Re:Tell HN: Regarding the silent banning of HN posters
by carbocation on Sunday April 11, 2010 @10:53AM
(#1256934)
Hellbanning for spammers is great. They can keep spamming away, to the detriment of nobody!
Perhaps some sincere people are not quite {smart, thoughtful, kind, cautious, interesting, deferential, in agreement with our general mode of thinking and writing} enough to cut it here. I do think that for them, an old-school ban (one that actually notifies you of your banishment in big red letters) would be more charitable.
The funny thing is that when I make a post that gets no replies, I'll open an incognito window just to see if I've been hellbanned.
Re:Tell HN: Regarding the silent banning of HN posters
by cynicalkane on Sunday April 11, 2010 @12:00PM
(#1257070)
I don't think that's why robak was banned. My theory is that the ban kicks in after the offending comment. This would explain the cases where it seems like someone was banned for an innocuous comment, but was actually banned for the comment before that.
In robak's case, the ban came after a silly ramble about the economy. Presumably a moderator looked at his post history and saw it was only one of a string of silly rambles, and decided to ban.
But I can see the 'upside' in that spammers have had a hard time gaining a foothold on HN, for the most part the system is effective even if it is very cruel towards some specific users.
You're listing 'robak' twice btw. He got banned well over a year ago, I can't see anything in his history that would have caused him to get banned so that by itself is pretty weird. Comments like the one he made around the time he got banned are routinely made by members today and nobody seems to get banned for any of that. You have to go back quite far in the comments history for that user, the comment that is the first one where he's 'dead' is:
"well, at least I know now how average Windows user looks and acts like..."
Which is pretty stupid but that's what the moderation system is for, not a ban (and that comment did not get any downvotes).
Some people here think that it is amusing that these users fail the 'intelligence test' that nobody responds to them their conclusion should be that they've been banned. I don't agree with that, it's a cruel punishment, and the arbitrariness with which it is meted out is another sore point.
HN is strange that way, but it works fairly well in spite of all that.