure, it's pessimistic, but I'm essentially working backwards from an attempt to impose a tax on dietary fat (for health reasons) in Denmark.

Sorry, what? Not to derail, but this is the most ridiculous thing I've heard in awhile unless I'm just missing something. The latest science has made it pretty clear dietary fat is quite good for you and simple carbs are what a healthy person should avoid.

Re:Sweden Wants to Fight Disposable Culture with Tax Breaks ... by gutnor on Monday September 26, 2016 @10:05AM (#12581877)
I'm pessimistic too. However, the labour cost is so huge that it will offset some of your points and only give a slight edge to repair and second hand shops.

If you don't have a top of the range, almost new fridge or TV, even phone, repair will almost always come close to replacement cost. And replacement give you back a 2 years guarantee with faster turnaround.

Re:Sweden Wants to Fight Disposable Culture with Tax Breaks ... by ryandrake on Monday September 26, 2016 @11:21AM (#12582556)
> If you don't have a top of the range, almost new fridge or TV, even phone, repair will almost always come close to replacement cost.

I tend to repair everything, and let me say that's not true for the vast majority of my possessions, including cars, appliances, electronics, etc. It highly depends on the nature of the failure, but generally parts are cheaper than replacement. Here are a list of things I've recently repaired around my house + the parts to repair. I don't recall the parts costs, but all were far lower than replacing the entire thing:

Dishwasher: Control board

Garage door opener: Broken gear and sprocket

Hot tub: Two pumps and a pressure/flow sensor

AV receiver: Three capacitors

Rear projection TV: Convergence ICs

Attic fan: Fan motor

And probably tons more that I'm not recalling at the moment. The key is to stop throwing money away on labor costs. Even getting someone out to your house can cost $50-100 and that's before he even does anything. Total scam. I disagree with a lot of replies here--DIY repair is still a viable option for most things around the home.

Re:Sweden Wants to Fight Disposable Culture with Tax Breaks ... by floatrock on Monday September 26, 2016 @01:10PM (#12583599)
For something like the AV receiver's three capacitors or the TV's convergence IC's, how did you track down the problem and source replacements?

Are there debugging manuals for that level of electronics failure, or was it just "hmmm, that capacitor probably shouldn't have all the goo around it"?

Re:Sweden Wants to Fight Disposable Culture with Tax Breaks ... by protomok on Monday September 26, 2016 @01:54PM (#12584003)
My approach as a learn-it-as-I-go-DIYer is basically:

1) Google part number and the symptoms, half the time somebody has blogged about the exact same issue. These consumer products often fail in the same way.

2) Google symptoms and look for issues with similar products. Faulty capacitors for example is a classic cause of problems for older electronics and can be observed by just looking at the PCB (see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capacitor_plague)

3) Debug using Service Manual (note the User Manuals are typically useless / not detailed enough). Again just googling your part number will typically get you a PDF. If you still can't find the Service Manual you can buy it at these sketchy sites online for $10US, or buy the manual from the OEM (typically closer to $50US from my experience).

4) If still not sure what's wrong, buy a new logic board

5) Buy new gadget

Warning - depending on which appliance is broken irritation level of spouse may grow exponentially!

Re:Sweden Wants to Fight Disposable Culture with Tax Breaks ... by ryandrake on Monday September 26, 2016 @01:53PM (#12583992)
Forums + Youtube + Digikey for most electronics repair. The ICs were a little specialty, I think I got them on eBay. For most anything once you get a hold of the part number, you're good to go.
Re:Sweden Wants to Fight Disposable Culture with Tax Breaks ... by gutnor on Monday September 26, 2016 @04:12PM (#12585146)
Wait does any of that include labour ? Because around here you won't find a technician working for less than 50 GBP an hour, parts not included. Or well, you can always find a "guy" that can come around, no guarantee of anything.

That's btw my key argument. If you repair yourself or live in an area with handy undeclared workers, yeah repairing is probably worth it.

Re:Sweden Wants to Fight Disposable Culture with Tax Breaks ... by protomok on Monday September 26, 2016 @01:33PM (#12583812)
A big pain for DIY repairs (at least here in Canada) is part prices and shipping costs. I often see a 2-4x spread in prices when checking Amazon.ca and Amazon.com (often will not even ship to Canada).

It's still cheaper (and more satisfying) to DIY but it really hurts when you're paying $40 for a $10 garage door opener part!

Re:Sweden Wants to Fight Disposable Culture with Tax Breaks ... by nommm-nommm on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @09:24AM (#12589391)
Maybe you'd have better luck with eBay?
Re:Sweden Wants to Fight Disposable Culture with Tax Breaks ... by Roboprog on Monday September 26, 2016 @11:39AM (#12582718)
I suspect I will do much more of that after I retire.

It's hard to motivate myself to spend much time on most such activities now. Now saying you don't have a point, just how the day flows sometimes.

Re:Sweden Wants to Fight Disposable Culture with Tax Breaks ... by digikata on Monday September 26, 2016 @12:22PM (#12583148)
I find that repairing it myself is often faster than getting a tech out to repair things. It seems to be a minimum of two appointments, one to diagnose things and order the part, another to come back to fix it. With the wait windows the repair services want, it's less time to do it myself.
Re:Sweden Wants to Fight Disposable Culture with Tax Breaks ... by ryandrake on Monday September 26, 2016 @11:50AM (#12582828)
Each of these repairs consisted of: an hour or so of diagnosis/research + order the parts online + go on with your life until delivered + a few hours or so to do the repair.

I spent more time finding the cheapest (+shipping) online source of garage door opener parts than I spent on actually repairing it.

Re:Sweden Wants to Fight Disposable Culture with Tax Breaks ... by mikepurvis on Monday September 26, 2016 @10:27AM (#12582050)
Right, but the point of this legislation is to adjust the incentives so that repair becomes possible/economical in a greater number of cases.
Re:Sweden Wants to Fight Disposable Culture with Tax Breaks ... by thrownblown on Monday September 26, 2016 @10:56AM (#12582330)
Aren't we about to be abounding with mechanical inclined labor? Like aren't all truck drivers and car drivers about to be automated?

This seems like a nobrainer.

Relocating that labor surplus towards supporting a repairable mechanical/technological industry and commercial future seems really plausible.

That sounds like a decent job, troubleshooting and repairing the machines, designing machines to be repaired. Better than driving trucks.

Re:Sweden Wants to Fight Disposable Culture with Tax Breaks ... by marcosdumay on Monday September 26, 2016 @05:23PM (#12585692)
How much is is worth? Assuming every "fixer" is competing with some industry robots somewhere, what is the ceiling on the fixer salary?
Re:Sweden Wants to Fight Disposable Culture with Tax Breaks ... by thrownblown on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @10:47AM (#12589960)
I was assuming in our little hypothetical utopia that most consumer goods are designed once again to be repaired and upgraded.

I was also imagining a bunch of truck drivers looking for jobs, since the robots took them all.

Further along in my thought experiment, I imagined that if I owned a sizable fleet of robot cars I'd rather repair and upgraded than replace them.

So I figured if you're into trucks, have basic the mechanical skills required to drive a truck (tire chains, flat tires, oil change, spark plug change) that a new job maintenaning, repairing and upgrading the new fleets of robot taxis and trucks might be right up your alley.

For some reason self repairing robots seem a bit further off.