News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:It Costs $30 to Make a DIY EpiPen by rayiner on Thursday September 22, 2016 @12:14PM (#12557879)
In a very real sense, people did "build Twitter instead of saving lives." The money invested in Twitter's IPO alone could've saved more than half a million kids from malaria. And your first point basically reduces to: it's more immoral to develop a cure and make lots of money from it, than to spend billions on activities that don't even cure anything. That's absurd.

Your point about anti-competitive conduct is well-taken. But beyond that, it's government's obligation to make sure everyone who needs life-saving treatment has it. But going into the business of saving lives shouldn't entitle you to any less of a profit motive than going into businesses that don't even save lives at all.

Re:It Costs $30 to Make a DIY EpiPen by TeMPOraL on Thursday September 22, 2016 @01:23PM (#12558471)
> And your first point basically reduces to: it's more immoral to develop a cure and make lots of money from it, than to spend billions on activities that don't even cure anything. That's absurd.

Did the American company invent stents and was just protecting their R&D returns from evil Russian copycats? Also the "active suppression" issue is here - apparently the company bribed the government to prevent the competition. The point is more like "it's more immoral to be a life-saving cure provider who decides to make more money from it by shutting down competition that can provide that cure cheaper, than to not be in the life-saving business entirely".

> The money invested in Twitter's IPO alone could've saved more than half a million kids from malaria.

True only if taken out of context of the economy at large. There was no point in time where someone could make a business decision and whole money invested in Twitter's IPO would go directly to cure malaria. That money was not controlled by Twitter, but by many people who invested in it, each having a personal choice of what to do with their wealth.

Re:It Costs $30 to Make a DIY EpiPen by makmanalp on Thursday September 22, 2016 @12:58PM (#12558243)
Agh, never argue with a lawyer, I guess :)

> it's more immoral to develop a cure and make lots of money from it, than to spend billions on activities that don't even cure anything

OK, when you put it this way, yeah, it's hard to argue against.

What I was going for was more about the after-the-fact of having developed a cure: there's something about the fact that they /have/ the cure and at that point choose not to make it more available that seems reprehensible. This to me seems analogous to the sad fact that people are dying of hunger all the time in the world but a lot of us are isolated from that fact by sheer distance and go about our lives ignoring that with no moral weight on our shoulders (analogy to twitter, not having developed a cure - and not to say that this is a good thing), but if we directly encounter a person dying of hunger one day and we have food (analogy to insert-pharma-here), I'd like to think most of us would feel obligated to help. The immediacy and ability to help seems a factor.