Re:The decline of Stack Overflow (2015)
by Mithaldu on Sunday September 25, 2016 @08:26PM
(#12578290)
Absolutely this. I ran into the issue today where somebody had posted an ambiguous answer. Mods rejected edits to clarify, the user themselves said "it's not ambiguous to me", and the question itself is locked.
Nope you can't.
- You'll be blocked if your edit is not "in the spirit of the originally post(er)".
If you only have to add a separate and standalone paragraph at the end on a newer subfeature (like your asp example), it's generally fine.
If you have to rewrite one of the main paragraph, the reviewers will systematically reject your edit.
Typically, that means that there is no way to update an obsolete post when the tools or best practices have changed, because it's considered major changes diverging from the original author.
- Combine that with the aggressive policy of closing and locking down questions, and it's impossible to post a new separate answer on most of the questions.