When, for any given thing you want to regulate, there are 4 incredibly wealthy special interest groups trying to warp your message to protect the profit margins of the companies they represent, rather than keep safety or anything else in mind there, making sure that you don't take "Totally reasonable measure A" and get the people you're protecting messaged, "HOW DARE YOU, MY FREEEEDOM!" - that's quite difficult.
But despite my understanding of that, the HUGE problem there is that "Totally reasonable measure A" and "Draconian Evil Measure X" look almost exactly the same to us onlookers, and when the FDA, or anyone, uses "Morally Ambiguous Embargo Y" to protect their actions, why, the rational response from us as onlookers is the ASSUME that they're performing "Draconian Evil Measure X."
So what, exactly, is the answer? I don't think there IS one presently out there that isn't incredibly messy, but I hope we can still discover it - that is, figure out how to protect the almost certainly true and reasonable actions from the 'bad guys,' while not falling afoul of the rational reaction of the 'good guys' (us, in this case, the people being protected) and coming under attack from THEM.
Right, but see you shouldn't because that's hilariously naive.
He's demanding transparency and good faith from the FDA.
Maybe it's better if I put it this way, "I don't actually think the FDA is up to rotten fuckery here, but it sure as hell looks like they're being FUCKING EVIL, and without a method to for to tell that they aren't, they should FUCKING STOP IT."
Is seems to be the same move as using rebate coupons rather than outright sales.
If so, I'm afraid you'll be sorely dissapointed.
Preferential reporters by government agencies ought to be illegal.
Why must the pharma company answer solely to shareholders? They are doing medicine - they also have an obligation to do right by the public. Generally, when a medical professional fails to do right by the public, they get replaced with one that will.
For many medicines, I have absolutely zero choice in that relationship. It's <Company> selling <Drug that I need to not die>, or the highway (Not to mention that I'm not choosing the medicine - my doctor is prescribing it.). If that is choice, then so is not paying taxes.
To be consistent with your position, preferential reporting by anyone with an involuntary relationship with their 'customer' base should be illegal. This would disqualify most pharma companies right off the bat.
There was no reason to downvote me, so you can concentrate on the source of the problem instead of throwing a silly rule at me. But it's far easier to just pinpoint a silly edit I made, isn't it? Let's completely ignore the fact that we are on a thread about the government controlling the media and that it was somehow sufficiently voted up to receive significant attention and that my initial statement somehow warranted downvotes.
And these general sentiments are definitely "alt-right." It has a generally conspiratorial tone with completely overzealous fear mongering about what the FDA is doing.
The press is a deeply flawed institution. The idea that what the press needs to become less flawed is to be more controlled by the subjects of their reporting is, frankly, idiotic. It's genuinely the stupidest thing I've heard this week.
I have no particular bone to pick with the FDA. I neither revere nor hate it. I don't want to defund it, but neither do I think it is above all reproach, nor that it is above trying to make itself look better than it is. But this isn't really about the FDA in particular, but about the general relationship of the subjects of reporting with the press in general, and particularly about the relationship of the government with the press.
Having as reliable as possible information about what our own government is doing is a bedrock foundation of a functioning democracy. We should be doing what we can to make sure that we get that information, not celebrating the government's attempts to manipulate the press. The certainly does not preclude criticizing the press for their many failures, but it does mean supporting them when they do the right thing, as the Scientific American is here.
PS: As far as the general sentiments of the alt-right go, the alt-right is defined by a belief that we should have a more authoritarian government that maintains order and ignores democracy. Guess who sounds kind of alt-right-ish in this conversation?
The government is not blocking any information. It is managing contacts. It wants trust worthy contacts who aren't going to spin things around for financial gain.
The actual information related to their policies are accessible again, by people who actually understand the material. Thousands and thousands of scientists from competing organizations observe and consume information from the FDA. There is nothing stopping journalists from seeking out this information and gathering opinions from the employees of these organizations, or professionals in whatever field they're reporting on in general.
"Do the right thing." How shallow and means absolutely nothing in the context of this conversation. Please say something a bit more substantial than that. The FDA wants to interact with reporters who don't spin information or misquote members of the FDA for their own gain. That's literally it. What's this "do the right thing" battle cry in reference to again?
It's extremely aggravating that this needs to spelled out on this forum these days.
PS: Nothing about what the FDA doing is remotely authoritarian. Stop promoting click bait, and furthermore at the very least don't try pathetically defending it.
