News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Fantastic World of Professor Tolkien (1956) by noonespecial on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @07:07PM (#12544119)
I'd say he invented the genre and so had to include some simple and readily grasped tropes in order to give it mass appeal... Or perhaps it gained that mass appeal precielsely by incorporating what you criticize.

Don't sweat it, when you write your world changing, genre defining masterwork, you can make it as deep and morally ambiguous as you please.

Re:The Fantastic World of Professor Tolkien (1956) by na85 on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @10:54PM (#12545067)
>Don't sweat it, when you write your world changing, genre defining masterwork, you can make it as deep and morally ambiguous as you please.

I hate this criticism. The idea that unless you are an author of similar calibre, you are not fit to critique is a dangerous one.

I haven't written an operating system, but I can still tell you that Windows 10 has numerous flaws. Should I STFU until I write my own?

Re:The Fantastic World of Professor Tolkien (1956) by macintux on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @11:10PM (#12545121)
> I haven't written an operating system, but I can still tell you that Windows 10 has numerous flaws. Should I STFU until I write my own?

If you started your critique of Windows 10 by calling Microsoft "Most overrated software shop of all time" and then proceeded with a few subjective, shallow criticisms with no detail, you might indeed be told that.

And I'd wager Microsoft has nowhere near the adoration that Tolkien has among HN readers.

Re:The Fantastic World of Professor Tolkien (1956) by philh on Wednesday September 21, 2016 @06:15AM (#12546826)
> If you started your critique of Windows 10 by calling Microsoft "Most overrated software shop of all time" and then proceeded with a few subjective, shallow criticisms with no detail, you might indeed be told that.

How about saying "those are subjective, shallow criticisms with no detail" instead of "STFU and write your own operating system"?

One of these criticisms actually has some bearing on the criticism it's criticizing. One does not.

Re:The Fantastic World of Professor Tolkien (1956) by yolesaber on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @11:16PM (#12545145)
>few subjective, shallow criticisms

What criticism isn't subjective?

I'd vouch that Tolkien is massively overrated as a writer. Perhaps not of all time, but up there along with Stephen King. I like Lord of the Rings just fine but it's not even close to my favorite work of written fantasy. His worlds are huge and beautiful, yes, especially his invented languages. But as works of readable fiction, they just fall so flat. My favorite part of the books are the indices because that's Tolkien's wheelhouse.

Re:The Fantastic World of Professor Tolkien (1956) by macintux on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @11:22PM (#12545155)
I suspect many modern readers consider Nathaniel Hawthorne's novels long-winded. Does that make him overrated, or just not quite in tune with Twitter-sized attention spans?
Re:The Fantastic World of Professor Tolkien (1956) by armitron on Wednesday September 21, 2016 @09:36AM (#12547993)
What are your favorite works of written fantasy that you find better than LotR?
Re:The Fantastic World of Professor Tolkien (1956) by yolesaber on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @11:11PM (#12545129)
> I'd say he invented the genre

No, he really didn't. Clark Ashton Smith, Lord Dunsany, Jack Vance, there plenty of writers and entire magazines devoted to fantasy.

>Don't sweat it, when you write your world changing, genre defining masterwork, you can make it as deep and morally ambiguous as you please.

Projecting much?

Re:The Fantastic World of Professor Tolkien (1956) by okey on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @11:42PM (#12545220)
I agree he didn't invent the genre, although he certainly helped popularise and develop it.

"plenty" perhaps oversells the genre pre-Tolkien, and also afaik Jack Vance didn't start writing until well after The Hobbit was published, so I'm not sure he belongs on your list - William Morris would have been a much better example as a direct precursor to both Tolkien and Lewis.

Re:The Fantastic World of Professor Tolkien (1956) by GFK_of_xmaspast on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @07:33PM (#12544261)
There was plenty of fantasy fiction pre-Tolkien.
Re:The Fantastic World of Professor Tolkien (1956) by elihu on Wednesday September 21, 2016 @01:33PM (#12550369)
How much of it do people still read, that you'd be likely to find in a typical bookstore? Aside from George MacDonald and things that are similar but not exactly the same as modern fantasy novels, such as various collections of fairy tales and epics like the Odyssey, I can't think of any examples. The Chronicles of Narnia were published in the 50's, whereas the Hobbit was released in 1937.
Re:The Fantastic World of Professor Tolkien (1956) by yolesaber on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @11:06PM (#12545107)
No clue why you are being downvoted. You are 100 percent correct. If anything, we are now saddled with Tolkien's dry tropes as the defining element of "fantasy".
Re:The Fantastic World of Professor Tolkien (1956) by GFK_of_xmaspast on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @11:51PM (#12545255)
It's just how things are on HN.

Here are some pre-Tolkien authors people may be interested in: * Dunsany * Mirrlees * Hodgson * Eddison * Howard * Lovecraft * and there are more, just google them, these are just the ones that come to mind