News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google accused of YouTube ‘free ride’ by DarkShikari on Saturday April 10, 2010 @07:41AM (#1254878)
These people operate on some sort of bizarre moon logic. Youtube doesn't "eat up your ISP's bandwidth", your customers eat up your ISP's bandwidth by using Youtube.

If electricity usage followed the same argument as they give, power plants would be at fault for their electricity being used.

Of course, your customers can't always easily be extorted for hundreds of millions of dollars, while (they think) Google can.

Re:Google accused of YouTube ‘free ride’ by lsb on Saturday April 10, 2010 @09:01AM (#1254961)
The ISP's logic of people paying for getting bits as well as people paying for receiving bits gets you (in America) text messages that are $0.20 to send, and $0.20 to receive.
Re:Google accused of YouTube ‘free ride’ by axod on Saturday April 10, 2010 @07:48AM (#1254886)
Problem is that ISPs hate it when you actually use bandwidth.

I got an email from my ISP - BT, to say that I'd used 80GB of transfer for March, and that if I went to 100GB, I'd have my speed capped for the next 30 days. This is on their (and I quote) "UNLIMITED" plan. bleurgg

Re:Google accused of YouTube ‘free ride’ by DarkShikari on Saturday April 10, 2010 @07:50AM (#1254888)
Of course. But normally ISPs take it out on their customers, as opposed to taking it out on the services their customers use.

Most likely the problem is that they now can no longer blame the problem on "bandwidth hogs"--with everyone using Youtube, everyone uses the bandwidth that you advertised to them.

Re:Google accused of YouTube ‘free ride’ by axod on Saturday April 10, 2010 @07:57AM (#1254896)
They certainly took/take it out on filesharing/p2p also though. I think they generally take it out on anything that eats bandwidth for them.

It's sort of ironic, since they have specifically sold the benefits of broadband ADSL as being able to watch movies, etc and now they complain people are actually doing that ;)

Re:Google accused of YouTube ‘free ride’ by swombat on Saturday April 10, 2010 @08:52AM (#1254945)
I think it's doubly ironic.

If the Telcos feel they can charge Google for carrying its bits, then perhaps they should pay all the newspapers, blogs, etc that are providing all their content to those telcos for free.

Over the last 20 years, Telcos have made humongous profits selling internet access to content that they didn't have any hand in producing. Meanwhile, the newspapers are going bust.

People keep talking about saving newspapers by introducing paywalls and such. There's already a paywall: it's the internet access monthly fee. Take the money out of there.

Re:Google accused of YouTube ‘free ride’ by axod on Saturday April 10, 2010 @08:58AM (#1254957)
I was with you up to the last crazy socialist sentence.

If the newspapers can't survive, (I for one still like reading my daily non-electronic paper), let them die.

ISPs should simply be a pipe. Nothing more, nothing less.

Re:Google accused of YouTube ‘free ride’ by swombat on Saturday April 10, 2010 @09:03AM (#1254964)
Oh, I agree - I don't think that should happen.

I just think that it's an uneasy "let's keep our eyes closed" arrangement to begin with. If the Telcos want to open their eyes instead, they might find they have a lot more to lose than to gain. Ditching Net Neutrality will cost them a whole lot more than it will gain them, as soon as content providers realise that actually, the providers should be paying them, not the other way around.

I mean, if Telefonica wants to block access to youtube, why should Google stop them? Fine. Block it. And lose 80% of your customers overnight. If Google wanted to play this game, they should be asking Telefonica to pay them money.

It's not a long step from this to having bloggers, newspapers, etc, organise in collectives that can charge telcos for "access to every newspaper on the web" or "every blog on the web".

Re:Google accused of YouTube ‘free ride’ by thefahim on Saturday April 10, 2010 @10:54AM (#1255113)
ISPs (Comcast, ugh!) have monopolies in a ton of areas in the states. Block YouTube and it'll lose 80% of it's traffic overnight, not the other way around.
Re:Google accused of YouTube ‘free ride’ by axod on Sunday April 11, 2010 @07:07AM (#1256685)
The article was about Europe AFAIK, which is certainly far more diverse in ISP offerings.

In the UK you have a choice from a few hundred ISPs, so there is no real monopoly here.