A belief in an independent, skeptical, and indeed antagonistic press was a core left-wing value as of, like, the late 20th Century. I think it still is or ought to be.
Because publishing a comprehensive news article with both sides is more disruptive than publishing a press release directly?
Not being concise, diligent, and stringent on what messages get sent out could have extremely negative effects. Letting news organizations pander to people's fears or general ignorance is a recipe for disaster.
I am not even sure why this needs to be explained. I mean, actually at this point on HN I do know why, it's people being disingenuous. Seriously how is this non-sense being upvoted?
From the article: >including ones from major outlets such as Fox News
Seriously, are we going to just sit here and pretend why this was done? An organization hell bent on bashing largely agreed upon scientific information is being denied the ability to spin information from an organization dedicated to the scientific understanding and safety of products. The FDA is basically refusing to play the game of yellow journalism and rightly so.
Spare me the patronizing pathetic attempts at an apology, and excuse me for calling out bullshit from scientific american. Shame on them. And shame on HN for upvoting this.
If they were interested in "refusing to play the game of yellow journalism" they would not pre-announce their activities at all.
And are you really saying that Scientific American is "an organization hell bent on bashing largely agreed upon scientific information"?
The FDA gets _true_ oversight from the thousands and thousands of scientist who work within the organization, who work outside the organization, and other organizations who have vested interests in "trashing" certain findings and approvals by the FDA. It sounds like you don't know how the FDA is generally set up so it would do you well to look into it. It's not exactly private.
The FDA again, doesn't want to play the game of yellow journalism. Why is this confusing? The following makes absolutely no sense, by the way. From your own post: "they would not pre-announce their activities at all." Please do elaborate how this somehow negates their motivations for not wanting the press to get out of hand and send false signals to the public. You can't just provide one little quip and expect that to unravel all their motivations. Again, I'm really struggling to see how this is confusing to anyone who has worked with anything remotely public, or even at a big corporation!
And no, I am not sure how a direct quote about Fox News and a sentence that follows the direct quote somehow gets misconstrued as me talking about "Scientific American." _However_, Scientific American has been known (especially over the last couple of years), to engage in generally click baity, irrefutably unscientific publications. Just like it is doing here.
Your hatred of Fox News is noted, however the government has no right to discriminate against media outlets. Considering that Fox has the largest viewership of any US news channel, you'd think that the FDA would have a mandate to ensure that their policies were reported to the largest audience.
Seriously, Politico was on the preferential list and not Fox? That's just pettiness on the part of the FDA and it's obvious that they have an agenda. My point isn't that Fox isn't given advance access -- my point is that there ought not be exclusionary access lists in the first place.
That is the most backwards statement you possible could have made. I am not even sure if you really believe it yourself.
>however the government has no right to discriminate against media outlets.
Yes they do.
>my point is that there ought not be exclusionary access lists in the first place.
And you've done nothing to negate my point that not only that they should and it makes sense to do so, but why you think letting news organizations run wild with public health information is a responsible thing to do. It's foolish, naive, and ignorant.
But that is essentially orthogonal to the issue of whether embargoes should be "close-hold", in those cases where the FDA does trust a reporter enough to grant them early access. After all, if the reporter merely wants to cast aspersions and FUD, a close-hold embargo doesn't really prevent them from doing so; they can probably come up with it on their own, or cite preexisting criticism related to the subject (regardless of how well it matches up with the exact announcement at hand). It is only if they want to get informed, on-topic reactions from sources with relevant knowledge and experience that the embargo gets in the way. Indeed, such an embargo may all but force even well-meaning journalists to include misleading or useless "context" - decreasing the accuracy of the article - just to provide some slight semblance of impartiality, as in this example from the Scientific American article:
> CBS plunked down an out-of-context quotation from the director of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, probably in hopes that readers wouldn't notice that it was two months old.
Now, I suppose it's possible that well-meaning journalists end up too credulously repeating the statements of sources with, as you say, vested interests in bashing the FDA. I suppose hamstringing them from even talking to those sources, along with all others, could hypothetically increase the overall accuracy of the article.
