Now imagine the scenario for most of the US, a public-transport-hostile country for the most part, where millions upon millions of people burn their precious lives waiting in traffic and sucking in traffic fumes. In my mind, this is one of the most appalling wastes of human potential that has ever existed. Sure, some try to make lemonade out of lemons by educating/informing themselves as they see fit but by and large, it is a huge waste. Not to mention the many thousands of people who die every year in car accidents during the daily commute.
So from my point of view, the self driving car is a thrilling concept: the ability to disengage from a useless, pointless, and hopeless daily grind and engage in something that I want to do, whether it be work, reading, watching a movie, etc. is cool. The closest I have come to this dream in my transit-unfriendly Texas city is the one job where I had an opportunity to take the train/bus into downtown: while this made my daily commute very long, I loved it because it freed me up from the drudge of driving.
Some might ask that perhaps I just hate driving. That is not true. I love taking road trips or autocrossing when I can. But to equate the daily commute with enjoyment is a bridge too far, in my opinion. Banish it, I say, banish it.
How will there still be no traffic jams, or the car will be like an office? In that case why not just work from home and come to work for meetings here and there? Might flexible / less work hours help?
I mean people will still be driving around in vehicle which often makes people motion sick if not paying attention to surroundings , cars requires a lot of energy, take up space etc.
I used to travel to work via train, it was 1.5 hours one way, it was highly productive time for me, but for some reason trains don't seem to make people as motion sick?
I guess one other thing to note is that in Australia, where I'm from originally, some see people think of others using public transport or biking as kind of peasants or feel it's inferior, that might be part of it too ? They're also the kind of people who often like to drive fast and own expensive cars as a status thing, so I'm still note sure it's going to take?
Unfortunately anti-public transit special interest groups have discredited public transit initiatives all over, and fighting this has been incredibly difficult.
On your last point people definitely do see owning expensive cars as a status item and for this reason I think it's valid to question to what degree and speed will autonomous car sharing networks replace individually owned cars.
On one side, you have a solution that requires a whole bunch of groups to align. On the other, you have an individual decision (buying a car). That's why I am excited. If it looked like it was on the horizon, I'd be just as excited for great public transit.
I also agree that telecommuting or flexible hours would work well. But again, for most office workers in the country and world, there is significant inflexibility: they must arrive at their appointed time, leave at their appointed time, and take breaks at appointed times. My statement was intended to be broad and to apply to all workers instead of just for the high-tech industry.
So I see self-driving cars as a backdoor solution to the above problems: replace regular cars with self-driving cars, maybe with car-sharing, and now a country that has so much invested in the car suddenly is able to significantly reduce the latter's influence on society without realizing it. Well, one can but hope anyways.
In my opinion a good public transport system does. I've spent time in Tokyo, the rail network is second to none, it's congested sure, but it works.
The problem is that people still need to get in and out of the cars for example, which means there is still wait time. Breakdowns will happen. All humans drivers will have to be banned etc.
It sounds to me like the auto-industry is still pushing a selfish agenda and the valley is buying it, because it's an opportunity to take more money.
For me, I'm happy because I'll still ride my bike and it will be a much safer place for me to exist because self-driving cars won't try and kill me, hopefully :)
Also we all know the security on cars is weak, who needs a bomb in a terrorist attack when you can just hack something and order 50,000 cars to crash (that might sound silly, but it hackers find ways). Do you trust auto manufacturers enough to secure it? Yeah we can mail firmware updates on USB sticks, what could go wrong.
Sorry I am pretty sure I am one of those hostile drivers. They should market it as like a designated driver for the drunk. It would sell faster then.
A sibling comment pointed out the loss of life issue. I recall (correctly, I hope) Sebastian Thrun mentioning that a traffic accident was part of his initial motivation. Reducing loss of life due to human folly is a strong motivator, but there are certainly ample opportunities for that beyond just this one.
Self-driving cars have widespread potential effects across society, from shipping to taxis to car ownership to the human angle in hours saved and lives saved. This is big. Think of all the lives lost and hours wasted in traffic in the US every year. (No functional public transit in most of the country, etc.)
It's an area where the challenges are largely technical--once the technology is safer than human drivers, we assume the regulatory issues will go away quickly. (And we probably underestimate the technical issues in getting there.)
The huge potential combined with massive and primarily technical challenges makes this probably the biggest thing since the Internet where a bunch of engineers feel like we can change society in a profound way with a bit of software.
It's partly because the tech is actually so new that we can project our expectations onto it rather than focusing on what is actually here today (which is impressive but far from the goal). Weigh this potential against the reality of what most of us actually work on today, and you may see the appeal.
Of course, reality will take time to catch up to the dream, but it's the dream that generates the excitement.