Re:Google accused of YouTube ‘free ride’ by dsplittgerber on Saturday April 10, 2010 @07:54AM (#1254891)
Years ago, I saw lots of "unlimited" cell phone plan commercials in London, every single one being subject to "fair use". How come it's that common in the UK? I think there are close to none "fair use" plans in e.g. Germany. Why the local differences?
Re:Google accused of YouTube ‘free ride’ by axod on Saturday April 10, 2010 @08:00AM (#1254897)
I think "unlimited" is just a word that gets people to buy something. It's not economical to actually offer something with unlimited anything. Even if you buy a dedicated server with "unlimited" transfer, it'll be limited by the connection speed - eg 10mbps uplink "unlimited bandwidth" works out at less than 5TB total transfer per month.

Same with the magic word "free". You'll often see that used such as "free mobile phone (small print: when you sign up to a contract at £19/month)" etc.

Are there true unlimited plans in Germany that aren't subject to any limits then?

Re:Google accused of YouTube ‘free ride’ by seles on Saturday April 10, 2010 @08:32AM (#1254929)
This is what at&t/apple does with their 'unlimited' iphone subscription. It might be unlimited but they try their best to stop you from using any actual bandwidth (tethering etc.)

Google has had to take a lot shit lately from non free speech and non free market ideologies.

Re:Google accused of YouTube ‘free ride’ by dsplittgerber on Saturday April 10, 2010 @08:12AM (#1254907)
For internet at home, I think so. Just checked the legalese for the #1 provider (Deutsche Telekom) here, found no wording relating to "fair use". Internet at home is extremely competitive here, though. Lots of different delivery methods (tv cable, telephone cable etc), unlimited internet + landline calls for ~30 EUR/month or less.

For mobile internet, it's a whole different story, obviously. There are all kinds of caps.

I think 'unlimited' should mean unlimited. But I agree, introducing caps sadly makes business sense for some companies.

Re:Google accused of YouTube ‘free ride’ by sadiq on Saturday April 10, 2010 @01:08PM (#1255323)
It's largely down to the Advertising Standards Agency refusing to do anything about the term "unlimited".

The problem is now that the term is completely meaningless. We found an Unlimited mobile data plan a few months back that had a 250mb a month 'fair usage' allowance. Total rubbish.

The next thing to watch for is "fibre optic broadband". The ASA don't see any problem with Virgin Media (a cable company) advertising their service as "fibre optic", despite the fact that the last leg is actually coax.

I've already had a couple of non-technical friends wonder what all the fuss is about "fibre optic", since they think they already have it.

Re:Google accused of YouTube ‘free ride’ by some1else on Saturday April 10, 2010 @07:56AM (#1254895)
This just shows that telco's won't solve a thing by capping bit-torrent traffic. What they need to do is stop charging too little for the bandwidth and improve their infrastructure to support the market they expanded to.
Re:Google accused of YouTube ‘free ride’ by Retric on Saturday April 10, 2010 @11:12AM (#1255149)
Bandwidth is not a major cost for most large scale ISP's. The real problem is there is only so many way's for ISP's to cut costs and pissing off the customers that most use the service is unlikely to cause them to quit because they don't have any choice.
Re:Google accused of YouTube ‘free ride’ by rbanffy on Saturday April 10, 2010 @11:31AM (#1255169)
This may drive up the prices to a point an ISP can profit from moving bits from A to B.
Re:Google accused of YouTube ‘free ride’ by Retric on Saturday April 10, 2010 @01:47PM (#1255398)
ISP's already profit from moving bit's from A to B. They want to make as much profit as possible.

ISP's have the same basic problem as the airlines. They are selling a commodity service that requires high capital costs and have little to differentiate themselves with. The only way to increase profits is to drive down costs because they can't offer much outside of "fat pipes".

Re:Google accused of YouTube ‘free ride’ by rbanffy on Saturday April 10, 2010 @08:45PM (#1256071)
Most ISPs earn much more from value-added products like anti-viruses and other security programs.
Re:Google accused of YouTube ‘free ride’ by PostOnce on Saturday April 10, 2010 @08:41AM (#1254937)
This is completely irrelevant but I quite enjoy the phrase "bizarre moon logic". Kudos for coining it.