But let's be real. What you end up with is essentially a series of glorified press releases. Press releases have their place: to inform the public of a particular organization's viewpoint. True, the FDA is an expert organization and chances are its viewpoints are typically reasonable - valid - plausible. Indeed, they're almost certainly more studied and thorough than a quick reaction from any other source. But even so, valid is not the same as right, and for issues as contentious as the ones the FDA often ends up having to deal with, there is rarely any single right viewpoint. Thus citing a range of sources, rather than providing the public with any organization's viewpoint alone, is the only responsible thing to do. That is not yellow journalism: it is the essence of journalism.
Seriously: do you really think -
> Even after he updated his piece later in the day to get some outside comments, there was little hint of how controversial the new rules were. Members of the tobacco industry were generally unhappy with increased federal regulation of their business, while antitobacco advocates tended to argue that the new regulations were far too weak and took way too long to promulgate. And there was no mention, in Felberbaum's article, at least, that the agency had tried to regulate e-cigarettes several years earlier but was slapped down with a stinging rebuke from the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia
- that omitting this context is an improvement?
It makes it pretty difficult to have any kind of information to spin. Whether or not it's 100% preventative measure is as you say, orthogonal to helping prevent the issue in the first place. If they have nothing to quote of context, or twist their words, any material they make will be generally lackluster to their audiences.
>What you end up with is essentially a series of glorified press releases.
The FDA does not have a PR branch. It is smartly using the press to get information out to the public.
>But even so, valid is not the same as right, and for issues as contentious as the ones the FDA often ends up having to deal with, there is rarely any single right viewpoint.
Allow me to be extremely blunt here: who cares? Again these view points are largely handled through the actual scientific process. The general public with no knowledge on the subject being discussed isn't going to properly shift through competing view points, and it is exceedingly unlikely these other view points are correct by the time the FDA wants to give a press release about certain processes or products.
Again, this information about these other view points isn't private. The FDA just doesn't want the press to misinform the public. What is so controversial about this?
>Thus citing a range of sources, rather than providing the public with any organization's viewpoint alone, is the only responsible thing to do.
There is nothing stopping organizations from researching these issues on their own and reporting them. The FDA just doesn't want the press to spin their statements into something that could harm the public in any form. If you go to a press event, you are expected to report accurately on FDA's statements and processes, or else you're not going to be invited back.
I would like an explanation what the big deal is about actions the FDA are specifically taking in direct regards to the close-hold embargo without resorting to absurd claims that the FDA is somehow ruining journalistic integrity. Report the statements accurately and when the FDA is ready for the public to view them. Journalistic integrity is not being ruined. Journalists can still investigate the products on their own, and report other organization's findings.
>that omitting this context is an improvement?
The real question is how is that paragraph adding anything of value to the new rules and regulations by the FDA? People tend to get lost in the minuet talking points and stick to pedantic details with stories like these. Again, the FDA wants to have direct statements on these matters so there isn't any confusion about what they're doing or what they're going to try do.
The propagation of (ethically-compromised) dysfunction? An escalating "giving forward" of negative value and technical debt? I seem to be increasingly noticing it.
Where a well-intentioned rational actor, because of upstream ethically-problematic dysfunction, chooses a "least-bad option" of creating their own ethically-questionable dysfunction, which then has a similar effect on downstream actors. Where at any point, you could imagine an upstream channel with a "no, that's beyond the pale, you need to stop doing that", but because of noise or other things, such signalling isn't working. Until it does. Sometimes.
In this case, company and press lying, tolerated by press and public, prompts government conduct that further degrades the press, increases tolerance of lying, and impairs everyone's ability to improve government conduct.
Or consider the attempt to force TPP ratification in post-election session. The Obama administration has only managed to remain kind of functional, by doing end-runs around a dysfunctional legislature and press. But that has a side-effect of disabling legislative and journalistic checks on groupthink and regulatory capture. And press discourse has become loud and low quality, drowning out signals. So while a (now former) White House official, nicely characterized the regulatory capture of US copyright law, as "extremists are people who talk only among themselves", with only our current functionally-degraded mechanisms, it's a struggle for that insight to constrain policy.
The larger context might be a decline of civic society and civil discourse. But this seems a particular feedback pattern, of "things are bad, so now I have to make them worse". But does it have a label?
It doesn't really matter what the initial justification was, it is what it is. You're increasingly noticing it because it is occurring everywhere and without any negative consequences to the bad actors (quite the opposite: significant rewards.)
Everything makes more sense if you don't think of the media as a medium, but a group of self-interested actors who sell tickets to exposing or suppressing what gets published.
