News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Will the left survive Millennials? by dang on Saturday September 24, 2016 @01:52AM (#12569652)
> the social justice crowd leaves their shrill stink

Please don't post ideological rants to Hacker News. We're going for civil, substantive discourse here, and these things aren't compatible.

Re:Will the left survive Millennials? by cryoshon on Saturday September 24, 2016 @03:48PM (#12572316)
I'd dispute that my posting was an ideological rant, given the depth and subtlety of my arguments as well as the ultimate admission that the demographic in question is useful and essential... it's also unarguable that SJWs are not shrill in opposition. I guess "stink" was too strong of a word choice for a word meant to convey pejorative association... but it sure reads as better copy.
Re:Will the left survive Millennials? by dang on Saturday September 24, 2016 @04:16PM (#12572448)
"Better copy", a.k.a. sharp rhetoric, is what we're hoping to avoid. I understand the impulse, but experience has taught us that thoughtful reflection doesn't mix well with it. The effects are subtle. It isn't just that it tends to produce angry responses; it's that it makes the ecosystem more acidic, so fewer of the rarer plants can thrive.
Re:Will the left survive Millennials? by hobs on Saturday September 24, 2016 @04:52PM (#12572585)
dang, I know you always are acting in good faith but I really question whether that is true.

Killing a post with one word (which isn't on any ban list on any website I know of) that crossed the line is one where more plants thrive, especially given the effort and thought that went into that post?

Re:Will the left survive Millennials? by dang on Sunday September 25, 2016 @03:10PM (#12576840)
I'm not sure what you mean by "killing a post with one word", but (a) users flagged that post (that's what "[flagged]" means), and (b) the problem with it ran all the way through it. I just quoted a sample.
Re:Will the left survive Millennials? by tracker1 on Friday September 23, 2016 @05:16PM (#12568017)
Yes, but there's a difference between showing offense, writing about it, boycotting, etc. and making it illegal, or in the terms of a college/university setting censoring.

I find it amusing how much talk goes into saying how much a given setting has diversity, or accepts diversity while trying to stifle speech, debate and interaction. Maybe I'm just too old now, but it clearly doesn't seem right. And while I really dislike the use of language to insight violence, riots or outright racist propaganda (that includes both the KKK and BLM in my mind), I wouldn't want to see the freedom of speech be limited in such ways. For similar reasons, I find the curbing of firearms rights alarming as well.

Re:Will the left survive Millennials? by hyperdunc on Friday September 23, 2016 @06:32PM (#12568426)
It's this obviously poor behavior and lack of self awareness on the part of some progressives that makes me think they aren't moving us in the right direction. Rather, they're creating more division by turning society into a "zoo of diversity" where each enclosed group is sheltered from the ideas of others and judged by different standards.
Re:Will the left survive Millennials? by hyperdunc on Friday September 23, 2016 @06:23PM (#12568378)
SJWs are obsessed with identity, which strikes me as being narcissistic. As you describe, they define new terms like "gender fluid" in order to give people new categories to define themselves by.

But if anything should be fluid, it's identity itself. Identity fluidity acknowledges that people can (and should) change as they are continually exposed to more information. It rejects the notion of a static identity defined by things like race, religion and gender, in favor of a fluid identity based on character and knowledge.

According to SJWs, identity is ego-based and needs to be protected from outside influence. Their model only creates a more divisive society where people express their fragility by being easy offended, rather than eschewing their current sense of self in favor of mental growth.

Re:Will the left survive Millennials? by RileyKyeden on Friday September 23, 2016 @07:56PM (#12568745)
I like how you fairly characterized (and seem to be on board with) the endgame of progressive politics while completely and utterly mischaracterizing the majority of the people involved, and strongly implied there exists, but never proving the existence of, a high level conspiracy to create an inclusive culture.
Re:Will the left survive Millennials? by cryoshon on Friday September 23, 2016 @08:29PM (#12568869)
there's no conspiracy. just like-minded people who behave in consensus-seeking ways.