News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sorry, Adobe, you screwed yourself by csomar on Sunday April 11, 2010 @07:23PM (#1257912)
Not true, as the iPhone gets more popular, Adobe will take care of those custom features. There will be custom features for iPhone, Android or Windows Mobile. It'll make developing for mobile more fun, because you don't have to develop each application alone and use a specific machine/os for each phone.
Re:Sorry, Adobe, you screwed yourself by Perceval on Sunday April 11, 2010 @08:10PM (#1257994)
Not true, as the iPhone gets more popular, Adobe will take care of those custom features.

Adobe's history of failing to update their products to take advantage of OS X, of Intel processors, of Cocoa, or of the Mac platform entirely seems to give to lie your belief.

Re:Sorry, Adobe, you screwed yourself by vetinari on Monday April 12, 2010 @02:35AM (#1258563)
How is that? In 2001/2002, the way to move your code base from Classic to OSX was Carbon, not Cocoa.

The switch to Intel was another big porting project. Now, if they want to switch to x64, they will be also forced to switch from Carbon to Cocoa.

So in few years, Adobe had to port their codebase several times to meet the OSX moving target. Actually, I'm suriprised they did it at all, considering the lack of transparency on Apple side.

If you are asking Adobe to throw away any frameworks used, that were later duplicated by Apple in OSX, and port to Apple provided frameworks, you have no idea how the project of the Creative Suite size is managed and developed. You may port your little OSX-only utility fast, but not CS.

Other big projects had similar problems - Microsoft Office? Alias|Wavefront (today Autodesk) Maya? They have similar pain points for the exactly same reason.

Re:Sorry, Adobe, you screwed yourself by danudey on Monday April 12, 2010 @02:41PM (#1259956)
The thing is that yes, these were all pretty big porting projects, but they were also things that Adobe would have known about years in advance, and just never bothered to deal with until after it was an issue for most people.

When they knew about an upcoming platform change a year or two in advance, and didn't bother to deal with it until a year or two after, I have to assume that they just never cared. That's why Apple doesn't want to deal with Flash - they don't want to rely on a company that doesn't care about Apple or its users, and they don't want to be beholden to Adobe's schedule of 'we'll support that next year when users are hurting for it'.

When Apple announced location support in iPhoneOS 2.0, for example, including GPS for the iPhone 3G, would Adobe have had it ready for launch day? From their history, Flash would have waited until the next 'major release'. Flash-based apps would have had a reduced feature set, and the App Store would have been full of applications that couldn't support the latest and greatest features, distracting from applications that properly supported 2.0 from the start.

Re:Sorry, Adobe, you screwed yourself by sorbus on Sunday April 11, 2010 @09:41PM (#1258132)
But someone else could have.
Re:Sorry, Adobe, you screwed yourself by jimbokun on Sunday April 11, 2010 @09:18PM (#1258098)
"There will be custom features for iPhone, Android or Windows Mobile."

Are there examples of this happening consistently in other cross platform development environments? My understanding is that cross platform frameworks cater to a lowest common denominator among platforms, perhaps occasionally supporting a custom feature here and there. Even then, the people developing the app need to spend the necessary effort to take advantage of platform specific features, as opposed to just deploying the identical app to all platforms.

Re:Sorry, Adobe, you screwed yourself by TomOfTTB on Sunday April 11, 2010 @07:34PM (#1257934)
Do you work for Adobe? If not I don't see how you make the claims that you're making right now. I certainly wouldn't bet my business on those claims. Which is what you're asking Apple to do.
Re:Sorry, Adobe, you screwed yourself by halostatue on Sunday April 11, 2010 @08:33PM (#1258022)
Or anyone who were to use Flash to create iPhone apps.
Re:Sorry, Adobe, you screwed yourself by tjogin on Monday April 12, 2010 @02:41AM (#1258572)
> you don't have to develop each application alone and use a specific machine/os for each phone.

Of course you do, developing with Flash on OS X is infeasible, the performance is laughable and the stability is worse (like the article says, Adobe's been neglecting Flash on OS X since forever).

You have to use Windows to get any work done, and that is just as "specific" as having to use OS X.