For illustration. Science education is remarkably ineffective, K-14, and worldwide. A rule of thumb that "people don't care whether science education actually works", will rarely steer you wrong. But it is an almost useless description of the underlying tangle of incentives and capabilities and visibilities and costs, which cause that surface behavior.
Take a professor teaching cell biology, who isn't disinterested in teaching deep understanding, but who, given severe time constraints, isn't going to disservice their students by trading against a specific superficial understanding that the high-stakes med school MCAT exam tests for. So yes, "don't care", sort of. But change the MCAT, and suddenly...
So one can have a observationally good description, one that's fine for spectators, but which isn't illuminating or helpful interventionally.
Or take the earlier copyright example. During the fight over SOPA, Hollywood executives publicly and angrily complained about congressmen not staying bought. A surface reading of that isn't a bad description of everyone's behavior. But my understanding is, they were basically saying "we talk among ourselves all the time; and we all agree; only a few weird and confused others disagree; and we're now startled and dismayed to find some politicians disagreeing; and can only imagine that this results from them being bought, or lied to, likely by the tech industry; we payed good money to elect what we thought were good people - why should we pay for the reelection of the corrupt and the gullible?". Will more insight into mechanism help you? Maybe not.
But while incentives matter, it's the actual incentives that matter. What if US copyright extensions were fought not with "Constitutional intent" and "public interest", so basically "we want you to give up a few billion dollars a year in Pooh et al merchandising fees", but fought instead with "here's a change in trademark law, or a copyright-excepting guardianship of a national treasure, which will preserve your big revenue streams in perpetuity". Addressing actual incentives, rather than narratives.
If you're talking about pharmaceutical companies, the FDA has enormous power over them, and I don't remember them ever saying anything critical of the FDA. That would be taking enormous risks.
Not that I pay close attention. There might be some, but I think the pharma industry is deathly afraid of antagonizing their regulator.
More funds for checks and balance. Laws that make it clear what transparency means and actual funds for enforcing these laws.
In general the US seems to be stuck in a gordian self-fulfilling prophecy: many people in the US see government administrations evil or inefficient in all matters and they are enough to actually handicap the government administrations, and make them actually inefficient.
I think that at one point US citizens have to come to terms with the idea that they need to be protected by efficient government administrations, and that regulations are actually what makes free market move in the direction of social progress.
But seeing the resistance there was to Obamacare (which, seen from western Europe is really the bare minimum a civilized country should have) I am not holding my breath.
The result is that the American media basically has become Pravda when it comes to the federal government.
FIFY.
And why are you limiting this to the feds? State/local actors are frequently worse. Or at least, I haven't heard of the FDA arresting journos.
Hmm...
http://slatestarcodex.com/2016/09/13/some-context-for-that-n...
"In any case, claims that the sugar industry sponsored one study back in the 1960s, and this means everything we’ve ever thought is wrong and biased against fat and in favor of sugar, miss the point (especially since there are probably problems with both sugar and fat). Whatever study the New York Times has dredged up was one volley in an eternal clandestine war of Big Fat against Big Sugar, and figuring out who’s distorted the science more is the sort of project that’s going to take more than one article."
http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2011/11/14/the-tweaker
(Suroweicki and Gladwell are two of favorite authors on their staff right now.)
From the article: "Documents obtained by Scientific American through Freedom of Information Act requests now paint a disturbing picture of the tactics that are used to control the science press. For example, the FDA assures the public that it is committed to transparency, but the documents show that, privately, the agency denies many reporters access—including ones from major outlets such as Fox News—and even deceives them with half-truths to handicap them in their pursuit of a story. At the same time, the FDA cultivates a coterie of journalists whom it keeps in line with threats. And the agency has made it a practice to demand total control over whom reporters can and can't talk to until after the news has broken, deaf to protests by journalistic associations and media ethicists and in violation of its own written policies."
So let see if I understand this...
1- They tell their friendly reporters who they can and can't talk to with conditional embargos.
2- They don't let reports they view as hostile into the press releases.
3- They actively thwart these reporters viewed as hostiles by intentionally telling them lies and half-truths.
This is completely absurd, A federal agency is manipulating the story it wants and the side it wants to tell it. It is picking the winners and losers, and the winners keep quiet about the scam because it they start to be seen as trouble makers, soon they will start getting the Fox News treatment too.