Cars play a large role in America. I don't know all the history about how it came to be this way, but I can make some guesses...
* America is very big, and a lot of the settlements are spread out by a ways. Cars make those communities less insular because they provide a way to get from one town to another, where biking would take a very long time and significant effort.
* I forget when (was it the Great Depression?), but there was a big government initiative to build interstate highways connecting places together by roads. Again, these were distant places, but by being able to travel by car, they now feel quite a bit closer. Most everyone on HN was born after this gigantic network of roads was already in place, and car culture was firmly cemented in the US.
* Due to the distances involved, getting a drivers license around the age of 16 or 17 is a huge amount of freedom bestowed on children just as they really desire such freedom. I spent a lot of time in a car as a teenager not just because of where we were going, but also since it was a mostly-private space for me and my friends.
* For the above reasons and many many more, America in general has a culture that is very centered on cars, so given that a lot of HN is both American and interested in technology, it makes sense there'd be a lot of autonomous car talk here.
I wish I had grown up somewhere less car-centric. I moved to NYC specifically so that I wouldn't have to rely on cars, and I quite like the public transportation here. When I've gone back to the rural New Hampshire town I grew up in, public transportation doesn't exist and getting anywhere except my immediate neighbor's houses takes a long time via bike, and I remember why I grew up with cars.
Edit to add: America is also heavily invested in cars and the culture that follows. The train system throughout the country has been in a terrible state for a looooooong time, and there's not much hope of it ever getting better due to the fact that we're so invested in cars. Some cities and towns have better public transportation support, but most don't. Some cities and towns have better support for bicycles and pedestrians, but most don't. There are occasional pushes to change things, but there's always heavy resistance due to just how deep into cars we are, and just how many people and local governments would truly need to get on the same page to make meaningful change.
A similar thing happened in Sydney, Australia, the city had one of the largest tram systems in the world, the director of the motor trade authority was elected into government and made sure that all the tracks were literally tared over, they are still under the roads. The excuse used was that the network was over congested / too popular, and cars would solve the problem, guess what? Sydney is in the middle of putting the tram network back in to solve the car problem :) Melbourne, Australia was spared because it built it's network in the 40's and 50's and it was difficult to persuade the working class that putting in such a newly built system was a good idea. People literally move to Melbourne because of the convenience they provide.
If you're interested Bikes vs Cars (http://www.bikes-vs-cars.com/) is an awesome documentary, it shows that LA even had things called "Bike Highways" at one stage. You will see how people were so negatively influenced by big business lobbying, and from memory outlines why New York was somewhat spared from the fate.
Sounds like you're being told the same stories again either way.
The reason I ask is there are plenty of other countries in the world where cars just aren't that important, let's take Netherlands for example. If you have automatic cars, society here is not just going to be that excited AFAIK. Public transport here is great and most people cycle everywhere, because it's fun, easy and good exercise. Not to mention a lot of people are employed as drivers.
Same for many Asian countries where population density is high, people just don't have the money/room for cars. Scooters are the way to go because of traffic congestion.
Besides, don't people enjoy driving? I don't own a car but when I get behind the wheel, it's a lot of fun. Will people really be able to handle the car doing the speed limit?
I understand technologically it's pretty interesting, but we've had commercial airliners that fly themselves (mostly) for a long time, same for ships and drones and we don't marvel over those things all the time, though I agree they are great innovations.
So apart from the tech what is the actual excitement about?
- Concern for those who will lose their jobs.
- Concern for others safety.
- Privacy concerns.
- Excitement about the safety benefits.
- Economic opportunity.
- Fundraising hype.
- All of the above?
As a Silicon Valley outsider sometimes I read HN and it feels like some context is missing. Sure it's going to change industries, but is this really good progress, necessary progress, or just the next thing we're told we need? I mean can a self-driving car really replace a delivery person yet, a person who can do things like leave packages with a neighbor and build relationships, trust etc?
Sorry if this is a little off-topic, but I'm genuinely curious because it's hard to understand, to me as an outsider, it really looks like some kind of ride-sharing turf war hype battle more than anything else?
I dare to say it, but it's the same for machine learning, a lot of it is fascinating, interesting, exiting tech, but how many product recommendations does one need? How good do my friend recommendations have to be? How smart does Siri need to be? Will a patient really feel better without being treated by a human? Are we really going to trust these things handling nuclear warheads?
Maybe I live a strange life and have unusual views, but I just don't really see the need most of these things when so many problems could be solved using other means. Using this stuff to help people is great, but how much of this effort is actually being put towards that end?
If I'm a little naive, apologies. I'm not having a go but these are just honest questions I often find myself asking when reading HN lately. Agreed this might not be the place to ask but I'm prepared to wear the down votes :)