News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Approve or Reject: Can You Moderate Five New York Times C... by SCdF on Wednesday September 21, 2016 @03:40PM (#12551526)
Wow really? I have the opposite opinion: easy and safe (for reddit's hive mind / what is currently popular / anti-popular) rise to the top, things people disagree with get downvoted.

The effect lessens the further you get from the front page, but the formula is the same.

NB: this is not true for some of their highly moderated subreddits like AskScience / AskHistorians or whatever. The rest of reddit does not operate that way though.

Re:Approve or Reject: Can You Moderate Five New York Times C... by SilasX on Wednesday September 21, 2016 @05:04PM (#12552235)
Right, but (per parent), it's still better than the alternatives. You can cite flaws, but it was an improvement over what we had before (yabb, slashdot, etc).

You can do better -- like the AskScience/AskHistorian forums -- but only at the cost of investing a lot more work. Is there something more scalable?

Re:Approve or Reject: Can You Moderate Five New York Times C... by SCdF on Wednesday September 21, 2016 @05:18PM (#12552329)
> You can cite flaws, but it was an improvement over what we had before (yabb, slashdot, etc).

FWIW I considered /. to be a better system than reddit. But I mean, it all depends on what you consider "better". Reddit is certainly more popular, so clearly it's better by some metric.

Re:Approve or Reject: Can You Moderate Five New York Times C... by loeg on Wednesday September 21, 2016 @06:08PM (#12552713)
Yeah, reddit tends to dogpile. Mildly controversial comments in popular subreddits get massively upvoted or massively downvoted depending largely on the first few votes.