News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Could These Intersections Make Us Safer? (2013) by phkahler on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @09:46AM (#12539419)
I've spent some time thinking about roadways, and I've decided the problem starts at a much higher level. When I'm traveling down the road it should be easy to get to the place I want to get, or onto another road that I need to get on. It seems the thing closest to me though is the LAST thing I want - a lane for going the opposite direction. If I'm going west, I don't want to go east, yet a few feet away is a lane going east. If I want to turn south, I'm going to have to cross that lane going east. This is why we have intersections and accidents.

If you look at the EPA fuel economy standards, they run cars on several different cycles representing different driving conditions. In particular there is a highway cycle and an urban cycle. When I worked in EVs I was stunned to find that the average speed on the urban cycle is a hair short of 20mph. You'd think with typical speed limits of 45mph it would be much higher, but with all the stopping and going you waste a lot of time and fuel. The main reason hybrid cars get better mileage is the recovery of kinetic energy when stopping. It seems we're demanding cars make up for deficiencies in roadway design, but that only helps with fuel, no peoples time.

So If we made a lot of one-way roads with the right nested structure (I'm playing with long ovals) we could eliminate a lot of intersections where lanes cross. Your travel distance might be 10 percent longer, but your time on the road could be reduced significantly. You'd also have to learn a slightly different route for going somewhere and coming home. Another aspect of reducing travel time is that with cars on the road for half the time, you'll have half as many cars on the road at any given time and that means you can put down half the pavement. Getting it right would be a huge win all around.

Re:Could These Intersections Make Us Safer? (2013) by bryanlarsen on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @09:53AM (#12539472)
"huge win all around"

Sure, if you're designing a cars-only freeway. Once you add pedestrians, one way streets dramatically increase the fatality rate. Cars are going faster (dramatically increasing the risk of fatality), and are generally only looking in one direction, so don't see pedestrians coming from the other direction.

Re:Could These Intersections Make Us Safer? (2013) by phkahler on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @02:21PM (#12541903)
>> Once you add pedestrians, one way streets dramatically increase the fatality rate.

The key is not to put the pedestrian paths next to the roads. That's similar to putting the opposing traffic right next to the road.

Imagine a suburban neighborhood where the sidewalks run through the back yards instead of out front by the road. You have branching walkways that are the inverse of the branching roadways. Now start to design high density cities along similar lines, where pedestrian areas connect high-density buildings in a sort of fractal pattern with roadways around the outside (one way of course) and branching in between the fractal stuff. You can add pedestrian bridges in key places if desired.

I don't think a large 2-d area with high fractal dimension makes the most sense, it should be more like a long strip with bulbs off the sides. These are then surrounded by an oval roadway with intruding branches. You lay multiple ovals next to each other and have a larger oval connecting them all at the ends - a perpendicular oval. Something like that.

If you think about how blood circulates in the body, it's a hierarchy of different sized arteries and veins. You can get from any capillary to any other by just going around the system one time. Now imagine you put a loop at each level of the hierarchy so you don't need to go all the way to the top level - long trip. If your try to lay that out flat there will be some intersections, and you may still have things close together that are topologically farther apart - it's when you start making those short connections that you create intersections and congestion which starts to destroy the efficiency.

I'd also prefer a fractal-like city with green space mixed in, so perhaps those ovals should not be side-by-side, but sprawling. How about all buildings are high density (so public transit makes sense) but the overall density is more like the burbs? Clusters of towers in the woods or open areas.