News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:In which the author's faith in humanity is restored by Ha... by brandnewlow on Sunday April 11, 2010 @12:12PM (#1257091)
Hacker News "works" because it's all a big job interview. The job in question is being someone PG thinks is cool. That's the glue that holds this community together and keeps people in line.
Re:In which the author's faith in humanity is restored by Ha... by plinkplonk on Sunday April 11, 2010 @12:23PM (#1257123)
"Hacker News "works" because it's all a big job interview. The job in question is being someone PG thinks is cool. "

I have to confess I find this a very strange way of thinking. I respect PG immensely, but I don't care if he thinks I am not "cool" and I am fairly sure he doesn't anyway. And that's perfectly fine -- I don't think I am cool why should he?

Do you really believe that most people here are trying to get PG's stamp of approval somehow? I suspect not.

Re:In which the author's faith in humanity is restored by Ha... by dfranke on Sunday April 11, 2010 @12:39PM (#1257165)
What brandnewlow describes was definitely and obviously true in the very-early days of HN (then Startup News), like from its public opening in Feb '07 until the next couple funding cycle deadlines. At that time the readership consisted very heavily of YC-hopefuls, and the site was low-volume enough that any given comment had a very good chance of being read by PG. But HN has grown a lot since then, I get much less impression that this dynamic still holds.
Re:In which the author's faith in humanity is restored by Ha... by tptacek on Sunday April 11, 2010 @02:05PM (#1257285)
Part of what makes Hacker News work is that it's a benign dictatorship. Sites that have curators work better than sites that don't. So there's some truth to what you're saying.

But many of the top posters on this site have no evident desire to work for (or, in my case, even be particularly respectful towards) Paul Graham. So I think you've missed the mark, too.

Re:In which the author's faith in humanity is restored by Ha... by SlyShy on Sunday April 11, 2010 @12:51PM (#1257185)
I don't think it has to do with PG anymore specifically. But rather, if you were to mention HN in a cover letter as the way you heard about a job opportunity, then your Hacker News profile would likely be checked out. I've had it happen 2 out of 2 times so far.
Re:In which the author's faith in humanity is restored by Ha... by brandnewlow on Sunday April 11, 2010 @01:15PM (#1257220)
If PG/YC cut ties with HN, the site and community would die.
Re:In which the author's faith in humanity is restored by Ha... by tptacek on Sunday April 11, 2010 @02:06PM (#1257287)
If Joel Spolsky cut ties with Business of Software, it too might die. But most of the people who contribute there don't want to work for Fog Creek.
Re:In which the author's faith in humanity is restored by Ha... by brandnewlow on Sunday April 11, 2010 @04:31PM (#1257532)
Point taken.
Re:In which the author's faith in humanity is restored by Ha... by jeromec on Sunday April 11, 2010 @01:41PM (#1257249)
I agree, but not because every participant wants in to YC. PG is the guiding anchor for the site. It's similar to how people speculate Digg would be different without Kevin Rose. These site creators are hosts. It's like going to someone's house; while you may be allowed to wander around your behavior will generally reflect the values of the host. The quality of HN is a flattering testament to the high bar set by having PG as host, as well as deliberate measures implemented to defend against degradation.
Re:In which the author's faith in humanity is restored by Ha... by karzeem on Sunday April 11, 2010 @01:57PM (#1257273)
Impressing (or at least not disappointing) PG was definitely a big incentive early on, and it lingers to a degree. I think, though, that PG's role in that has been replaced by the community at large. People are civil and thoughtful because they want to live up to the community.

(Incidentally, I think in communities where people are jerks, it's also because they think that's what the community expects.)